This review is extraordinarily long because I wrote it for a class a few semesters ago where the assignment was to write a 1000 word review of a small press book:
There are few things less tedious than having to listen to a friend recount a dream they thought was particularly interesting. It is boring. There is a flatness to the retelling. Weird event follows weird event and time seems to slow down while the narrative never goes anywhere. While the work of Shane Jones is strongly related to dreaming, it is never boring. Instead, it is exciting. He may write about men with axe noses and polite sea monsters and tiny sheriffs living in stomachs, but his narratives never embrace dreaming in their entirety. Unlike an account of a dream, Jones’ writing is carefully constructed with an emphasis on feelings such as helplessness and yearning that underlie the unreal situations that he described. Instead of existing in dreams, his writing seems to exist in realities that are different from our own. They ignore the laws of physics and follow other laws; where people, objects, and places transform and inexplicably shift in size.
In 2009, the small press, Publishing Genius, published Jones’ debut novel, Light Boxes. The following year, it was reprinted by Penguin Books. The novel concerns a town of balloonists and their war with February, a man who refuses to allow the month of which he shares a name to end. Its unreal elements are less prominent than in Jones’ other work and the story resembles Richard Brautigan’s more fantastical work.
His new poetry collection, A Cake Appeared, embraces the possibilities of the unreal to its fullest capacity. The majority of the poems are no longer than a page. They vary between prose poems and free verse, and everything is story/narrative-based. The long poem, “The Nightmare Filled You with Scary,” is the highlight of the book, but it does not feel like it is a good fit. Its darker tone contrasts with the other poems which, unlike “Scary,” share connections. For example, in “Attics,” birds build an attic on top of a man’s attic, and he charges townsfolk to look at it as they have ‘an emotion of their choosing,’ while a woman in “Her Chimney Tells Me She is Sad” builds a chimney around herself because she ‘wanted to feel something,’ then in “Half Scary,” a man in a town is building another chimney around himself: ‘When the evening sets / it’s so quiet / except for the scrapping / of mortar on the bricks. / The chimney sits around his waist.’
Characters from one poem will stumble into another. In “Bob,” a scarecrow chases a character named Bob On A Bicycle into a river, where he is eaten by an alligator. On the next page, the title character in “A So Sad Big Man” sits in a bathtub. A man on a bicycle rides into the bathroom and starts ‘riding in circles around the so sad big man in the bathtub’….”Feeling any better?” he asks. “A little,” said the so sad man breaking a smile.’
“The Nightmare Filled You with Scary” concerns a town whose dreams are haunted by a man named Avery. There is an echo of Light Boxes here, where every person in a town shares a common antagonist, although the poem focuses on a married couple and their baby. Each line consists of about four words, giving the poem a claustrophobic-feel. It is never made clear what is so terrifying about Avery. He may kill the townspeople with his shotgun, but they are willing to commit suicide in their dreams to wake themselves up so they can avoid a confrontation with him. They surround their sleeping bodies with gun and knives, because assumingly, they can only acquire these weapons in their nightmares if they take this precaution prior to bedtime. The animals in the town also fear Avery and commit suicide to avoid him. The married couple of the poem recently had a baby, who understandably has sleeping problems. They try to teach him to commit suicide, but do not succeed. Due to this, the baby is likely to be more psychologically damaged when he gets older than everyone else in the town. Eventually, the problem is partially solved when the couple and the baby join a motorcycle gang.
One of the joys of reading the poems in A Cake Appeared involves the transformation of people or objects. In “Poem That Is 20-25 Lines Long Including Line Breaks,” the protagonist watches as ‘one bear steps on the squirrels and pushes the other bear through a glass window and (he) run(s) over to watch the bear falling but the bear is now a car bouncing and rolling down the cliff and when it reaches the bottom it hesitates, rocks from side to side for a moment, before exploding.’ Jones leaves it up to the reader to determine the meaning behind this transformation. His work may be simplistic on its surface level, but he leaves what lurks below open to interpretation. The surface provides an inviting entry point into his poetry while its depths are responsible for its greatness.
Morgan Blair’s wonderful cover art is worthy of a mention, featuring a bearded man and his elaborately designed shirt (or sweater). The man, whose face is not shown above his lips, is reflected in the book’s content, bringing to mind the characters that reappear throughout the poems. Men with beards are very prominent in the book, and their facial hair often serves as a major component to the stories, such as in “Hello Woman in the Woods,” where a man with a beard finds a woman knitting a sweater. When finished, she gives it to him. ‘The sweater was orange (like on the cover) and on the front was stitched a picture of him without a beard. After he put the sweater on his beard fell off and onto the stitched picture on the sweater.’
Shane Jones’ A CAKE APPEARED is proof that the use of minimalist language can result in something magical. It is a feast for the imagination and the senses.