Someone please recommend this book to Elon Musk for a good laugh!
The plot seems very nonsensical to me.
DNF at 64%
If humanity had extremely vague fears its extinction, why did it not send arcs to nearby star systems instead of to preserve its future? The idea to cryogenicial freeze and store just 900 people on a space station orbiting Earth just in case and then to forget about them for thousand years to be awoken only if or when having received the information that humanity was extinct is obscenely moronic.
It is even more contrived that station is supposed to have survived the entire time undisturbed, especially close before and after the apocalypse. Moreover, why did nobody improve or modernise the equipment of the station in more than a thousand years? The station was such a trash that it was a 50-50 chance if it survived docking to the space elevator that had been built for it..
What was their return this way supposed to achieve? Why didn't they even have enough supplies for some extra weeks?
Their plan to resettle a radiated hell hole devoid of resources is utterly moronic!
The protagonist most times acted like an android, rather emotionless and entirely focused on his mission. In other times he was troubled.
In general the characters tended to ponder about moral dilemmas at the most importune moments to show that the author is on "the right side of history". Therefore, gender, anti populism and anti capitalism statements were forced into the story..
In general, the author does everything to dramatise the story, mostly by having the actors act impatient and moronic or having them come to wild conclusions.
In the end, i gave up on the book when the author's nihilistic world view became too much
for me and i realised that the plot led nowhere.
Criticism and comments
The use of nuclear weapons causing extra long radiation is absolutely idiotic in any scenario as it makes the war utterly pointless as there is nothing to win from it..
I found it hilarious that they worry about the radiation during a short reconnaissance mission toan only secondarily affected territory but with the same breath plan to build a permanent colony #rofl#.
The author obviosly doesn't understand how the thermohaline circulation of oceans works. If there is a major difference of temperature of the poles and the equator it has to exist!
A space elevator is supposed to have survived 1000 years and a nuclear holocaust intact? And the imbeciles built it on a dormant volcano directly bordering three Tectonic plates! of all places? That seems absolutely preposterous.. I also highly doubt that their non metal equipment would have survived the time. They should have been printed fresh when needed..
If the team has been trained from a very young age why did not establish optimised, well coordinated teams? Why were they not psychologically and ideologically prepared for the possibility of depopulation the Earth? Why are there no sperm and egg banks with suitable incubators? Religious hesitations?
The excursion to Svjalbard seemed horribly mis-timed as it served no current purpose.
#Rofl# the space station needed a working space elevator for people to reach Earth- otherwise they would have starved to death in space.. Not to mention that their protocol to only put on environmental suits after having landed successfully is that idiotic that only Hollywood film makers would be dumb enough to do that..
Did the space station have no properly working scanners? Why didn't it neither have satellites or drones? The determination of radiation and temperatures and the general situation in the landing area BEFORE sending ill equipped people there would've been critical. The lack of measurements about the magnetic field and tests for air borne pathogens is sheer criminal as well.
One would assume that these people would have the best equipment for every foreseeable scenario to achieve their critical mission. Sadly, theirs reminded me more of pre 1970s Russian equipment.
The protagonist's glorious choice to open his helmet in an untested environment in extremely cold environment reminded me of idiotic Hollywood Scify movies again..
The plot to neutralise Toussaint seemed extremely convoluted, sabotaging her module like the others would have been easier and foolproof!
Why would T. Need his cides if she had superior access herself?
Regarding the rusted robotic arm - only fools would leave the station pressurised with air over such a long time.. But it fits to the other idiocies..
Why could the crappie space station not contact the satellites in orbit?
Their terraforming efforts of an entire planet would need much more time given the low amount of personal. What was vehemently ignored at that point was the rampant radiation that would have to overcome first. Furthermore, the process seems to be out of order. Without stabilised weather and nitrogen in the ground and cleaning potential pollutions and pathogens planting seems pointless..
I had to shake my head several times when i read about their idiotic repopulate the Earth plan. Firstly, the jokers have cloning tech but don't use it for alternative procreation, secondly they worried about limited food supplies and radiation already and their ability to reliably grow excess food in the next decades seems doubtful. I also couldn't follow their sentiment of unfairness of having and raising children reproachably preventing them from doing jobs with a high lethality rate as men.. The fact that they were even taught such notions which might endanger the mission whilest being prepared for their quest in isolation once again shows the gross incompetence of their mentors.
It was hilarious how amateurish they did their Greenland expedition. Anyone with half a brain would use sonar and radar before landing. The same goes for scanning for radiation. Their surprise to find ice on Greenland was laughable as it was states that big parts of the northern and southern hemisphere were covered by ice... Moreover i had troubles with the existence of an secret listening post as the necessary antennas would be a dead give away.. once again i missed drones or robots for reconnaissance as it is standard in our time..
I couldn't follow the logic behind the irradiation of the personal.
The conclusion from the signal loop seemed unfounded and arbitrary.
The reaction to the incident was bizarre as it was either caused by a massive malfunction or sabotage, both of which endanger their holy mission.
The statement about the remaining living age of our sun was wrong, the one about the universe was a hypothesis..
Regarding the Kanpur mission. This seems to be a very bad location for a major radio telescope as there are no high mountains nearby. Once again they didn't use their sensors properly to locate the entry point and best landing point.To prevent a hostile take over of the aircraft it also should have started again. I found it bewildering that they would take a woman to a suicide mission if they insist on traditional reproduction.
Their accidental discovery of a potent world threatening phenomenon in the area showed again how amateurish their protocols were. Before resettling the planet they should have scouted it properly. Once again their clownish and utterly reckless behavior reminded me of idiotic western Scify movies..
About the climate crisis that led to the final war.The plot tries to make the reader believe that terraforming equipment that is 1000 years older than the crisis is supposed to be superior to anything the imbeciles on Earth could come up with? Even if that was the case people from Earth would have used it!!
The exodus: the protagonist's thought process was bizarre - he acted like a drama queen. Given the fact that the remaining crew could and should go into cryo sleep, his mission has the potential to save both them and their mission in the future..
Ross 128b: the fact that there is a space station orbiting the planet seems to contradict magnetic storms, the same goes for the scientific data regarding the sun.. The fact that nobody contacted them did not mean that no contact is possible. Once again the premature decision to land without ANY easily achievable intelligence was utterly reckless, just again gross incompetence for drama reasons.. instead there was more abstract gender drama.. #argh#
Rossur: i found it hilarious how wrong most of the protagonist's deductions and conclusions were. Their "rescue" was as moronic as the original plot. More population would not help to improve the situation. Better living standards would most likely lead to to social reforms. Capitalism is not the unique evil form of society that demands work to survive.
Lyra: i had to agree with her. This is a time for actions to improve the lives of everyone and not for hollow revolutionary declarations!