What do you think?
Rate this book
Hermeneutics: Studies in the History of Religions
The Sword and the Flute--Kali and Krsna: Dark Visions of the Terrible and the Sublime in Hindu Mythology
Krsna and Kali are two of Hinduism’s most popular deities, representing dramatically different truths about the nature of the sacred. The cruel and terrible Kali is thought to be born of wild, aboriginal roots. She is the goddess of thieves and often associated with human blood sacrifice. Krsna, in contrast, is the divine lover and inimitable prankster who plays a bewitching flute to draw all to him. But Kali and Krsna have much more in common than their contrasting personalities suggest. Kinsley shows that Krsna’s flute can be interchangeable with Kali’s sword, revealing important perceptions of the divine in the Hindu tradition.
175 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1975
9 people are currently reading
318 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
June 29, 2025
Some books don’t just expand the mind—they offer you back to yourself, reframed, re-ignited, re-membered. I read The Sword and the Flute in 2005, but it felt less like reading and more like remembering something I’d always known. It wasn’t scholarship—it was homecoming. Because I have always known: Ma Kali is my Mother.
David Kinsley’s book is a work of comparative mythology, yes, but it’s also a dance between the beautiful and the terrible, the flute and the sword, Krishna and Kali. It is a mirror held up to Hindu theology that reveals just how deeply the subcontinent dreams its gods—darkly, ferociously, tenderly, with contradictions so sharp they cut through Western binaries like Ma’s scimitar through ego.
Kali and Krishna. One holds a bloody blade, the other a murali. One dances on a corpse in the cremation ground, the other pirouettes on moonlit riverbanks. But both—both are irresistible. Both pull the soul into their vortex not by comfort but by confrontation. When Kinsley speaks of “dark visions of the terrible and the sublime,” I knew he wasn’t theorising—he was invoking.
Kali was never abstract to me. I grew up with Her fierce eyes in the corner of the puja room, with incense curling around Her protruding tongue like dark mist. In my lowest moments, I didn't cry to the sky—I screamed into Her lap. When I was disillusioned, it was not Gita's karma-yoga that saved me, but Her blunt force. Her rage gave me refuge. Because Her rage wasn’t random. It was holy.
Reading this book didn’t introduce me to Ma. It reminded me why She makes sense. Kinsley doesn't flinch from Her horror. He doesn't reduce Her to metaphor or flatten Her into feminist tokenism. He shows how She is the raw power of reality: death, time, change, rupture, the dissolution of everything that pretends to be permanent. Kali is not just the end of illusion; She is the Mother through that end.
And then—Krishna. The seducer, the trickster, the flute-player who makes gopis forget their names, who speaks philosophy while His chariot rolls through war. Kinsley’s genius is to pair them—not as opposites, but as complementary. The flute and the sword are not two weapons, but two calls. One lures you with love, the other slices through your falsehoods. And in some moments, both are the same.
In my reading, the connection between them became clear. Both Krishna and Kali annihilate the ego. Both seduce, devour, and re-create the self. Krishna does it through lila, divine play. Kali does it through mahapralaya, the final dissolution. One is blue like the infinite sky, the other black like the womb of creation. But both carry within them the echo of the cosmic “ॐ”—a vibration both tender and terrifying.
There’s a line in the book that still strikes like a bell in my memory: that in Hinduism, the ultimate is not tame. It is not domesticated. The divine is not here to be safe—it is here to be real. And that, I think, is the power of this work. Kinsley dares to present the divine not as comfort food, but as wild fire. Not as the end of questions, but as the beginning of awe.
Nearly twenty years later, I still return to The Sword and the Flute. Not because I seek knowledge, but because I seek permission. Permission to feel rage and still be held. Permission to see the divine in contradiction. Permission to bleed and still be beautiful. After all, she who drinks blood also gives birth. That is Ma.
ॐ क्रीं कालिकायै नमः।
David Kinsley’s book is a work of comparative mythology, yes, but it’s also a dance between the beautiful and the terrible, the flute and the sword, Krishna and Kali. It is a mirror held up to Hindu theology that reveals just how deeply the subcontinent dreams its gods—darkly, ferociously, tenderly, with contradictions so sharp they cut through Western binaries like Ma’s scimitar through ego.
Kali and Krishna. One holds a bloody blade, the other a murali. One dances on a corpse in the cremation ground, the other pirouettes on moonlit riverbanks. But both—both are irresistible. Both pull the soul into their vortex not by comfort but by confrontation. When Kinsley speaks of “dark visions of the terrible and the sublime,” I knew he wasn’t theorising—he was invoking.
Kali was never abstract to me. I grew up with Her fierce eyes in the corner of the puja room, with incense curling around Her protruding tongue like dark mist. In my lowest moments, I didn't cry to the sky—I screamed into Her lap. When I was disillusioned, it was not Gita's karma-yoga that saved me, but Her blunt force. Her rage gave me refuge. Because Her rage wasn’t random. It was holy.
Reading this book didn’t introduce me to Ma. It reminded me why She makes sense. Kinsley doesn't flinch from Her horror. He doesn't reduce Her to metaphor or flatten Her into feminist tokenism. He shows how She is the raw power of reality: death, time, change, rupture, the dissolution of everything that pretends to be permanent. Kali is not just the end of illusion; She is the Mother through that end.
And then—Krishna. The seducer, the trickster, the flute-player who makes gopis forget their names, who speaks philosophy while His chariot rolls through war. Kinsley’s genius is to pair them—not as opposites, but as complementary. The flute and the sword are not two weapons, but two calls. One lures you with love, the other slices through your falsehoods. And in some moments, both are the same.
In my reading, the connection between them became clear. Both Krishna and Kali annihilate the ego. Both seduce, devour, and re-create the self. Krishna does it through lila, divine play. Kali does it through mahapralaya, the final dissolution. One is blue like the infinite sky, the other black like the womb of creation. But both carry within them the echo of the cosmic “ॐ”—a vibration both tender and terrifying.
There’s a line in the book that still strikes like a bell in my memory: that in Hinduism, the ultimate is not tame. It is not domesticated. The divine is not here to be safe—it is here to be real. And that, I think, is the power of this work. Kinsley dares to present the divine not as comfort food, but as wild fire. Not as the end of questions, but as the beginning of awe.
Nearly twenty years later, I still return to The Sword and the Flute. Not because I seek knowledge, but because I seek permission. Permission to feel rage and still be held. Permission to see the divine in contradiction. Permission to bleed and still be beautiful. After all, she who drinks blood also gives birth. That is Ma.
ॐ क्रीं कालिकायै नमः।
November 17, 2025
To accept one’s mortality is to be able to act superfluously, to let go, to be able to sing, dance, and shout. To win Kali’s boon is to become childlike, to be flexible, open, and naive like a child. It is to act and be like Ramakrishna, who delighted in the world as Kali’s play, who acted without calculation and behaved like a fool or a child.
January 7, 2026
The stars are blotted out,
Clouds are covering clouds,
It is darkness, vibrant, sonant.
In the roaring whirling wind
Are the souls of a million lunatics,—
Just loose from the prison house,—
Wrenching trees by the roots,
Sweeping all from the path.
The sea has joined the fray,
And swirls up mountain-waves,
To reach the pitchy sky.
The flash of lurid light
Reveals on every side
A thousand, thousand shades
Of Death begrimed and black—
Scattering plagues and sorrows,
Dancing mad with joy,
Come, Mother, Come!
For Terror is thy name,
Death is in Thy breath,
And every shaking step
Destroys a world for e’er.
Thou “Time,” the All-Destroyer!
Come, Mother, Come!
Who dares misery love,
And hugs the form of Death—
Dance in destruction’s dance,
To him the Mother comes.
(as cited in Sister Nivedita, Kali the Mother)
Clouds are covering clouds,
It is darkness, vibrant, sonant.
In the roaring whirling wind
Are the souls of a million lunatics,—
Just loose from the prison house,—
Wrenching trees by the roots,
Sweeping all from the path.
The sea has joined the fray,
And swirls up mountain-waves,
To reach the pitchy sky.
The flash of lurid light
Reveals on every side
A thousand, thousand shades
Of Death begrimed and black—
Scattering plagues and sorrows,
Dancing mad with joy,
Come, Mother, Come!
For Terror is thy name,
Death is in Thy breath,
And every shaking step
Destroys a world for e’er.
Thou “Time,” the All-Destroyer!
Come, Mother, Come!
Who dares misery love,
And hugs the form of Death—
Dance in destruction’s dance,
To him the Mother comes.
(as cited in Sister Nivedita, Kali the Mother)
April 28, 2018
It's quite a beautiful look at Krishna + Kali in the context of the Hindu Goddesses and Gods. It touches upon them as powers and qualities within us, but indirectly. I recommend it and found it to be quite enjoyable. A testament to the pursuit of the Divine Consciousness being a going against the flow of ordered human existence (civilization).
July 30, 2019
An interesting read on the similarities between Krishna and Kali. Is a great book to start out with if you are wanting to research the harmonies and duality between the terms sacred and profane. If you are new to all of the gray areas that Eastern philosophies and Hinduism can cover this book may shock you, but it will lead you to more.
November 15, 2023
I read this book for the first time a decade ago during my linguistics studies. Having read it again, I can say it’s simply brilliant.
December 9, 2016
The Kali chapters are more interesting than the Krishna chapters. I haven't read many straight religious study texts before, so I do not have much to set a standard by. There was some interesting information there that will help inform some of my other readings. There were some guesses made about the meanings of various things, and some disagreements with guesses that other people have made. Nothing terribly outlandish.
August 8, 2013
This is an important work in the canon of Hinduism and studies of Kali. I read this years ago, and it has had a strong influence on my understanding of Hinduism and Indian culture. Kinsley is a foremost scholar in this field. I'd recommend this book as a prime source. Compelling reading.
February 27, 2016
this is great book when one is interested to know about krsna and gopi amorous love affair..one will begin to discover the secret of krsna devotees highest goal...radha controled the cowherd boy krsna. instead of a god who is always in control...learn the secret of krsna flute.
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews