Company is near-universally acknowledged to be the show where Sondheim hit his stride--after doing the lyrics for three shows and the music and lyrics for one success and one flop, Company took on a more experimental vibe than the others had and, according to some, dealt the death blow to the Golden Age of Broadway. Three cheers for Company, amiright?
Okay, fine, I don't dislike every Golden Age show, but I much prefer this style of show and music to them. The closest comparisons I can find for Company are that from a music standpoint, it's scored like a non-sung-through Falsettos and from a structure standpoint, like Assassins with a base location where all of the characters start out that then switches to other locations for backstory but ultimately still comes together at the end.
Despite it being one of my most listened to soundtracks, I've never actually seen Company live, though I do want to see it and have seen the proshot with Neil Patrick Harris as Bobby, as well as be in it and direct it someday. Bobby is up there with like half the characters in Assassins as my dream role, and Joanne falls somewhere in the Max Bialystock-Pseudolous range of "she'd be so fun to play!". Hell, my profile picture is a reference to the posters for Company 2022, which I have mixed feelings on but still enjoy.
Bobby, however...Bobby is one of my favorite characters in theatre, if not my absolute favorite. His story arc captures so many of my emotions and fears perfectly and Being Alive and Marry Me a Little just reach into my heart and tear it out. Listening to them makes me feel like I've been plucked like a chicken (or in that case I guess a man--hey Diogenes, how ya doing?); I feel like my heart has been exposed. The fear of becoming distant from your friends because they all find people who they love in a different way from you, of internal and external pressure from all sides to get married, the idea that you are only a piece and you need "your other half" to become whole, the desire to have someone "marry [you] a little, love [you] just enough" and "want [you] more than others--not exclusively" is something that I think is just as relevant today as it was in 1970 when the show debuted--it hits home for me, anyways.
The issue with Company is that its book is…not the best. The score is among my favorites, but the script and vignettes that make it up never had that same spark for me to the point where I almost feel like it would’ve been better completely sung-though.
As for recordings of the show, while I maintain that Patti LuPone is the best Joanne, nothing beats the upbeat energy of the original 1970 recording for me, even if Raul Esparza is probably the best Bobby—the way he sings “make me confused, mock me with praise!” gives me chills every time. While I like the aesthetic of genderbent Company (again, I had a Company-themed graduation party and my invites were mock-ups of the 2022 revival poster), I do think that it fails as a revival that stresses the genderbent element by not really discussing the difference in stigma around being a 35 year old bachelorette with 3 boyfriends in modern day as opposed to being a 35 year old bachelor with 3 girlfriends (and yes, they smoke weed)(not really, but I couldn’t resist. And also Bobby canonically smokes weed so) in 1970. I hate how there’s less prominent women in a show ostensibly meant to be feminist, I don’t like that they made one of the boyfriends an outright misogynist (I assume it’s supposed to be the Kathy of them since Kathy’s whole thing is that she wants to settle down and be married but like. how do you leapt from that to one of the boyfriends disdainfully calling Bobbie a feminist in You Could Drive a Person Crazy?), I don’t like that they made the only canonical queer couple Jamie and Paul while eliminating the subtext between Bobbie and Joanne (and also since it undercuts the tension of Marry Me a Little—Jamie is gay, of course he’s not going to marry Bobbie, while in the original there’s the vibe that Bobby and Amy could be together, which makes Amy gently turning him down more impactful. Personally I think that they should do a revival examining Bobby from an aromantic perspective since that’s absolutely how I read him (although I read Bobbie as a lesbian) or do a sort of combination of the scripts where Bobby/ie is bisexual and the partners are a mix of genders (personally I want to direct a version that’s all women, I think that could be cool). I just think the genderbend has a lot of missed potential. Although I do love Bobby/ie in any form.