Pest Control reminded me of an outrageous Mel Brooks movie. The events are absolutely improbable, but you just have to suspend your disbelief long enough to end up chuckling and shaking your head in wonder. At one point, I was expecting a modern apocalyptic drama where genetic engineering went wrong and, at another point, I was expecting the protagonist to assume the “mistaken identity” implicit in the story. Neither happened and the results turned out to be even more worthwhile than my erroneous expectations.
Imagine a world of super-assassins where everyone keeps score of who is making the most money via mercenary contracts for both national and personal interests. Then, imagine an assassin with a conscience (oxymoronic, I know) who refuses a big job only to have a group seek out new talent. Then, imagine an innocent blundering into that talent search and the wildest chain of coincidences imaginable allowing others to believe that his innocence is a cover-up, a front, a blind, a beard(?), etc. When “The Exterminator” proves to be exactly what he claims to be (not an assassin? Or a wrestler?), both hilarity and a reasonable modicum of suspense takes over the plot.
[Spoiler Alert] I can’t help but share my absolute favorite scene in the book. Unarmed and facing an armed assassin, “The Exterminator” realizes that all of Manhattan is the world’s most efficient killing machine. He starts running and leads the assassin (with gun in hand) to my very favorite Manhattan restaurant (Angelo’s on Mulberry Street). Now, if you know what is alleged to be in the back room at Angelo’s (and I’m not sayin’…), you won’t be surprised at what happens to the assassin when he comes running in with a gun. Even if you understand this spoiler, it’s going to be funny when you read it.
In terms of humor, Pest Control is the absolute best I’ve read since the days of Douglas Adams. To be sure, Adams’ humor had a foundational sophistication in the chaos where Bill Fitzhugh is more slapstick—the late author’s Woody Allen to Fitzhugh’s Mel Brooks. But this reviewer likes both, depending on mood, so the chaos in Pest Control was marvelous. Unless you’re one of those people who wants verisimilitude in all things, this is a largely undiscovered and underrated book that I recommend most highly. Thanks to my brother’s generosity, I was able to “discover” it. Don’t miss it.