What do you think?
Rate this book
Lake Manawa Summers #1
Making Waves
When spunky Marguerite Westing discovers that her family will summer at Lake Manawa in 1895, she couldn't be more thrilled. It is the perfect way to escape her agonizingly boring suitor, Roger Gordon. It's also where she stumbles upon two new sailing, and sailing instructor Trip Andrews. But this summer of fun turns to turmoil as her father's gambling problems threaten to ruin the family forever. Will free-spirited Marguerite marry Roger to save her father's name and fortune? Or will she follow her heart--even if it means abandoning the family she loves?
Author Lorna Seilstad's fresh and entertaining voice will whisk readers away to a breezy lakeside summer holiday. Full of sharp wit and blossoming romance, Making Waves is the first book in the LAKE MANAWA SUMMERS series.
Author Lorna Seilstad's fresh and entertaining voice will whisk readers away to a breezy lakeside summer holiday. Full of sharp wit and blossoming romance, Making Waves is the first book in the LAKE MANAWA SUMMERS series.
368 pages, Paperback
First published September 1, 2010
122 people are currently reading
3075 people want to read
About the author
Lorna Seilstad
20 books243 followersFor as long as I can remember, I loved writing. I even dreamed in plots. I also grew up attending antique auctions nearly every weekend, so history was as much a part of my life as chores on our farm in Iowa, reading books, and playing with Barbies.
So, writing historical romances fit perfectly. Times may change, the style of clothes, the way we speak, but the common threads that unite us remain the same. Couples fall in love. Injustices
happen. We fight for what we believe in. We struggle. We endure. We grow.
After graduating from York College in York, Nebraska with an A.A. and then receiving a B.S.Ed. from Lubbock Christian University, I met and married the love of my life, David. God had
written our love story, and I knew from the moment we met that he was the one. It was not love at first sight by any means, but I was so sure he was "it" that I wrote that I'd met the man I would marry in my diary. We pledged our hearts to one another two and half years later.
I taught high school English until my oldest child was born. After that I began my career as a professional wiper. I wiped noses, counter tops, tiny tushes, tears, and scraped knees.
Deciding that my children were now older and less in need of my constant supervision, I started pursuing my first love again --writing. After joining American Christian Fiction Writers, I found a wonderful critique group and began studying the craft of writing.
David and I have three children ages 18, 16, and 11. We also work in youth ministry and teach youth and adult Bible classes.
Thank you so much for stopping by, friend!
So, writing historical romances fit perfectly. Times may change, the style of clothes, the way we speak, but the common threads that unite us remain the same. Couples fall in love. Injustices
happen. We fight for what we believe in. We struggle. We endure. We grow.
After graduating from York College in York, Nebraska with an A.A. and then receiving a B.S.Ed. from Lubbock Christian University, I met and married the love of my life, David. God had
written our love story, and I knew from the moment we met that he was the one. It was not love at first sight by any means, but I was so sure he was "it" that I wrote that I'd met the man I would marry in my diary. We pledged our hearts to one another two and half years later.
I taught high school English until my oldest child was born. After that I began my career as a professional wiper. I wiped noses, counter tops, tiny tushes, tears, and scraped knees.
Deciding that my children were now older and less in need of my constant supervision, I started pursuing my first love again --writing. After joining American Christian Fiction Writers, I found a wonderful critique group and began studying the craft of writing.
David and I have three children ages 18, 16, and 11. We also work in youth ministry and teach youth and adult Bible classes.
Thank you so much for stopping by, friend!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 313 reviews
August 22, 2014
Very late to review, but this was one of my favourite summer books!
This book is all about...
Boats!
Water!
Camping!
Sailing!
Fun!
Welcome to Lake Manawa!
Marguerite Westing and her family are vacationing in Lake Manawa, and feisty, vivacious Marguerite sees this as an opportunity to escape her boring suitor and have some fun. After all, who'd want a man as boring as a doorknob, who always orders vanilla ice cream and doesn't even like swimming? Bleh. Marguerite is bored to tears and looking for some excitement.
This and the handsome, sexy sailor that comes with it might just prove to be the right distraction!
Ha! Could you imagine? I totally want to board this!
Just kidding though, Lake Manawa's resort sailboats in 1895 were a little bit tamer...probably more along the lines of this:
But the good-looking sailor does come with the lessons! Only, he's a bit of a blockhead...
I'm all about beaches, boats, sailing and sunshine, so this novel came across as very refreshing and fun for me. It was just the perfect fluffy summer read! If Marguerite's interest had been in, say, bicycling instead of sailing, I probably wouldn't have enjoyed it as much, giving all the descriptions there was. But as it was, I found it really interesting. Marge was a wonderful heroine!! She was bubbly, outspoken, unconventional and just plain fun. I very much look forward to reading the second book of this series!
See you soon, Lake Manawa!
This book is all about...
Boats!
Water!
Camping!
Sailing!
Fun!
Welcome to Lake Manawa!
Marguerite Westing and her family are vacationing in Lake Manawa, and feisty, vivacious Marguerite sees this as an opportunity to escape her boring suitor and have some fun. After all, who'd want a man as boring as a doorknob, who always orders vanilla ice cream and doesn't even like swimming? Bleh. Marguerite is bored to tears and looking for some excitement.
This and the handsome, sexy sailor that comes with it might just prove to be the right distraction!
Ha! Could you imagine? I totally want to board this!
Just kidding though, Lake Manawa's resort sailboats in 1895 were a little bit tamer...probably more along the lines of this:
But the good-looking sailor does come with the lessons! Only, he's a bit of a blockhead...
I'm all about beaches, boats, sailing and sunshine, so this novel came across as very refreshing and fun for me. It was just the perfect fluffy summer read! If Marguerite's interest had been in, say, bicycling instead of sailing, I probably wouldn't have enjoyed it as much, giving all the descriptions there was. But as it was, I found it really interesting. Marge was a wonderful heroine!! She was bubbly, outspoken, unconventional and just plain fun. I very much look forward to reading the second book of this series!
See you soon, Lake Manawa!
June 26, 2017
I needed a lighthearted, funny, sweet read, and this lovely debut novel was the perfect fit. I enjoyed how the story was set during a true piece of history at Lake Manawa, too. I was happy to discover this author, because her style of writing reminded me, very much, of Jen Turano, which I love. I would recommend this book to people who enjoy reading romantic comedy type stories and to those who are looking for a Christian Fiction read that is more than just a "clean" read. This story had a wonderful spiritual theme to it that focused on the importance of being honest and true and learning to trust God with our lives. I am looking forward to finishing this series; it seems perfect for summer time reading.
February 18, 2024
What a delightful story indeed! Such a refreshing read with a pretty much loving family although the mother was utterly wearisome to be polite. Set in 1895 it was a lovely escape type tale. Spiritual elements in a wholesome read; a central theme was that telling lies, no matter how small or seemingly unimportant, still causes trouble with consequences one way or another. I liked how the spunky and fun main character Marguerite learned this to be oh so true even though being truthful can be difficult too. The old tent meetings that held the evangelistic services were a common part of the summer vacationing/resort area goer's experience for beach/lake getaways. This was a true pleasure read as I could certainly recommend it for anyone really; to enjoy a more light hearted but yet still containing faith aspects. My first for this author but definitely not the last as she passes my "one chance try".
December 31, 2010
I could go all year, and never read a book this good. The story center on Marguerite Westing and her family, as they spend the summer at beautiful Lake Manawa.
I LOVED this book, and the characters were charming and intriguing while still being real and rich. Mrs. Seilstad made quit a splash with this first novel. Her writing style made this book co me to life with all the details about sailing and Lake Manawa. I felt as if I could feel the warm breeze running through my hair as I sat along with Marguerite on that first boat trip; I could hear the sounds of the midway and picture the pigpen gambling hall as if it was right in front of me. And don't even get me started on Trip Andrews. Be still my beating heart. Trip was handsome, complex and an oh-so-strong man of God. He was truly swoon worthy, unlike his advisory, the weaselly Roger Gordon. I liked that, even at the end, you still couldn't tell who Marguerite would choose. There were plenty of twists and turns to keep the book moving, though I found more often than not, that I wanted to savor each page.
I loved this book and I would recommend it to anybody who loves a great historical romance, or sail boats. LOL ;)
I LOVED this book, and the characters were charming and intriguing while still being real and rich. Mrs. Seilstad made quit a splash with this first novel. Her writing style made this book co me to life with all the details about sailing and Lake Manawa. I felt as if I could feel the warm breeze running through my hair as I sat along with Marguerite on that first boat trip; I could hear the sounds of the midway and picture the pigpen gambling hall as if it was right in front of me. And don't even get me started on Trip Andrews. Be still my beating heart. Trip was handsome, complex and an oh-so-strong man of God. He was truly swoon worthy, unlike his advisory, the weaselly Roger Gordon. I liked that, even at the end, you still couldn't tell who Marguerite would choose. There were plenty of twists and turns to keep the book moving, though I found more often than not, that I wanted to savor each page.
I loved this book and I would recommend it to anybody who loves a great historical romance, or sail boats. LOL ;)
February 11, 2011
This was a fun read with a charming, unique setting. Flawed yet feisty Marguerite was a heroine to cheer for, and Trip, the handsome sailing instructor was dreamy in the extreme. Great job, Lorna!
July 19, 2013
I only picked up Making Waves because it was a Kindle freebie (still is) and I was in Washington DC for a week and the metro commute was too long to just sit.
Plot
The words that come to mind when I think about this book are disorganized and incoherent. I don't think the author had a clearly defined plot to follow because everything is jumbled up and thrown in. There are no guidelines. It's almost as if she remembers incidents and people that she wanted to talk about earlier, but instead of going back and putting them where they're supposed to be, she just throws them in where she is and leaves it.
The beginning is rather promising - I actually thought it might have something to it - but after the first chapter, Marguerite falls into the lake and nothing is promising again.
Mrs. Seilstad seems to be more interested in filling us in on minute details about sailing, the very bottom of the barrel of Marguerite's closet, anything and everything about Trip Andrews, ice cream in its various states of representation and other as illogical and unneeded items than she is about clearly developing her characters and defining her plot to make sense.
Towards the end, I was flipping through pages because there were so many twists and turns that could have been expediently placed throughout the book, but were shoved to the end because we had to wade through stagnant and over-detailed chapters about the blossoming, failing, re-blossoming, failing, blossoming again, failing and eventually blossoming for good relationship between Trip and Marguerite (even though the village idiot's idiot could have figured out by reading the back cover that they were going to end up madly in love, despite their "anger at each other"). It's waterlogged with such repetitiveness that you begin to get lost and wonder if perhaps you're reading the same few pages over and over. They have a sailing lesson, Trip gets mad because Marguerite lies to him, they make up at a dance and the whole vicious cycle begins again. The real plot of the book is brought in too late to do anyone any good.
God is given backstage to Marguerite and Trip. There's the usual tacky summer revival where the heroine gets choky over her sins and meets the hero afterwards (neat, elegant and worn-out way for you to discover that the man you could hardly tell was a Christian, is in fact born-again and, supposedly, very adamant about it).
Marguerite, though her conversations with the Lord are amusing, used God as a crutch and deliberately misinterprets Scripture to fit her spoiled, "headstrong" agendas. Very often, we find her asking God to forgive her for something she's about to do and justifying things with Him to serve her purposes.
And we're supposed to believe that she's really enjoying a deep relationship with God?
It's about as deep as Trip's and Trip's is nothing to write home about either.
The man actually uses the verse in Romans (Greet each other with a holy kiss) as an excuse to give Marguerite one. And Marguerite, good Christian girl that she is, doesn't call him out on his error, but instead says she likes his "interpretation" and then wonders - of all things - what he would do with the Song of Solomon!
Is this supposed to be Christian? Because it's not even funny.
Not only that, but there are other discrepancies as well. Margeurite repeatedly kisses Trip "for luck" and only on the last one does she say "I don't believe in luck. I believe in God."
As if we're supposed to believe it now.
Roger (the sadistically evil villain and the man Marguerite is forced to engage herself to) repeatedly announces that Marguerite "belongs to him" but it's not until the last few pages that Trip lamely speaks up and says "she isn't yours. She belongs to God."
A little late to the party, aren't you buddy?
I could go on and on, but it would basically boil down to transcribing the book for you here.
Sadly, there are moments where true inspiration in the plot could have peeked out, but the author simply doesn't know how to handle them. Flimsy excuses are given to support circumstances that could create sympathy with the characters or suspense in the plot and nothing is fleshed out satisfactorily. The last few chapters are pell-mell with action running downhill and everything coming to a head so quickly and illogically that the reader is left in the dust.
I've read elsewhere that there are glaring errors in the historical content as well. For example, the driving point of the first half of the book is that it's improper for women to go sailing, when, in fact it was an encouraged summer activity for proper young ladies.
Characters
Marguerite Westing - Heroine
Marguerite Westing is a flighty, manipulative, petty, childish young lady who behaves so badly that you wish she would be stuck marrying that "cruel" and "vicious" tyrant of a Roger because he's the only guy in the book who could give her what she deserves.
Of course she's the most beautiful creature ever to touch a foot on this hallowed earth, but aside from that, there's really nothing behind it except a lying, conniving, oh-so-helpless heroine who rarely thinks of anyone but herself.
"Trip" Phillip Sutton Andrews III - Hero
You say white, I say black. You say chocolate, I say vanilla. You say right, I say wrong. You say dog, I say cat. You say Phillip Sutton Andrews III, I say, most naturally, dimples.
It's the first thing that comes to mind with a name like that, especially after you've been greeted with those roguish craters every time you meet him.
Honestly, I have never known a man so more defined by a physical trait except perhaps for Santa Claus. In the good times, in the bad, in the rocky places, in the smooth, in the drowning and the saving, you can always count on them to come through. And Marguerite informing the reader that she longs to touch them. Or that she notices them.
Other than that, there's not much to the man aside from his muscular arms, his broad chest, his gold-flecked hazel eyes, his sun-kissed brown hair and how good he looks in a striped, Union suit bathing costume.
He's the typical all-perfect hero-man who is sensitive and courteous, but carries a hurt deep inside that the heroine (in this case our hapless, careless Mar-Guer-Ite) can't help but stir up.
Apparently she sees something in him that I missed.
Roger Gordon - Villain
The only problem with Roger is that he's only really a villain in the last, oh, four chapters. Other than that, he's just boring and mysteriously evil.
Marguerite doesn't like him because he's dull. And not handsome. And not Trip. And she treats him rather cruelly though it's only meant to come off as headstrong.
Roger IS dull, but at least he's human. And I don't blame him a bit for wanting to bring Marguerite down. She could use it.
Of course, since he's the villain, you're supposed to agree with the persecuted heroine that just because he isn't handsome, has a caterpillar mustache and round shoulders, doesn't let her order what she wants at a restaurant, frowns upon her wild and childish caprices, and attempts to make her become a respectable member of society he is woefully evil and thus undeserving to be treated in a kind and courteous manner.
In fact, it's all this that makes his descent into villain-hood all the more laughably unbelievable. An intelligent man like Roger, with his steely business mind, would think of much better evil plots than the bumbling attempts he and his henchman make at the end of this wreck and ruin to destroy Marguerite's family and force her to marry him (though, by the end, I am still wondering why he wouldn't hand her over to Trip with a "good riddance" and a sigh of relief anyway).
I don't like Roger, but I can't imagine why even he would go through all this trouble just because he wants to "own" Marguerite. She's really not worth it and it's a weak reason to go through such illegal and highly dangerous pains to get her.
Mark Westing - Heroine's brother
Mark isn't bad. He has his flaws and he's often too conveniently tucked away so that Marguerite and Trip can be alone together, but he's actually one of the better attempts at characterization that this author makes.
He's sweet and caring and willing to put his life on the line for the people he loves. At the end, we're supposed to have the impression that Marguerite is the loyal, caring one who will do anything to save her family, but really, it's Mark who steals that role - and with good reason.
He actually cares.
Mr. and Mrs. Westing - Heroine's parents
They're both pretty weak as characters go. Mrs. Westing is the typical doting mother who only wants her daughter to marry into wealth and prestige. Aside from her pushiness at getting Marguerite to be civil to Roger and knack for showing up at just the right moment to choose the ugliest dress in her daughter's closet for her to wear, she's pretty much relegated to the background and is quite forgettable. (One point I'd like to bring up here: why is it that the pushy mothers (and ect.) always choose the frocks that make their daughters look the worst when they go out with the man the mother wants them to marry, but when the girl is meeting the man they really love, they always get to choose the dress they like best and the mother is never around?)
Mr. Westing is supposed to be this wonderful man whom Marguerite adores, but somewhere in the tussle this book represents, he never gets around to revealing that side of his character. What we get is a soppy weakling who sinks his family into ruin and who deserves neither his daughter's sympathy (such as it is) or loyalty.
He could have added a lot to the book if not for his woeful underdevelopment.
Lily - Heroine's personal maid
Poor Lily. Not only is she this petty creature's maid, she also has to put up with all her complaining and whining over Roger and her fantasizing over Trip and her extremely misguided beliefs about what God's word is actually saying to her.
This much-to-be-pitied girl handles the situation well, though she's often pushed to the wayside as well.
The host of minor and secondary characters
This bunch is a motley crew including assorted servants, childhood friends, sisters and Trip's crew.
Most of them aren't bad, but since they're only pulled out when needed, it's hard to give them any sort of accurate review. Mary, Laura and Alice are treated with especial carelessness.
Likes
Surprisingly, there actually are a few.
- The beginning of this book is great. It's exactly what an author wants to get their reader hooked on a book. It's funny, clever, and defines character traits very effortlessly.
- Ok, so Marguerite has some pretty funny thoughts and there is some good repartee hidden in and around the clunky plot.
- The research behind Lake Manawa is detailed and the Mrs. Seilstad does have a flair for knowing the name brands floating around (though she does end up using them in a rather liberal and choppy manner). It's little details like that make the book more believable.
Dislikes
I'll try to keep this short because I've already outlined most of them.
- I have a real peeve with obvious discrepancies in language and action. For instance, no decent, self-respecting man like Trip would even try to touch a girl the way it's accepted now and he touches Marguerite. It just wasn't done. I know it's technically "romantic" but only a boy of ill-repute or shady upbringing would dare to act in such a manner.
Roger isn't much better, but at least he's engaged to the girl.
- The modern figures of speech tossed around without an ear for the period in which they're placed. "Calling the shots", "daddy", "guys" "I blew it" - those are all too modern to flow with the story line and thus only detract from it. There are hundreds of more examples, but I only had time to go through a few pages.
- The use of God to basically justify situations. God wasn't really the focus of any of these people's lives and He was only brought in to make the book "Christian". It's really not worthy of that genre in any way, shape, or form since God is pretty much ignored and manipulated anyway.
Plot
The words that come to mind when I think about this book are disorganized and incoherent. I don't think the author had a clearly defined plot to follow because everything is jumbled up and thrown in. There are no guidelines. It's almost as if she remembers incidents and people that she wanted to talk about earlier, but instead of going back and putting them where they're supposed to be, she just throws them in where she is and leaves it.
The beginning is rather promising - I actually thought it might have something to it - but after the first chapter, Marguerite falls into the lake and nothing is promising again.
Mrs. Seilstad seems to be more interested in filling us in on minute details about sailing, the very bottom of the barrel of Marguerite's closet, anything and everything about Trip Andrews, ice cream in its various states of representation and other as illogical and unneeded items than she is about clearly developing her characters and defining her plot to make sense.
Towards the end, I was flipping through pages because there were so many twists and turns that could have been expediently placed throughout the book, but were shoved to the end because we had to wade through stagnant and over-detailed chapters about the blossoming, failing, re-blossoming, failing, blossoming again, failing and eventually blossoming for good relationship between Trip and Marguerite (even though the village idiot's idiot could have figured out by reading the back cover that they were going to end up madly in love, despite their "anger at each other"). It's waterlogged with such repetitiveness that you begin to get lost and wonder if perhaps you're reading the same few pages over and over. They have a sailing lesson, Trip gets mad because Marguerite lies to him, they make up at a dance and the whole vicious cycle begins again. The real plot of the book is brought in too late to do anyone any good.
God is given backstage to Marguerite and Trip. There's the usual tacky summer revival where the heroine gets choky over her sins and meets the hero afterwards (neat, elegant and worn-out way for you to discover that the man you could hardly tell was a Christian, is in fact born-again and, supposedly, very adamant about it).
Marguerite, though her conversations with the Lord are amusing, used God as a crutch and deliberately misinterprets Scripture to fit her spoiled, "headstrong" agendas. Very often, we find her asking God to forgive her for something she's about to do and justifying things with Him to serve her purposes.
And we're supposed to believe that she's really enjoying a deep relationship with God?
It's about as deep as Trip's and Trip's is nothing to write home about either.
The man actually uses the verse in Romans (Greet each other with a holy kiss) as an excuse to give Marguerite one. And Marguerite, good Christian girl that she is, doesn't call him out on his error, but instead says she likes his "interpretation" and then wonders - of all things - what he would do with the Song of Solomon!
Is this supposed to be Christian? Because it's not even funny.
Not only that, but there are other discrepancies as well. Margeurite repeatedly kisses Trip "for luck" and only on the last one does she say "I don't believe in luck. I believe in God."
As if we're supposed to believe it now.
Roger (the sadistically evil villain and the man Marguerite is forced to engage herself to) repeatedly announces that Marguerite "belongs to him" but it's not until the last few pages that Trip lamely speaks up and says "she isn't yours. She belongs to God."
A little late to the party, aren't you buddy?
I could go on and on, but it would basically boil down to transcribing the book for you here.
Sadly, there are moments where true inspiration in the plot could have peeked out, but the author simply doesn't know how to handle them. Flimsy excuses are given to support circumstances that could create sympathy with the characters or suspense in the plot and nothing is fleshed out satisfactorily. The last few chapters are pell-mell with action running downhill and everything coming to a head so quickly and illogically that the reader is left in the dust.
I've read elsewhere that there are glaring errors in the historical content as well. For example, the driving point of the first half of the book is that it's improper for women to go sailing, when, in fact it was an encouraged summer activity for proper young ladies.
Characters
Marguerite Westing - Heroine
Marguerite Westing is a flighty, manipulative, petty, childish young lady who behaves so badly that you wish she would be stuck marrying that "cruel" and "vicious" tyrant of a Roger because he's the only guy in the book who could give her what she deserves.
Of course she's the most beautiful creature ever to touch a foot on this hallowed earth, but aside from that, there's really nothing behind it except a lying, conniving, oh-so-helpless heroine who rarely thinks of anyone but herself.
"Trip" Phillip Sutton Andrews III - Hero
You say white, I say black. You say chocolate, I say vanilla. You say right, I say wrong. You say dog, I say cat. You say Phillip Sutton Andrews III, I say, most naturally, dimples.
It's the first thing that comes to mind with a name like that, especially after you've been greeted with those roguish craters every time you meet him.
Honestly, I have never known a man so more defined by a physical trait except perhaps for Santa Claus. In the good times, in the bad, in the rocky places, in the smooth, in the drowning and the saving, you can always count on them to come through. And Marguerite informing the reader that she longs to touch them. Or that she notices them.
Other than that, there's not much to the man aside from his muscular arms, his broad chest, his gold-flecked hazel eyes, his sun-kissed brown hair and how good he looks in a striped, Union suit bathing costume.
He's the typical all-perfect hero-man who is sensitive and courteous, but carries a hurt deep inside that the heroine (in this case our hapless, careless Mar-Guer-Ite) can't help but stir up.
Apparently she sees something in him that I missed.
Roger Gordon - Villain
The only problem with Roger is that he's only really a villain in the last, oh, four chapters. Other than that, he's just boring and mysteriously evil.
Marguerite doesn't like him because he's dull. And not handsome. And not Trip. And she treats him rather cruelly though it's only meant to come off as headstrong.
Roger IS dull, but at least he's human. And I don't blame him a bit for wanting to bring Marguerite down. She could use it.
Of course, since he's the villain, you're supposed to agree with the persecuted heroine that just because he isn't handsome, has a caterpillar mustache and round shoulders, doesn't let her order what she wants at a restaurant, frowns upon her wild and childish caprices, and attempts to make her become a respectable member of society he is woefully evil and thus undeserving to be treated in a kind and courteous manner.
In fact, it's all this that makes his descent into villain-hood all the more laughably unbelievable. An intelligent man like Roger, with his steely business mind, would think of much better evil plots than the bumbling attempts he and his henchman make at the end of this wreck and ruin to destroy Marguerite's family and force her to marry him (though, by the end, I am still wondering why he wouldn't hand her over to Trip with a "good riddance" and a sigh of relief anyway).
I don't like Roger, but I can't imagine why even he would go through all this trouble just because he wants to "own" Marguerite. She's really not worth it and it's a weak reason to go through such illegal and highly dangerous pains to get her.
Mark Westing - Heroine's brother
Mark isn't bad. He has his flaws and he's often too conveniently tucked away so that Marguerite and Trip can be alone together, but he's actually one of the better attempts at characterization that this author makes.
He's sweet and caring and willing to put his life on the line for the people he loves. At the end, we're supposed to have the impression that Marguerite is the loyal, caring one who will do anything to save her family, but really, it's Mark who steals that role - and with good reason.
He actually cares.
Mr. and Mrs. Westing - Heroine's parents
They're both pretty weak as characters go. Mrs. Westing is the typical doting mother who only wants her daughter to marry into wealth and prestige. Aside from her pushiness at getting Marguerite to be civil to Roger and knack for showing up at just the right moment to choose the ugliest dress in her daughter's closet for her to wear, she's pretty much relegated to the background and is quite forgettable. (One point I'd like to bring up here: why is it that the pushy mothers (and ect.) always choose the frocks that make their daughters look the worst when they go out with the man the mother wants them to marry, but when the girl is meeting the man they really love, they always get to choose the dress they like best and the mother is never around?)
Mr. Westing is supposed to be this wonderful man whom Marguerite adores, but somewhere in the tussle this book represents, he never gets around to revealing that side of his character. What we get is a soppy weakling who sinks his family into ruin and who deserves neither his daughter's sympathy (such as it is) or loyalty.
He could have added a lot to the book if not for his woeful underdevelopment.
Lily - Heroine's personal maid
Poor Lily. Not only is she this petty creature's maid, she also has to put up with all her complaining and whining over Roger and her fantasizing over Trip and her extremely misguided beliefs about what God's word is actually saying to her.
This much-to-be-pitied girl handles the situation well, though she's often pushed to the wayside as well.
The host of minor and secondary characters
This bunch is a motley crew including assorted servants, childhood friends, sisters and Trip's crew.
Most of them aren't bad, but since they're only pulled out when needed, it's hard to give them any sort of accurate review. Mary, Laura and Alice are treated with especial carelessness.
Likes
Surprisingly, there actually are a few.
- The beginning of this book is great. It's exactly what an author wants to get their reader hooked on a book. It's funny, clever, and defines character traits very effortlessly.
- Ok, so Marguerite has some pretty funny thoughts and there is some good repartee hidden in and around the clunky plot.
- The research behind Lake Manawa is detailed and the Mrs. Seilstad does have a flair for knowing the name brands floating around (though she does end up using them in a rather liberal and choppy manner). It's little details like that make the book more believable.
Dislikes
I'll try to keep this short because I've already outlined most of them.
- I have a real peeve with obvious discrepancies in language and action. For instance, no decent, self-respecting man like Trip would even try to touch a girl the way it's accepted now and he touches Marguerite. It just wasn't done. I know it's technically "romantic" but only a boy of ill-repute or shady upbringing would dare to act in such a manner.
Roger isn't much better, but at least he's engaged to the girl.
- The modern figures of speech tossed around without an ear for the period in which they're placed. "Calling the shots", "daddy", "guys" "I blew it" - those are all too modern to flow with the story line and thus only detract from it. There are hundreds of more examples, but I only had time to go through a few pages.
- The use of God to basically justify situations. God wasn't really the focus of any of these people's lives and He was only brought in to make the book "Christian". It's really not worthy of that genre in any way, shape, or form since God is pretty much ignored and manipulated anyway.
November 12, 2023
This was such a great read! Light, funny and romantic with a touch of adventure! I enjoyed all the characters (except the one you're not supposed to) and especially loved Marguerite's vivacious nature and thoroughly enjoyed seeing how much Trip loved and embraced it. I loved the unique setting, camping on the shores of Lake Manawa, and learning about the different aspects of sailing. Lastly I really liked the central theme of truth versus lies and how no matter what kind of lie we tell, it affects and hurts someone, mostly ourselves. A delightful and cute read, can't wait to read the sequel which is also sitting on my shelf!
April 10, 2023
Marguerite Westing is what you'd call unconventional. Sewing circles bore her, the stars call to her, and she and her mother have what could be termed a tempestuous relationship. When her family camps at Lake Manawa for the summer, Marguerite knows from the minute she sees the lake that she's in love--and as time passes, love for a certain sailing instructor flourishes, as well.
Only, there's a problem, because a certain caterpillar-mustached bore wishes he was the recipient of that love. And he is determined to change Marguerite's mind.
Suddenly, what was to be a relaxing summer has turned into a downright hurricane.
***
PLOT
Lorna Seilstad is one of the best Christian historical fiction authors out there, and her clever plot, which is infused with rich history, illustrates her ability to transport the reader back in time. With just the right amount of romance and action, this book sails along at a steady pace. Not too fast, not too slow.
SETTING
I've never cared for Iowa's history, simply because there are other areas that call to me. But reading the Author's Note, I will admit I am intrigued, even though I've finished the book. Capturing a popular resort in it's prime, Seilstad makes the reader feel like they're sailing on the Endeavor or plummeting down the toboggan slide with the characters.
CHARACTERS
Marguerite is the type of character who could easily get on my nerves. In fact, she's a bit spoiled and petty at times. But I didn't mind, because her character arc is set in motion almost immediately, and though she learned some hard lessons the hard ways, she is an admirable character. Impulsive, but admirable in her desire to protect her family and do what's best for them, even if it lands her in an unsavory and terrible situation.
Trip is great, too. We didn't see as much of him as Marguerite, but that didn't bother me, because Seilstad wove the story in such a way that, through Marguerite's eyes, we learn plenty about this dear character with hidden pain.
The crew of secondary characters is fantastic as well. Not fantastic because they all are delightful and splendid, but fantastic because they are so well-written and portrayed. Lilly is a dear and I'd like to know her story. I kind of ship her and Harry. (Are you catching all these puns?)
The primary antagonist is well-written, as well. A nasty sot who needs to be beamed over the head with a mast, but well-rounded and believable. (The other antagonists are good to hate as well, but this one in particular is a rotten fish.)
FAITH
The primary themes are the danger of lying and the importance of honesty. Tent revivals are attended, church is contemplated and mentioned, God and the Bible are discussed, and characters learn their ways aren't always His.
VIOLENCE
This is light in the violence department. A character gets in a fight, a character is smacked upside the noggin and almost drowned, and a character is locked in a chilling place (if you read this book, you'll get the reference.)
CONTENT WARNING
Gambling is discussed quite often, and a character heavily partakes in it. (It is never, ever lauded, though, and is shown as the evil destroyer it is.) A man forces a woman to kiss him a few different times, and prostitutes are mentioned.
CONCLUSION
There are some books that cause quite a splash, and this was one of those for me. A definite re-read and re-reread, I so enjoyed the sarcasm, Marguerite fighting against unfair societal impositions on women, her protective nature, Trip's faith, and Lilly's mentoring to Marguerite. I was snickering half the time, because though this book addresses the serious topic of the dangers of gambling, there is a bevy of humor incorporated as well.
I truly enjoy this entire series. To readers of Christian historical romance, this is not a book you want to miss out on.
Only, there's a problem, because a certain caterpillar-mustached bore wishes he was the recipient of that love. And he is determined to change Marguerite's mind.
Suddenly, what was to be a relaxing summer has turned into a downright hurricane.
***
PLOT
Lorna Seilstad is one of the best Christian historical fiction authors out there, and her clever plot, which is infused with rich history, illustrates her ability to transport the reader back in time. With just the right amount of romance and action, this book sails along at a steady pace. Not too fast, not too slow.
SETTING
I've never cared for Iowa's history, simply because there are other areas that call to me. But reading the Author's Note, I will admit I am intrigued, even though I've finished the book. Capturing a popular resort in it's prime, Seilstad makes the reader feel like they're sailing on the Endeavor or plummeting down the toboggan slide with the characters.
CHARACTERS
Marguerite is the type of character who could easily get on my nerves. In fact, she's a bit spoiled and petty at times. But I didn't mind, because her character arc is set in motion almost immediately, and though she learned some hard lessons the hard ways, she is an admirable character. Impulsive, but admirable in her desire to protect her family and do what's best for them, even if it lands her in an unsavory and terrible situation.
Trip is great, too. We didn't see as much of him as Marguerite, but that didn't bother me, because Seilstad wove the story in such a way that, through Marguerite's eyes, we learn plenty about this dear character with hidden pain.
The crew of secondary characters is fantastic as well. Not fantastic because they all are delightful and splendid, but fantastic because they are so well-written and portrayed. Lilly is a dear and I'd like to know her story. I kind of ship her and Harry. (Are you catching all these puns?)
The primary antagonist is well-written, as well. A nasty sot who needs to be beamed over the head with a mast, but well-rounded and believable. (The other antagonists are good to hate as well, but this one in particular is a rotten fish.)
FAITH
The primary themes are the danger of lying and the importance of honesty. Tent revivals are attended, church is contemplated and mentioned, God and the Bible are discussed, and characters learn their ways aren't always His.
VIOLENCE
This is light in the violence department. A character gets in a fight, a character is smacked upside the noggin and almost drowned, and a character is locked in a chilling place (if you read this book, you'll get the reference.)
CONTENT WARNING
Gambling is discussed quite often, and a character heavily partakes in it. (It is never, ever lauded, though, and is shown as the evil destroyer it is.) A man forces a woman to kiss him a few different times, and prostitutes are mentioned.
CONCLUSION
There are some books that cause quite a splash, and this was one of those for me. A definite re-read and re-reread, I so enjoyed the sarcasm, Marguerite fighting against unfair societal impositions on women, her protective nature, Trip's faith, and Lilly's mentoring to Marguerite. I was snickering half the time, because though this book addresses the serious topic of the dangers of gambling, there is a bevy of humor incorporated as well.
I truly enjoy this entire series. To readers of Christian historical romance, this is not a book you want to miss out on.
August 24, 2010
What an absolutely wonderful book!
With vivacious characters and a story line that draws the reader into the middle of the story world and a love that swept me away, there was not a thing that I did not totally fall in love with.
Lighthearted, with a gripping story message, I laughed and frolicked with the characters, watching them grow and expand their horizons.
Marguerite is a precocious young woman thirsty for adventure and she finds it by the bucket load, along with a fair amount of trouble! She grew so much in this story and her transformations were genuine and enlightening. The love story was warm and giving. The suspense was intriguing, going right down to the wire, until I wasn’t sure how Marguerite was going make it out!
I can’t say anything negative about this book, it is a fabulous debut in a wonderful era, (late 19th century) on a beach (I could see the waves and boats on the water and smell the island breeze). I felt the stifling heat of a distasteful engagement and couldn’t wait to be released along with Marguerite. In short: I. Cannot. Wait. For. More.
This review is my honest opinion, thanks to the publishers for my copy to review.
Available September 2010 from Revell, a division of Baker publishers.
With vivacious characters and a story line that draws the reader into the middle of the story world and a love that swept me away, there was not a thing that I did not totally fall in love with.
Lighthearted, with a gripping story message, I laughed and frolicked with the characters, watching them grow and expand their horizons.
Marguerite is a precocious young woman thirsty for adventure and she finds it by the bucket load, along with a fair amount of trouble! She grew so much in this story and her transformations were genuine and enlightening. The love story was warm and giving. The suspense was intriguing, going right down to the wire, until I wasn’t sure how Marguerite was going make it out!
I can’t say anything negative about this book, it is a fabulous debut in a wonderful era, (late 19th century) on a beach (I could see the waves and boats on the water and smell the island breeze). I felt the stifling heat of a distasteful engagement and couldn’t wait to be released along with Marguerite. In short: I. Cannot. Wait. For. More.
This review is my honest opinion, thanks to the publishers for my copy to review.
Available September 2010 from Revell, a division of Baker publishers.
July 21, 2014
This is a really cute book, a perfect read for summer. I found Marguerite's character to be infectiously charming. She certainly has a zest of life that often gets her into trouble at times, but that is also one of her most admirable qualities.
I found the first bit of the book to be a little slow; once the conflict came into the story, it picked up speed. The story is lighthearted for the most part, with a lot of humorous moments, but also delves into what it means to be truthful and the cost of loyalty. The romantic aspect was nothing surprising, but it was endearing. The "villain" of the story was more laughable than scary, but that wasn't what really drew me to the story anyway, so I didn't mind that much.
The setting was well-done. It was sort of funny that the wealthy of the time really though they were "roughing it" at Lake Manawa. I found all of the historical tidbits to really enhance the story, and I even loved the details about sailing.
Recommended if you're looking for a frothy-fun, summery read, with a lovely message as well.
I found the first bit of the book to be a little slow; once the conflict came into the story, it picked up speed. The story is lighthearted for the most part, with a lot of humorous moments, but also delves into what it means to be truthful and the cost of loyalty. The romantic aspect was nothing surprising, but it was endearing. The "villain" of the story was more laughable than scary, but that wasn't what really drew me to the story anyway, so I didn't mind that much.
The setting was well-done. It was sort of funny that the wealthy of the time really though they were "roughing it" at Lake Manawa. I found all of the historical tidbits to really enhance the story, and I even loved the details about sailing.
Recommended if you're looking for a frothy-fun, summery read, with a lovely message as well.
January 24, 2015
Oh boy this book was a good read. I really enjoyed the characters Marguriete was such a spunky, funny, good natured gal. I love the story line and how it ended. Will definatley read the next ones in this series.
May 9, 2015
Star 1 - For making me laugh
Star 2 - For a cute setting
Star 3 - For showing the lies can trip you up.
- 1 star for shallow romance
- 2 star for poorly executed faith message.
Star 2 - For a cute setting
Star 3 - For showing the lies can trip you up.
- 1 star for shallow romance
- 2 star for poorly executed faith message.
January 9, 2016
I don't think I could ever do as good of a review as my friend Anne, but I'll give it a try. I loved this book so much! It's my #1 recommendation for a (historical) summer read, as it was so good! I loved the sailing, the friendship/romance developing through Marguerite and Trip, the sweet relationship between little brother and big sister, and the simple summer activities and fun. This book was a combination of light-hearted and deep with all the issues with her family. I felt sorry for her with all she goes through with her mom, and also with her dad, as she discovers his making so many unwise decisions. The light-heartedness and summer fun was always present throughout the story, though, so reading this book is well worth it and would be great for while on summer vacation! The only thing I didn't like, and I had to take a star off for, is her ranting and immature, whining prayers. It seemed she didn't understand God at all. Other than that, it was a delightful, enjoyable read, and has made it on my favorites-must-read-again-list!
April 30, 2023
This was such a fun book! The characters are so full of life! There are quite a good bit of one liners, or the main characters getting into scrapes.
The romance was a little cheesy at times, but mostly it was super sweet and it made me smile a lot! Trip and Marguerite are definitely a couple for the ages. Also, the absolute best lines in this book are when Trip wants to give Marguerite a kiss and he compares it to "greeting one another with a holy kiss". Marguerite then says that "she likes his interpretation of scriptures" and then she blushes because she starts thinking about what he could do with the Songs of Solomon. As a married woman myself, yes, please!😍 I hope they show up married in the next books as at least side characters.
I bought a copy of this book at a library sale and I will so be keeping this on my shelf and hopefully adding to the series. Sadly I don't own the rest of them. 😕
Also, just look at how gorgeous this cover is! ⛵
The romance was a little cheesy at times, but mostly it was super sweet and it made me smile a lot! Trip and Marguerite are definitely a couple for the ages. Also, the absolute best lines in this book are when Trip wants to give Marguerite a kiss and he compares it to "greeting one another with a holy kiss". Marguerite then says that "she likes his interpretation of scriptures" and then she blushes because she starts thinking about what he could do with the Songs of Solomon. As a married woman myself, yes, please!😍 I hope they show up married in the next books as at least side characters.
I bought a copy of this book at a library sale and I will so be keeping this on my shelf and hopefully adding to the series. Sadly I don't own the rest of them. 😕
Also, just look at how gorgeous this cover is! ⛵
September 17, 2010
Making Waves is a transporting read. I felt like I was AT the lake with Marguerite. (Now I want a vacation.) ;) There is a sweet, yet exciting theme in this book with the characters and setting. Marguerite definitely makes waves wherever she goes, and I like that about her. Her stubbornness sometimes gets her into trouble, but by the end of the book she is managing that pretty well. The hint of danger to the book also intrigued me and I thought the end especially was fast-paced while not being scary. I kind of wish she had ended the story a little later than she did with more resolution is certain areas, but since this is a series she might address those things in the next book. I would recommend this to someone who wants to read a book that will take them away for a little while and tell them a sweet, fun story.
September 22, 2017
In a fit of positive boredom, I browsed through all the Christian fiction ebooks my library had to offer, desperate for something fun. And just happened to stumble across Making Waves. Thank you, Lord, for inspiring Lorna Seilstad to write! For gifting her with a hearty imagination, hilarious sense of humor, and the writing chops to bring a story together.
Making Waves is Lorna Seilstad's first novel, but you would never really guess it by the solidness of her storytelling. A majority of my issues with Christian fiction stems from its preaching to the choir, but Marguerite's faith felt natural, an extension of herself, probably because she spoke to God like you would speak to a friend. In that instance, the authoress reminds me a little of Stephen Bly. Stuart Brannon, Bly's first character, spent a goodly portion of his life conversing with God in a way that said the Lord was standing right next to him. Marguerite's relationship with Christ gave me the same feeling. That's what I like from my Christian fiction, and that's what Lorna Seilstad delivered.
If I were to make one mild remonstrance it's that the "villain" felt a little bit based off Cal Hockley, Rose's intended in Titanic. Abrupt mood changes, nice to mean, etc. Most people don't really swing to such extremes so it felt a bit melodramatic at times, but I loved the book so much that it really didn't matter.
One of the best things in the story was watching Marguerite realize that she couldn't lie any longer. Not to herself, not to Trip, not to Roger, and not to her family. The truth set her free in ways that lying would have never done. And God rewarded her and gave her the desires of her heart and healed her family in the bargain. The story itself is loads of fun, but it also shared a couple of important profound messages about trust and truth.
In the end Making Waves was the perfect way for me to combat boredom on a weekend. While it's wholeheartedly late Victorian, the story also delves into an area of the US that I never really experienced or even imagined. Who knew that the wealthy would go camping by Lake Manawa in order to escape the brutal heat of the summer? I learned some exciting tidbits of history and fell in love with Marguerite and Trip along the way.
Now I just have to fight back the urge to dive into the 2nd book in the series, A Great Catch. As much as I'd like to, I can't spend all my time just reading, no matter how tantalizing Lorna Seilstad makes the idea!
Making Waves is Lorna Seilstad's first novel, but you would never really guess it by the solidness of her storytelling. A majority of my issues with Christian fiction stems from its preaching to the choir, but Marguerite's faith felt natural, an extension of herself, probably because she spoke to God like you would speak to a friend. In that instance, the authoress reminds me a little of Stephen Bly. Stuart Brannon, Bly's first character, spent a goodly portion of his life conversing with God in a way that said the Lord was standing right next to him. Marguerite's relationship with Christ gave me the same feeling. That's what I like from my Christian fiction, and that's what Lorna Seilstad delivered.
If I were to make one mild remonstrance it's that the "villain" felt a little bit based off Cal Hockley, Rose's intended in Titanic. Abrupt mood changes, nice to mean, etc. Most people don't really swing to such extremes so it felt a bit melodramatic at times, but I loved the book so much that it really didn't matter.
One of the best things in the story was watching Marguerite realize that she couldn't lie any longer. Not to herself, not to Trip, not to Roger, and not to her family. The truth set her free in ways that lying would have never done. And God rewarded her and gave her the desires of her heart and healed her family in the bargain. The story itself is loads of fun, but it also shared a couple of important profound messages about trust and truth.
In the end Making Waves was the perfect way for me to combat boredom on a weekend. While it's wholeheartedly late Victorian, the story also delves into an area of the US that I never really experienced or even imagined. Who knew that the wealthy would go camping by Lake Manawa in order to escape the brutal heat of the summer? I learned some exciting tidbits of history and fell in love with Marguerite and Trip along the way.
Now I just have to fight back the urge to dive into the 2nd book in the series, A Great Catch. As much as I'd like to, I can't spend all my time just reading, no matter how tantalizing Lorna Seilstad makes the idea!
January 6, 2014
Marguerite Westing is looking forward to a summer at Lake Manawa, Iowa where all the fashionable people are gathering this summer in 1895. Her mother dreads the prospect of camping in tents but Marguerite welcomes the change for it means keeping her personal maid and friend Lilly and getting away from her persistent, boring suitor Roger Gordon. When Marguerite sets eyes on the lake, she falls in love with the water immediately. She also falls in the water and is rescued by sailor and boat maker Trip Andrews. Marguerite is drawn to the water and drawn to Trip, despite his somewhat taciturn nature. She just HAS to have sailing lessons - the only problem is, ladies don't sail. She comes up with a plan of action that will give her exactly what she wants while still maintaining a sense of propriety. So what if she has to tell some little white lies to get it? God will understand, won't He? Certainly He wants things to go Marguerite's way, right? If so, then why doesn't he make Roger go away for Roger does NOT understand Marguerite's curiosity and lively nature. Trip understands Marguerite perfectly. Trip can't help being drawn into Marguerite's orbit. They share a love of God but how can he love her when he can't stand liars? He doesn't have time to involve himself in the life of a flighty young lady. Ever since his mother left he's been working hard to live up to his stern father's expectations and that includes winning the upcoming regatta. That means no distractions! When Marguerite and Trip discover a shocking Westing family secret, they grow even closer but Trip feels the Westings need to stop lying and look to God to guide them. Marguerite is beginning to think God has another path in store for her than the one she wants and that includes sacrificing herself to save her family. How can she live a vanilla life when she's a strawberry girl?
I had a really hard time getting though this book. Right from the beginning I hated the characters. Marguerite is spoiled and immature. Her father is the cause of all her problems because he promises her the world. I'm sure I was like Marguerite when I was a teenager but that doesn't make her an appealing heroine. She sends up quick prayers for silly things like a lightning strike to hit Roger so she doesn't have to face the problem of rejecting him. It takes Trip to set her right but I didn't like him either. He's a very hard young man exactly like the father he fears and respects. He jumps to conclusions and doesn't ask questions. He improves by story's end but I wasn't too interested in him. The other characters were all stock characters: the indulgent father; the mother who wants what's best for her daughter; the annoying little brother and the villain who seeks to posses a beautiful woman like a piece of art at any cost. Snooze. The story would have been better without knowing what the villain was thinking and planning. The dialogue was terrible and didn't sound period. Marguerite is a woman ahead of her time and she has potential to be more interesting once she matures but this story makes her out to be incredibly annoying and bratty. The plot was very slow moving with too many descriptions of the art of sailing. I liked the lake setting and the interesting historical tidbits thrown in. The author's note explains what is real. I also think the story would have been better not as an Inspirational story. I skipped revival meeting passages and skimmed discussions of what God wants, etc. etc. I don't think the message was all that heavy handed and it didn't really come through in the end. I believe change has to be internal because the character recognizes something is wrong with their behavior and understands the need to change and I think this is more of what happened in this particular novel so the Inspirational bits were unnecessary. I think other people might like this book, especially Christian readers close to Marguerite's age. It just wasn't my cup of tea.
I had a really hard time getting though this book. Right from the beginning I hated the characters. Marguerite is spoiled and immature. Her father is the cause of all her problems because he promises her the world. I'm sure I was like Marguerite when I was a teenager but that doesn't make her an appealing heroine. She sends up quick prayers for silly things like a lightning strike to hit Roger so she doesn't have to face the problem of rejecting him. It takes Trip to set her right but I didn't like him either. He's a very hard young man exactly like the father he fears and respects. He jumps to conclusions and doesn't ask questions. He improves by story's end but I wasn't too interested in him. The other characters were all stock characters: the indulgent father; the mother who wants what's best for her daughter; the annoying little brother and the villain who seeks to posses a beautiful woman like a piece of art at any cost. Snooze. The story would have been better without knowing what the villain was thinking and planning. The dialogue was terrible and didn't sound period. Marguerite is a woman ahead of her time and she has potential to be more interesting once she matures but this story makes her out to be incredibly annoying and bratty. The plot was very slow moving with too many descriptions of the art of sailing. I liked the lake setting and the interesting historical tidbits thrown in. The author's note explains what is real. I also think the story would have been better not as an Inspirational story. I skipped revival meeting passages and skimmed discussions of what God wants, etc. etc. I don't think the message was all that heavy handed and it didn't really come through in the end. I believe change has to be internal because the character recognizes something is wrong with their behavior and understands the need to change and I think this is more of what happened in this particular novel so the Inspirational bits were unnecessary. I think other people might like this book, especially Christian readers close to Marguerite's age. It just wasn't my cup of tea.
June 11, 2018
This book was the perfect beach read! The main character was quirky and endearing and the love story was sweet. For some reason I would describe this book as a 1895 Dirty Dancing but Christian Fiction remake with sailing... Lol. This was my first book by this author and I would read more of her books for sure.
November 19, 2010
Mrs. Seilstad truly makes waves in her debut novel. She writes delicious humor and swoony romance - but still makes you think about honesty and obligations. Her research shines without blinding you. This is the first in the Lake Manawa Summers series, and I can't wait for the next two books.
May 25, 2023
A sweet, wholesome read all about the glamping summer life at Lake Manawa. Follow along for some sailing, summer carnivals with a little twist of romance.
July 22, 2014
I absolutely adored Lorna Seilstad's When Love Calls, which I read last summer, but the next two books of hers that I've read haven't quite lived up to the first. I realise that this is her debut and that her writing will have improved with time, but it took me a while to really get into this book and care about the characters. As much as I enjoyed the historical details about camping at Lake Manawa and sailing, it took a while for the main conflict to emerge.
The book started out feeling rather light and fluffy, with Marguerite's biggest issue being that she couldn't work up the courage to tell Roger that she didn't want to court him. The storyline eventually took a more serious turn when the issue of a family gambling problem emerged, and Marguerite found herself bound to Roger with no way to escape. The book definitely became more engaging at this point, even if it still had a pretty light tone.
In spite of the slow start and initial lack of conflict, I did end up enjoying this book once it properly engaged me. I have to give the author credit for the tough issues she explores, and the interesting questions that are raised about family loyalty, and how much you should be held responsible for your family's mistakes.
As well as the slow start, the other issues that hold me back from rating this book higher relate to Trip and Roger. Trip's internal conflict relates to his mother's abandonment, and this gives him trust issues when it comes to women. While I'm sure this is an entirely probable issue, it just feels like one that's been overdone in a lot of romance novels. It wasn't done badly, but it wasn't particularly intriguing either. Since the "I don't know how to trust someone of the opposite sex because of a bad break-up/family issue" storyline has been done so many times, it really needs to be done differently to actually engage me. And as for Roger, he definitely became more of a villain as the story developed...but he also felt a little over-the-top, since I was never sure what his motivation was. Yes, he likes having his own way, and Marguerite is one of the few things he struggles to control--but was that it? He felt a little bit like a Disney villain.
Unlike my first read from Lorna Seilstad, I wasn't blown away by this book. It was a fun, sweet romance that eventually engaged me and caught my attention once the conflict got moving, but to begin with I found it very easy to put this book down and not feel the need to squeeze in more reading time. While the setting and historical details were fantastic (as I've found in all of her books so far) the characters and their conflicts weren't the most original, which may be this book's drawback. Still, this is a fun summer read that eventually delves into some serious issues. I'm not in a rush to read the rest of the books in the series, but I might be tempted if I find them on sale. 3.5*
The book started out feeling rather light and fluffy, with Marguerite's biggest issue being that she couldn't work up the courage to tell Roger that she didn't want to court him. The storyline eventually took a more serious turn when the issue of a family gambling problem emerged, and Marguerite found herself bound to Roger with no way to escape. The book definitely became more engaging at this point, even if it still had a pretty light tone.
In spite of the slow start and initial lack of conflict, I did end up enjoying this book once it properly engaged me. I have to give the author credit for the tough issues she explores, and the interesting questions that are raised about family loyalty, and how much you should be held responsible for your family's mistakes.
As well as the slow start, the other issues that hold me back from rating this book higher relate to Trip and Roger. Trip's internal conflict relates to his mother's abandonment, and this gives him trust issues when it comes to women. While I'm sure this is an entirely probable issue, it just feels like one that's been overdone in a lot of romance novels. It wasn't done badly, but it wasn't particularly intriguing either. Since the "I don't know how to trust someone of the opposite sex because of a bad break-up/family issue" storyline has been done so many times, it really needs to be done differently to actually engage me. And as for Roger, he definitely became more of a villain as the story developed...but he also felt a little over-the-top, since I was never sure what his motivation was. Yes, he likes having his own way, and Marguerite is one of the few things he struggles to control--but was that it? He felt a little bit like a Disney villain.
Unlike my first read from Lorna Seilstad, I wasn't blown away by this book. It was a fun, sweet romance that eventually engaged me and caught my attention once the conflict got moving, but to begin with I found it very easy to put this book down and not feel the need to squeeze in more reading time. While the setting and historical details were fantastic (as I've found in all of her books so far) the characters and their conflicts weren't the most original, which may be this book's drawback. Still, this is a fun summer read that eventually delves into some serious issues. I'm not in a rush to read the rest of the books in the series, but I might be tempted if I find them on sale. 3.5*
August 14, 2022
This book was adorable!
Marguerite Westing was fun, feisty, and very determined. She really grew in the book. She was self-centered a bit at first, even lying in order to get what she wanted, but eventually as the book became more serious she realized what needed to be done, and that she wasn't doing it for herself but for her family.
The romance of the book was sweet, light, and just plain adorable. I like how it progressed, and how it seemed to be a more realistic "fall-in-love" sort of thing, as if it happened over the summer.
Trip was wonderful and so sweet. As much as he really did love Marguerite, he understood she was taken and kept his distance… until she told him why she was courting him. He was protective over her with Rodger, and I'm really glad he didn't immediately forgive her.
Rodger, at first, was just set on having Marguerite for a wife, but as the book progressed, he became more aggressive toward her, eventually leaving welts on her wrists.
I liked the suspense and brief danger in the book towards the end.. something that got you turning pages.
I like how the book jumped between the views of some the characters, the majority being Marguerite, Trip, and Rodger, because it didn't just show one side of the story… It gave more background on the characters.
As for the setting, it was expressed in such detail you felt like you were there.
I do wish Marguerite hadn't waiting so long to tell Rodger, but at the same time I did think it gave the story more depth-like how if she didn't marry Rodger for the business deal then the whole story would have been different.
After some point in the book, you didn't hear much about Marguerites dreams of sailing… they just sort of vanished… I wished Seilstad would have touched on that throughout the book, rather then have Marguerite mention it randomly at the very end.
There is mentions of alcohol, if that is something you are concerned about. Christianity isn't mentioned much in the book… just enough and a little more to make it a Christian book, I feel, but God was mentioned all the same more then a few times. :)
All in all, this book is fun, lighthearted, and teaches a good lesson on speaking up and telling the truth.
Marguerite Westing was fun, feisty, and very determined. She really grew in the book. She was self-centered a bit at first, even lying in order to get what she wanted, but eventually as the book became more serious she realized what needed to be done, and that she wasn't doing it for herself but for her family.
The romance of the book was sweet, light, and just plain adorable. I like how it progressed, and how it seemed to be a more realistic "fall-in-love" sort of thing, as if it happened over the summer.
Trip was wonderful and so sweet. As much as he really did love Marguerite, he understood she was taken and kept his distance… until she told him why she was courting him. He was protective over her with Rodger, and I'm really glad he didn't immediately forgive her.
Rodger, at first, was just set on having Marguerite for a wife, but as the book progressed, he became more aggressive toward her, eventually leaving welts on her wrists.
I liked the suspense and brief danger in the book towards the end.. something that got you turning pages.
I like how the book jumped between the views of some the characters, the majority being Marguerite, Trip, and Rodger, because it didn't just show one side of the story… It gave more background on the characters.
As for the setting, it was expressed in such detail you felt like you were there.
I do wish Marguerite hadn't waiting so long to tell Rodger, but at the same time I did think it gave the story more depth-like how if she didn't marry Rodger for the business deal then the whole story would have been different.
After some point in the book, you didn't hear much about Marguerites dreams of sailing… they just sort of vanished… I wished Seilstad would have touched on that throughout the book, rather then have Marguerite mention it randomly at the very end.
There is mentions of alcohol, if that is something you are concerned about. Christianity isn't mentioned much in the book… just enough and a little more to make it a Christian book, I feel, but God was mentioned all the same more then a few times. :)
All in all, this book is fun, lighthearted, and teaches a good lesson on speaking up and telling the truth.
September 14, 2010
Making Waves by Lorna Seilstad is a delightful historical romance in a unique setting. I enjoyed the sailing theme and the sexy sailing instructor, Trip, in particular. I found the details about the lake were just enough to make me feel the spray of water hitting my face and the heat of the sun warming my back. This author has a way with words that really pulled into the setting.
The theme about truthfulness in the story was well done. I appreciated the way the author showed all levels of dishonesty and how they can damage relationships. Even the tiniest of white lies. I smiled numerous times while reading this novel because some of the scenes were so poignant. This was a sweet romance with just enough sizzle and heart-pounding moments to keep me anticipating the next scene. And the next. And the next.
Trip was an awesome hero. He had his lovable, protective moments, and he also had his stereotypical male moments when he reacted to what he saw as rejection, which made him even sexier to me. I could sense the attraction between Trip and Marguerite developing and felt it sparking when they were close to each other.
I loved how Marguerite responded to each situation. She was spunky and adorable, and overall a very likable heroine even with her flaws. I also enjoyed the hint of mystery to the story and couldn't stop reading when things started coming to a head and getting slowly exposed. Bottom line... this was a fantastic read. I am definitely reading more books by this author in the future.
The theme about truthfulness in the story was well done. I appreciated the way the author showed all levels of dishonesty and how they can damage relationships. Even the tiniest of white lies. I smiled numerous times while reading this novel because some of the scenes were so poignant. This was a sweet romance with just enough sizzle and heart-pounding moments to keep me anticipating the next scene. And the next. And the next.
Trip was an awesome hero. He had his lovable, protective moments, and he also had his stereotypical male moments when he reacted to what he saw as rejection, which made him even sexier to me. I could sense the attraction between Trip and Marguerite developing and felt it sparking when they were close to each other.
I loved how Marguerite responded to each situation. She was spunky and adorable, and overall a very likable heroine even with her flaws. I also enjoyed the hint of mystery to the story and couldn't stop reading when things started coming to a head and getting slowly exposed. Bottom line... this was a fantastic read. I am definitely reading more books by this author in the future.
January 1, 2015
Marguerite Westing is thrilled when she discovers that her family will spend the summer of 1895 at Lake Manawa; it's the perfect way to escape her agonizingly boring suitor Roger Gordon. While she is there, she develops an interest in sailing, something considered very unladylike at the time, and an interest in a sailing instructor, Trip Andrews. Her summer of fun soon turns to turmoil when she discovers that her father has a gambling problem, and she may be forced to marry Roger to save her father's reputation and the family fortune. Or will she follow her heart, even if it means abandoning her family?
Even though the romance part of the story was a bit predictable, I really enjoyed this book. What really drew me into the story was the humor; from the first pages, there were many "laugh out loud" moments. Overall, it was a fun, light read perfect for summer.
Lake Manawa, Iowa, is real place, and it was considered the "Coney Island of the West" in its heyday. Up until 1927, it was a popular resort. The wealthy use to spend summers "camping" there, but while they did sleep in tents, they weren't exactly "roughing it"; they brought their furniture from home, and their servants, and the ladies still dressed to to the nines, and wore gloves and carried parasols. It was a very interesting time to read about.
Sadly, the resort was gone by the 1930's, falling into disrepair from fires and tornadoes. It is now a state park.
Even though the romance part of the story was a bit predictable, I really enjoyed this book. What really drew me into the story was the humor; from the first pages, there were many "laugh out loud" moments. Overall, it was a fun, light read perfect for summer.
Lake Manawa, Iowa, is real place, and it was considered the "Coney Island of the West" in its heyday. Up until 1927, it was a popular resort. The wealthy use to spend summers "camping" there, but while they did sleep in tents, they weren't exactly "roughing it"; they brought their furniture from home, and their servants, and the ladies still dressed to to the nines, and wore gloves and carried parasols. It was a very interesting time to read about.
Sadly, the resort was gone by the 1930's, falling into disrepair from fires and tornadoes. It is now a state park.
February 13, 2012
By now, I’ve read quite a few Christian romance novels. Change the setting, the decade, the characters, but the plot line still seems pretty similar. So I admit that when I started this book, I was wondering if there would be anything different in this story that I haven’t already read elsewhere (even the choice between a rich boring man or an exciting but poor man is nothing new).
I’m pleased to tell you that yes, there were some things in this book I didn’t expect. I won’t tell you what, that would spoil it for you! The two main characters had some deep flaws that got in the way of their relationship. The way those characters were written was more realistic than many others I’ve read. I did feel that the ending was a little too tidy, though. One character suddenly seemed to exhibit a change of heart that I felt was not consistent with who she seemed to be the rest of the book, and that didn’t feel natural.
I also wish the author would have delved into the darker side of a couple of characters instead of leaving it mostly to my imagination. One character tends toward abusive behavior, and another was prey to a habit which could have been explored more fully to create more of a sense of urgency for the protagonist’s situation. Sorry to be so vague about these “darker sides” but I don’t want to ruin it for anyone who wants to read it.
If you’re looking for an easy-to-read romance with characters you can relate to, though, I would recommend this book.
I’m pleased to tell you that yes, there were some things in this book I didn’t expect. I won’t tell you what, that would spoil it for you! The two main characters had some deep flaws that got in the way of their relationship. The way those characters were written was more realistic than many others I’ve read. I did feel that the ending was a little too tidy, though. One character suddenly seemed to exhibit a change of heart that I felt was not consistent with who she seemed to be the rest of the book, and that didn’t feel natural.
I also wish the author would have delved into the darker side of a couple of characters instead of leaving it mostly to my imagination. One character tends toward abusive behavior, and another was prey to a habit which could have been explored more fully to create more of a sense of urgency for the protagonist’s situation. Sorry to be so vague about these “darker sides” but I don’t want to ruin it for anyone who wants to read it.
If you’re looking for an easy-to-read romance with characters you can relate to, though, I would recommend this book.
July 24, 2015
As for a debut novel into the Christian Historical Romance genre Lorn definitely made splash and some waves of her own. Of course I could be biased with such a character with the name of Marguerite and a Mr. Andrews, as my name is Margaret and my maiden name Andrews. Yet perhaps again it was the picturesque setting where the waves lapping at the shoreside and the wind flapping in the sails could be heard as clear as day off the pages of the book. Or maybe it was the strawberries from the frothy vanilla sundays. Either way this introduction through the adventure in the Manawa Summers Series to the writing and imagination of author Lorna Seilstad is a breathe of fresh air.
Marguerite is a fun and witty character. And I quite wonder if our Roger is bipolar... The entire cast of characters brings together a great calm yet adventurous summer read for anyone to enjoy year round.
*Thanks to Revell Books and Lorna Seilstad for providing a copy for review.*
Marguerite is a fun and witty character. And I quite wonder if our Roger is bipolar... The entire cast of characters brings together a great calm yet adventurous summer read for anyone to enjoy year round.
*Thanks to Revell Books and Lorna Seilstad for providing a copy for review.*
September 9, 2010
What a sweet debut novel! There's nothing like a good, clean, summer read and if you're like me, a girl who hates to see summer's end, you're always looking for books to keep the fun going! A lakeside campsite on Lake Manawa definitely has that summer vibe! I've read mountains of historical romances and I must say what makes this one so good is the setting. Most of the books that I've read set in the 1890s are set in the West or in the city but this one was set on a lake resort in Iowa. How cool right? Oh, did I also mention there's a hunky sailing instructor involved?
Making Waves has it all romance, fun, a guy with a creepy mustache and lessons about lying and it's consequences. Of course there's the obligatory happily ever after too but I'm not telling who gets it. ;-) I was really satisfied with this sweet debut from Lorna Seilstad and I'm sure you will be too if you love Christian themed romance!
* I received my copy from the publisher as an influencer for the author.*
Making Waves has it all romance, fun, a guy with a creepy mustache and lessons about lying and it's consequences. Of course there's the obligatory happily ever after too but I'm not telling who gets it. ;-) I was really satisfied with this sweet debut from Lorna Seilstad and I'm sure you will be too if you love Christian themed romance!
* I received my copy from the publisher as an influencer for the author.*
March 24, 2023
Rating: 3/5 stars
I read this book because it was recommended to me by a close friend. I love reading peoples favorite books because it gives such a personal insight into their inner world. That being said I didn’t particularly enjoy this book, or gain any insight into the mind of my friend. The characters were too immature for my liking, and some of the plot was generally unbelievable. However I did like the setting of the story, it was like experiencing a little sliver of summer in dreary January.
I read this book because it was recommended to me by a close friend. I love reading peoples favorite books because it gives such a personal insight into their inner world. That being said I didn’t particularly enjoy this book, or gain any insight into the mind of my friend. The characters were too immature for my liking, and some of the plot was generally unbelievable. However I did like the setting of the story, it was like experiencing a little sliver of summer in dreary January.
January 19, 2021
Based on the title and cover, this seemed like a silly, light read. The first chapter or so seemed to confirm it. But the story grew in substance and depth from there. So much better than I thought it was going to be.
December 17, 2011
Very good! I thoroughly enjoyed it and it had me chuckling at a few parts - I loved the two main characters wit! :-D Had a great lesson within the story, as well!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 313 reviews