What do you think?
Rate this book


384 pages, Paperback
First published October 1, 2001
Oar was introduced in the Expendable, first book in the series, but met a terrible end. Except, she’s not dead after all (she has a firm belief that she can’t be killed), and is the narrator of this book. You have the feeling that Gardner had a lot of fun writing this book from her perspective, and it’s equally fun to read. And, despite Oar’s constant, outrageous claims, he’s done an excellent job of letting us see the truth behind them – not only about Oar, but about the supporting cast as well.
There’s a mystery (or several) in the book, and it builds up to some major issues. But it all makes sense and it’s satisfying, in a way that SF books don’t always pull off. My only complaint about it, really, is that a number of the key issues come into focus only quite late in the book. It feels like half of the book is Act I, another third is Act II, and just the remainder is Act III. While a lot of the key issues are set up and hinted at throughout the book, they’re very much peripheral until they end, when they suddenly leap to the front of the stage. I’d have liked to see a better balance.
And there’s one very strong hint at a secretive character’s identity. I don’t recall whether this is explained in later volumes, but I hope so.
If you’re a fan of thoughtful adventure SF, you’ll enjoy this. I urge you to start at the beginning of the series (skip Commitment Hour), but this works as a standalone as well. I recommend it strongly.