What do you think?
Rate this book
Roaring Silence
"Roaring Silence", a personal account of Karate-do training under some of the leading instructors in the world, has been out of print for several years. It is with great pleasure that the publishers, Paul H. Crompton Ltd., have reissued it in a new edition. This will please also it is hoped the many new as well as older karate students who want to know what was it like in "byegone days" when names like Higaonna, Tani and the rest were not so well known. "Roaring Silence" is at the same time an account of personal triumph over the adversities of life, and an example to the young of today of one man's dedication to an art which changed his life. From the streets of England to the dojos of Karate-do training in Okinawa, Michael Clarke will captivate readers with his story.
128 pages, Paperback
First published April 1, 1987
About the author
Michael Clarke
5 books1 followerLibrarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Please see: Michael Clarke
Michael Clarke (1958-1999)
By the age of 17, Michael Clarke, Kyoshi 8th dan was behind bars, a veteran street fighter serving a two-year sentence for occasioning grievous bodily harm. Turning 18 behind the walls of one of England's most notorious prisons 'Strangeways', was a wake up call that began his climb off the bottom.
Released back into society on parole in December 1973, he began training in karate in January 1974.
After ten years of training in the Japanese system of Tani-ha Shito-ryu, he travelled to Okinawa for the first time in 1984, in search of the more traditional training methods. There he was accepted into the dojo of the famed Morio Higaonna sensei. In 1992 he entered the Jundokan dojo of Eiichi Miyazato sensei, the dojo where Higaonna sensei himself had learnt karate, and became a student of the man who had received his instruction directly from the founder of goju-ryu: Chojun Miyagi. Six weeks before he passed away, in 1999, Miyazato sensei promoted Michael to 6th dan.
source: Amazon
Please see: Michael Clarke
Michael Clarke (1958-1999)
By the age of 17, Michael Clarke, Kyoshi 8th dan was behind bars, a veteran street fighter serving a two-year sentence for occasioning grievous bodily harm. Turning 18 behind the walls of one of England's most notorious prisons 'Strangeways', was a wake up call that began his climb off the bottom.
Released back into society on parole in December 1973, he began training in karate in January 1974.
After ten years of training in the Japanese system of Tani-ha Shito-ryu, he travelled to Okinawa for the first time in 1984, in search of the more traditional training methods. There he was accepted into the dojo of the famed Morio Higaonna sensei. In 1992 he entered the Jundokan dojo of Eiichi Miyazato sensei, the dojo where Higaonna sensei himself had learnt karate, and became a student of the man who had received his instruction directly from the founder of goju-ryu: Chojun Miyagi. Six weeks before he passed away, in 1999, Miyazato sensei promoted Michael to 6th dan.
source: Amazon
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
October 26, 2018
"Roaring Silence" by Michael Clarke is a truly uninspired book. A storyline with little or no potential for "life" unfortunately met that standard all too quickly.
The layout of the book is an unfamiliar, and highly strange format. A simple example, neither who nor what is shown on the front cover is ever identified. The book is twelve chapters in length but no table of contents exists. The Further reading section (pp.8) was given between the Dedication-Photo page, and the Acknowledgements page rather than at the end of the book where it belongs. Before the Preface, or the story which Mr. Clarke eventually tells, he lists authors and the titles of other books which he recommends. There is a twisted irony to this placement... (i.e. read other books first).
Listing the date of publication, the ISBN, or any other identification number for any of Clarke's recommended books would have been obscenely useful. He failed to do so. Clarke's apparent contention these particular books are/were more geared for the mental development aspects of karate training rather than the physical per se is highly curious. He seems to imply that "Roaring" is about the physical?
Throughout the book are numerous black and white photographs. Some are full page, others are captioned. The purpose or function of many are quite unclear, if not outright unnecessary. What function does the full page, close-up photo of the author (?) in a quasi defensive posture on the second page of the book possess? If showing "dynamic" action was the intent then cutting off the top of the authors (?) head in that photograph does absolutely nothing helpful!
Excessive group photos (pp. 30, 48, 62, 68, 82, 108, 120, 121, etc.) and too many unnecessary photos of individual friends also fill its pages. Why does the reader care about the author "vigorously" demonstrating a front kick (pp.61)? What possible value does two pages of the author demonstrating still photography of postures (pp.126-127) jammed in the back of the book hold?! Such photography fills far too many pages without having any tangible value to them. While some photos could surely have made interesting chapter headings, majority should easily be done without.
The book is not entirely without some minor sparks of life however. The Forward is fairly eloquent. Clarke's sentiment that karate has serious potential as a tool to help youth heading down the "wrong path" (if cliched) always bears repeating. The stories of Morio Higaonna sensei an Okinawan karate personality as a normal human being, the authors host on Okinawan rather than some "mythical" or living legend of Okinawan karate are fairly unusual too.
So there are literal sparks of interesting information in "Roaring Silence". But too few sparks exist to give this work any true flame. Perhaps in the "next" edition mandatory, critical editing changes will be made.
If you want to understand the training experiences of a martial artist explore C.W. Nicol's Moving Zen: One Mans Journey to the Heart of Karate none have yet been done as well, nor even close!
The layout of the book is an unfamiliar, and highly strange format. A simple example, neither who nor what is shown on the front cover is ever identified. The book is twelve chapters in length but no table of contents exists. The Further reading section (pp.8) was given between the Dedication-Photo page, and the Acknowledgements page rather than at the end of the book where it belongs. Before the Preface, or the story which Mr. Clarke eventually tells, he lists authors and the titles of other books which he recommends. There is a twisted irony to this placement... (i.e. read other books first).
Listing the date of publication, the ISBN, or any other identification number for any of Clarke's recommended books would have been obscenely useful. He failed to do so. Clarke's apparent contention these particular books are/were more geared for the mental development aspects of karate training rather than the physical per se is highly curious. He seems to imply that "Roaring" is about the physical?
Throughout the book are numerous black and white photographs. Some are full page, others are captioned. The purpose or function of many are quite unclear, if not outright unnecessary. What function does the full page, close-up photo of the author (?) in a quasi defensive posture on the second page of the book possess? If showing "dynamic" action was the intent then cutting off the top of the authors (?) head in that photograph does absolutely nothing helpful!
Excessive group photos (pp. 30, 48, 62, 68, 82, 108, 120, 121, etc.) and too many unnecessary photos of individual friends also fill its pages. Why does the reader care about the author "vigorously" demonstrating a front kick (pp.61)? What possible value does two pages of the author demonstrating still photography of postures (pp.126-127) jammed in the back of the book hold?! Such photography fills far too many pages without having any tangible value to them. While some photos could surely have made interesting chapter headings, majority should easily be done without.
The book is not entirely without some minor sparks of life however. The Forward is fairly eloquent. Clarke's sentiment that karate has serious potential as a tool to help youth heading down the "wrong path" (if cliched) always bears repeating. The stories of Morio Higaonna sensei an Okinawan karate personality as a normal human being, the authors host on Okinawan rather than some "mythical" or living legend of Okinawan karate are fairly unusual too.
So there are literal sparks of interesting information in "Roaring Silence". But too few sparks exist to give this work any true flame. Perhaps in the "next" edition mandatory, critical editing changes will be made.
If you want to understand the training experiences of a martial artist explore C.W. Nicol's Moving Zen: One Mans Journey to the Heart of Karate none have yet been done as well, nor even close!
Displaying 1 of 1 review