Middle-class Chinese women in the global city of Hong Kong have entered the workforce in unprecedented numbers over the past three decades, and the demand for foreign domestic workers has soared. A decade ago some foretold the decline in foreign workers and the influx of mainland workers. But today over 120,000 women from the Philippines, over 90,000 from Indonesia, and thousands more from other parts of South and Southeast Asia serve as maids on two-year contracts in Hong Kong, sending much needed remittances to their families abroad. Nicole Constable tells their story by updating Maid to Order in Hong Kong with a focus on the major changes that have taken place since Hong Kong's reunification with mainland China in 1997, the Asian financial crisis of the late 1990s, and the outbreak of SARS in 2002-2003. Interweaving her analysis with the women's individual stories, she shows how power is expressed in the day-to-day lives of Filipina domestic workers and more-recent Indonesian arrivals.
Nicole Constable is assistant professor of anthropology at the University of Pittsburgh. Other contributors are Sharon A. Carstens, Myron L. Cohen, Mary S. Erbaugh, Elizabeth Lominska Johnson, Howard J. Martin; and Ellen Oxfeld.
it fell into a pattern of describing migrant policy, how agencies exploited them, how employers exploited them, and the cartoonishly evil circumstances that filipina workers fell into that became somewhat monotonous, or at the very least repetitive. does it count as trauma porn? i felt chapter 8 was the most important and engaging one
An informative and personal ethnographic study of (mainly) Filipino migrant domestic workers in Hong Kong with their brutal experience and subtle resistance. Nice to see that humour sometimes becomes a means of resistance. Downside: not sure if Foucault's mode of discipline is necessary as a theoretical discourse to describe the experience of these brave ladies. I think a rigorous analysis of the emergence of global capitalism and how it ties to migrant labour is more interesting.
I was inspired to investigate more about domestic helpers after reading the book “the Help”.
This is a nonfiction book that examines foreign domestic helpers in Hong Kong from the 1990s to 2006. The book begins by tracing the history of domestic helpers, from local to foreign workers, and how industrialization and changing family structures facilitated the influx of foreign domestic helpers into HK. It then examines the power imbalance between workers and employers, using examples to show how workers were exploited through underpayment or, even worse, violations of their basic human rights, such as being locked in kitchens. This is heartbreaking and frightening because it shows how power imbalance can reduce a worker to a commodity in the eyes of an employer. I appreciate the book’s consideration of religion and how faith influences the way workers deal with hardship and unfair treatment. At the same time, I can’t help but wonder about the danger of misinterpreting religious teachings without grounding them in reality. I also appreciate the selection of cases showing the convoluted ways in which workers can advocate for their rights legally. Although a legal structure may exist to protect workers, it does not necessarily serve the disadvantaged when navigating that system is logistically challenging or in conflict with one another (2-week rule)
My childhood was fortunate enough to include several patient and loving domestic helpers. My parents did not grow up with much money, and I wonder whether that experience shaped the way they treated others. They taught me to address our helpers with respect and to say “please” and “thank you.” Looking back, I wish I had taken the opportunity to know them more as individuals. Frankly, I don’t have many memories of them outside of their hardworking professional roles.
I sympathize with and agree with much of the book’s content, particularly its discussion of the vulnerability created by the power imbalance between workers and employers. Workers may be unaware of their rights and can be vulnerable to manipulation by employers who have significant influence over their employment and legal status to stay in Hong Kong. To make the book more complete, I would have liked it to explore what makes an employer-worker relationship successful and respectful. It would also have been useful to include more perspectives from employers, including cases involving difficult relationships with workers. This would not necessarily undermine the book’s argument about structural inequality; instead, it could provide a fuller picture of the complexities of the employer-worker relationship.
So Filipina Maids in Hong Kong have to live within rigid rules of other people as Overseas Foreign workers. They have to deal with jealous Chinese wives. They are looked down upon due to their class and status as poor maids. On top of that, they have to deal with a level of paternalism that forces them to be part of other people's family dinners when they would rather be out with friends. Their lives are heavily policed and there often is not much recourse.
Comprehensive account of Filipina domestic workers in Hong Kong, with due respect to historical context and global economic patterns that resulted in the present situation of dependency of Philippines vis'a'vis Hong Kong and hence, the power imbalance experienced by Filipina workers vis'a'vis their elite employers.
A good and accessible intro book to south-north migration of low-skill labours, yet, if you have read articles/ books about this topic before then it wouldn't say anything new.
Although Constable tries to pay respect to "deferential practices" or "discursive resistance" (in which Filipina domestic workers aspire to discipline themselves into the ideal domestic worker when facing abuses by employers instead of contesting radically) and situate such rational responses amidst their economic insecurity and fear of further abuses, she seems to not be able to constrain her support for more radical contestation, and at times, seems to be reproaching her research subjects for not doing more.
A really lucid, readable contribution by a woman who seems to have a lot of respect for the power and self-advocacy of migrant workers. Has a particular focus on Filipinas. Gives a good picture of the international political and economic context. Has jokes.
Read this for my research project on Foreign Domestic Workers in Hong Kong. Lots of eye opening insights and things I didn't know about! Was mainly about the dynamics of power between FDWs and their employers in Hong Kong, and I gained a lot of knowledge about how this system can be unjust.
Fascinating book, very well written. Constable strikes a great balance in describing the institutional systems and laws, intertwining the experiences that migrants face as a result. INFURIATING!