Poetry for Young People: Edgar Allan Poe, edited by Brod Bagert. Sterling Publishing Company, 48 pages. Non-fiction, work of poetry.
Description: A sampling of Edgar Allan Poe's poems are presented, along with adapted excerpts from some of his longer prose. The poems are illustrated and briefly annotated.
Review: This collection helps young readers ease into poetry that might normally seem too difficult for them to enjoy. Dark, dreamlike illustrations accompany the texts and reflect the dark mood of Poe's writing. This dark, melodramatic mood will appeal to older children who enjoy stories about the supernatural.
Because kids might have a hard time deciphering the meaning of these poems, each one is described briefly in a way that sets the stage for readers as they launch into the poems. Unfamiliar words are also pulled out of the text and paired with familiar synonyms. This technique assists readers without making them flip to a glossary for a full definition. The volume is prefaced with a short biography of Poe. It would be helpful for readers not to skip this preface, as it provides a rich context for the poems.
Professional Reviews:
Katka, Pat. School Library Journal, June 1995.
Katka believes that Bagert's annotations detract from the experience of reading a poem. I disagree with this assessment. For children who are just being introduced to Poe, these explanations will help them decipher the poems' meaning. For more advanced readers, the annotations can simply be skipped.
I could only find one review for this title.