After a visit to Spooksville’s very own witch, Ann Templeton, on Halloween night, Adam and his friends investigate a spooky, abandoned house. Everyone knows the stories of how kids disappear in this house and never return, and even Watch and Sally don’t want to risk it. But when Adam sees a strange light and hears a mournful cry, he can’t resist trying to help. Is it possible that the kids who disappeared into the Evil House are still trapped there? Trigger warnings: child death (off-page), abduction, severe illness, violence, blood/implied gore, implied body horror, bullying.
I’ve been eagerly awaiting Halloween in Spooksville, and The Evil House doesn’t disappoint. It’s one of my favorites of the recent (for me) books, and I’m newly frustrated that there’s nowhere to stream the show right now because I have distinct memories of this episode. Pike is at his spookiest here with haunted houses, alternate dimensions, magicians, and, of course, Halloween, and it has pretty much all my favorite things in the series.
Adam is brave (sometimes stupidly brave), but it’s his heart that makes him the real hero of this series. He can’t walk away from someone in trouble, even if they’re a stranger, and wherever they go, he tries to make things better for the people there. (I also love that Adam is much more compassionate than Sally. Boys can be soft. Girls can be tough. Knock down those gender norms.) Pike also does a nice job developing the villain of this story, making him believable, and giving him a compelling backstory all in a few short pages. I will say that I don’t care for Bryce being a more permanent part of the group though. It didn’t really need a fifth wheel, and literally every function he serves in this particular book can be fulfilled by Sally or Adam. (I also just don’t find him that interesting… or trustworthy.)
Potential spoilers ahead! I’m still compiling evidence for my theory that Watch isn’t human/is from another time/dimension/outer space, so of course I loved the line about him only seeing stars in the crystal ball.
I review regularly at brightbeautifulthings.tumblr.com.