What do you think?
Rate this book
Lady of the Butterflies
AKA Rebel Heiress
On the ancient marshlands of Somerset - a place of mists and magic - a girl grows up in the shadow of the English Civil War, knowing that one day she will inherit the rich estate which belonged to her late mother. Her father, a stern but loving Puritan, once a distinguished soldier in Cromwell's army, fears for his daughter in the poisonous aftermath of the war, and for her vulnerability as an heiress. But above all he fears and misunderstands her scientific passion for butterflies.
The girl is Eleanor Glanville, destined to become one of the most famous entomologists in history, bequeathing her name to the rare butterfly which she discovered, the Glanville Fritillary. But not before she had endured a life of quite extraordinary vicissitude. Two marriages and an all-consuming love, which proved her undoing, a deep friendship with one of the great scientists of the day and finally, a trial for lunacy (on the grounds that no sane person would pursue butterflies). The dramatic events of her life are played out against the violent events of the Monmouth Rebellion and the vicious controversy over whether or not to drain the Somerset marshes (what is now the M5 motorway runs across Kings Sedgemoor Drain - one of the first great ditches which reclaimed the land for farming and destroyed this precious natural habitat).
On the ancient marshlands of Somerset - a place of mists and magic - a girl grows up in the shadow of the English Civil War, knowing that one day she will inherit the rich estate which belonged to her late mother. Her father, a stern but loving Puritan, once a distinguished soldier in Cromwell's army, fears for his daughter in the poisonous aftermath of the war, and for her vulnerability as an heiress. But above all he fears and misunderstands her scientific passion for butterflies.
The girl is Eleanor Glanville, destined to become one of the most famous entomologists in history, bequeathing her name to the rare butterfly which she discovered, the Glanville Fritillary. But not before she had endured a life of quite extraordinary vicissitude. Two marriages and an all-consuming love, which proved her undoing, a deep friendship with one of the great scientists of the day and finally, a trial for lunacy (on the grounds that no sane person would pursue butterflies). The dramatic events of her life are played out against the violent events of the Monmouth Rebellion and the vicious controversy over whether or not to drain the Somerset marshes (what is now the M5 motorway runs across Kings Sedgemoor Drain - one of the first great ditches which reclaimed the land for farming and destroyed this precious natural habitat).
533 pages, Hardcover
First published August 11, 2009
45 people are currently reading
2818 people want to read
About the author
Fiona Mountain
13 books49 followersFiona Mountain grew up in Sheffield and moved to London aged eighteen where she worked in the press office for Radio 1 for ten years, handling the PR for presenters including John Peel, Mark Radlcliffe and Steve Wright and traveling with the Radio 1 Summer Roadshow.
Her first novel, Isabella, tells the haunting love story of Bounty mutineer Fletcher Christian and his cousin, Isabella Curwen. It was short-listed for the Romantic Novel of the Year Award in 2000, the first debut novel to reach the shortlist. It was followed with Pale as the Dead and Bloodline, which combine history with mystery and feature 'ancestor detective', Natasha Blake. Bloodline is the winner of the prestigious Mary Higgins Clark Award.
Fiona's novels have been published in America, Canada, Japan, Thailand, Italy, Germany, Holland and Australia. Though having enjoyed writing the mysteries, Lady of the Butterflies, published in 2009, marks her permanent return to historical fiction.
She lives in a seventeenth century house in the Cotswolds with her husband, Tim, a musician, and their four young children.
Her new book, 'The Keeper of Songs' out in 2021.
Her first novel, Isabella, tells the haunting love story of Bounty mutineer Fletcher Christian and his cousin, Isabella Curwen. It was short-listed for the Romantic Novel of the Year Award in 2000, the first debut novel to reach the shortlist. It was followed with Pale as the Dead and Bloodline, which combine history with mystery and feature 'ancestor detective', Natasha Blake. Bloodline is the winner of the prestigious Mary Higgins Clark Award.
Fiona's novels have been published in America, Canada, Japan, Thailand, Italy, Germany, Holland and Australia. Though having enjoyed writing the mysteries, Lady of the Butterflies, published in 2009, marks her permanent return to historical fiction.
She lives in a seventeenth century house in the Cotswolds with her husband, Tim, a musician, and their four young children.
Her new book, 'The Keeper of Songs' out in 2021.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews
August 2, 2010
First of all, a complaint regarding so many reviews I've seen about this book in which the protagonist's name is spelled incorrectly. Did you seriously even read the book? Did you miss the fact that this book is based on a real person? Hello, it's Eleanor Glanville. How do you read an entire book about someone and then misspell the main character's last name? Glanville. Say it with me. It's not Granville. I'm embarrassed for you.
Moving on.
I don't often do the whole historical romance thing because heaving bosoms isn't generally my thing. But this ARC crossed my path and I ran with it, and I can honestly say I rather enjoyed it. The story traces the life and times of Eleanor Glanville, a 17th-century entomologist whose particular interest was in butterflies. Her interest was encouraged by her father from a young age, rather unheard of for the time, and her scientific nature got her in some trouble later on in life when her second husband and her first son (from her first marriage) tried to pass her off as insane. You know, women shouldn't be all smart and all, it makes their menfolk look dumber than they might be.
There were a few occasions that I was concerned it would be a little too melodramatic for my tastes. When I read historical fiction I want to be able to learn something, and Glanville's relationships with men was not what I was interested in discovering. Her studies were what drew me into the story, but that aspect of her life was often overshadowed by her sexual experiences. (I know, I know - sex sells, blah, blah, blah.)
Overall though, I was enthralled throughout. Fiona Mountain seems to be a fabulous writer with a true interest in telling a story. She clearly did research on the politics of the time, the day-to-day life experiences a woman might have at in the 1600s in England, even the clothing the characters wore. Since this was an ARC I can't comment on the final publication that hit stores this month, but even for an ARC I thought it was fantastic. If you're into historical fiction (historical romances even), knock yourself out. And if you're just in it for the science and the pretty butterflies like myself, you still probably won't be disappointed.
Moving on.
I don't often do the whole historical romance thing because heaving bosoms isn't generally my thing. But this ARC crossed my path and I ran with it, and I can honestly say I rather enjoyed it. The story traces the life and times of Eleanor Glanville, a 17th-century entomologist whose particular interest was in butterflies. Her interest was encouraged by her father from a young age, rather unheard of for the time, and her scientific nature got her in some trouble later on in life when her second husband and her first son (from her first marriage) tried to pass her off as insane. You know, women shouldn't be all smart and all, it makes their menfolk look dumber than they might be.
There were a few occasions that I was concerned it would be a little too melodramatic for my tastes. When I read historical fiction I want to be able to learn something, and Glanville's relationships with men was not what I was interested in discovering. Her studies were what drew me into the story, but that aspect of her life was often overshadowed by her sexual experiences. (I know, I know - sex sells, blah, blah, blah.)
Overall though, I was enthralled throughout. Fiona Mountain seems to be a fabulous writer with a true interest in telling a story. She clearly did research on the politics of the time, the day-to-day life experiences a woman might have at in the 1600s in England, even the clothing the characters wore. Since this was an ARC I can't comment on the final publication that hit stores this month, but even for an ARC I thought it was fantastic. If you're into historical fiction (historical romances even), knock yourself out. And if you're just in it for the science and the pretty butterflies like myself, you still probably won't be disappointed.
August 8, 2025
a super fascinating dive into the life of scientist eleanor glanville! i loved (and also hated) the characters and wow what a powerhouse of a woman
4 stars
4 stars
March 22, 2019
1662, Somerset, England
Nine year old Eleanor Goodricke is already known as unusual child: “…climbing trees for birds’ eggs, pond dipping and hunting under rocks for beetles and whatnot.” Keeping “a collection of animal skulls and bones in a little casket in her chamber.”
As much as her Puritan father rails against Catholics and Cavaliers, it makes her that much more interested in both.
Despite that, he is someone scholarly, who has a curious mind and eagerness for knowledge, which he passes on to his daughter. He is the one who introduces her to butterflies. He shows her a little worm and explains how it evolves into a beautiful butterfly.
Upon meeting Edmund Ashfield, she is very impressed by him, and him finding her curious questions interesting and not rude. She is even more intrigued upon hearing about his best friend Richard Glanville. “The Cavalier. The fine horseman and swordsman.” Just his name and being Cavalier evokes something inside her.
At the age of 22, she gets her chance to meet the man she’s been dreaming about.
Eleanor is such a likeable person; her passion for nature and variety of living organisms is very vivid, but her story progresses at a very slow pace. It is rather a tedious read.
@FB/BestHistoricalFiction
Nine year old Eleanor Goodricke is already known as unusual child: “…climbing trees for birds’ eggs, pond dipping and hunting under rocks for beetles and whatnot.” Keeping “a collection of animal skulls and bones in a little casket in her chamber.”
As much as her Puritan father rails against Catholics and Cavaliers, it makes her that much more interested in both.
Despite that, he is someone scholarly, who has a curious mind and eagerness for knowledge, which he passes on to his daughter. He is the one who introduces her to butterflies. He shows her a little worm and explains how it evolves into a beautiful butterfly.
Upon meeting Edmund Ashfield, she is very impressed by him, and him finding her curious questions interesting and not rude. She is even more intrigued upon hearing about his best friend Richard Glanville. “The Cavalier. The fine horseman and swordsman.” Just his name and being Cavalier evokes something inside her.
At the age of 22, she gets her chance to meet the man she’s been dreaming about.
Eleanor is such a likeable person; her passion for nature and variety of living organisms is very vivid, but her story progresses at a very slow pace. It is rather a tedious read.
@FB/BestHistoricalFiction
December 22, 2018
Lady of the Butterflies (Fiona Mountain)
This is the story of Eleanor Glanville, daughter of a Puritan Nobleman on the marshlands of England. Set in the 17th century, it chronicles her life, from childhood to adulthood.
Family tragedies, war, betrayals & passion occur. Eleanor is not the average woman, she is a woman "before her times". She has an obsessive interest in science, particularly that of butterflies. This causes the town people to think her, mad, crazed, even a witch. She is a passionate woman, with a lustful scandalous obsession, that adds to her troubles. Despite the challenges she faces, she becomes a pioneer of science, juggling family and estate.
A true fascinating tale, based on the life of Eleanor Glanville. Ms. Mountain is descriptive in detail of the times. Also well researched I learned a lot about butteries. I highly recommend to those who love historical fiction based upon actual historical people.
* I won on GR'S give-a-ways
This is the story of Eleanor Glanville, daughter of a Puritan Nobleman on the marshlands of England. Set in the 17th century, it chronicles her life, from childhood to adulthood.
Family tragedies, war, betrayals & passion occur. Eleanor is not the average woman, she is a woman "before her times". She has an obsessive interest in science, particularly that of butterflies. This causes the town people to think her, mad, crazed, even a witch. She is a passionate woman, with a lustful scandalous obsession, that adds to her troubles. Despite the challenges she faces, she becomes a pioneer of science, juggling family and estate.
A true fascinating tale, based on the life of Eleanor Glanville. Ms. Mountain is descriptive in detail of the times. Also well researched I learned a lot about butteries. I highly recommend to those who love historical fiction based upon actual historical people.
* I won on GR'S give-a-ways
July 14, 2011
In Lady of the Butterflies, author Fiona Mountain tackles the life of the spirited and tenacious Eleanor Glanville. Known today as one of the pioneer entomologists of the 17th century, Eleanor was an anomaly among the women of her day and her personal life was no less captivating.
Raised by her staunch Puritan father after the death of her mother and sister, Eleanor’s childhood was sheltered and lonely. For a child whose very soul craved fresh air, freedom and nature, she found it difficult to adhere to the restrictions of her father’s religion. Though education was for boys, Eleanor’s father encouraged her studies in nature, especially her love of butterflies, as to him they were a sign from God of hope and eternal life. Not everyone appreciated Eleanor’s inquisitive nature, though and townspeople were sure she was a little touched in the head. After all, this was the 17th century and superstition rampant in small towns, with many still believing that butterflies are souls of the undead and to study them is akin to witchcraft.
Through love, passion, heartache and diversity, readers follow Eleanor through her life as a mother, wife, lover and scientist. At the soul of the novel, is Eleanor’s passionate love affair with the devastatingly charming Richard Glanville. With all its beautiful complexities and layers, I was entranced by the intensity of their relationship.
A mix of historical fact and the author’s imagination, Lady of the Butterflies is an elegantly written novel that kept me up til all hours of the night and had me utterly gripped from page one. I have since added her other books to my wishlist and will be recommending this novel to everyone I know! Never again will I look at butterflies without thinking of the extraordinary Eleanor Glanville.
Raised by her staunch Puritan father after the death of her mother and sister, Eleanor’s childhood was sheltered and lonely. For a child whose very soul craved fresh air, freedom and nature, she found it difficult to adhere to the restrictions of her father’s religion. Though education was for boys, Eleanor’s father encouraged her studies in nature, especially her love of butterflies, as to him they were a sign from God of hope and eternal life. Not everyone appreciated Eleanor’s inquisitive nature, though and townspeople were sure she was a little touched in the head. After all, this was the 17th century and superstition rampant in small towns, with many still believing that butterflies are souls of the undead and to study them is akin to witchcraft.
Through love, passion, heartache and diversity, readers follow Eleanor through her life as a mother, wife, lover and scientist. At the soul of the novel, is Eleanor’s passionate love affair with the devastatingly charming Richard Glanville. With all its beautiful complexities and layers, I was entranced by the intensity of their relationship.
A mix of historical fact and the author’s imagination, Lady of the Butterflies is an elegantly written novel that kept me up til all hours of the night and had me utterly gripped from page one. I have since added her other books to my wishlist and will be recommending this novel to everyone I know! Never again will I look at butterflies without thinking of the extraordinary Eleanor Glanville.
June 20, 2010
WOW! I read this book in two days! I couldn't wait to get started on it as soon as I read the book description and found out I was getting an advance reader copy. I opened the front cover when I got it and couldn't put it down.
This author was such a fabulous writer!!! She based the book on fact, filled it with such rich history, facts on the study of butterflies and how it came about that the women in the book started studying them. You felt as if you were there with the characters and the descriptions of the countryside. You can't put the book down you are so drawn into the story, and can't wait to see what is going to happen next in her life. The story at the end of how the writer came across her story (Eleanor's) how she found out all of the information on her life and that of her husbands, children, and that of the others in the story is as fascinating as the book itself.
If you don't buy another book this year, pick this one up! I guarantee whomever you may be you will love this book. I wish I could give it more than five stars!
This book was based on the 17th century life of Eleanor Glanville, who grew up on the ancient marshlands of Somerset, her life marked by two reckless passions, a fascination with natural history and butterflies in particular, and a tempestuous love affair with the dashing soldier Richard Glanville -- a romance that nearly cost her everything.
In a world where butterflies were believed to be the souls of the dead, Eleanor was regarded as little better than a witch. But her story -- set against a backdrop of war, betrayal and sexual obsession-- is the life of a truly great scientific pioneer, a passionate women far ahead of her time.
This author was such a fabulous writer!!! She based the book on fact, filled it with such rich history, facts on the study of butterflies and how it came about that the women in the book started studying them. You felt as if you were there with the characters and the descriptions of the countryside. You can't put the book down you are so drawn into the story, and can't wait to see what is going to happen next in her life. The story at the end of how the writer came across her story (Eleanor's) how she found out all of the information on her life and that of her husbands, children, and that of the others in the story is as fascinating as the book itself.
If you don't buy another book this year, pick this one up! I guarantee whomever you may be you will love this book. I wish I could give it more than five stars!
This book was based on the 17th century life of Eleanor Glanville, who grew up on the ancient marshlands of Somerset, her life marked by two reckless passions, a fascination with natural history and butterflies in particular, and a tempestuous love affair with the dashing soldier Richard Glanville -- a romance that nearly cost her everything.
In a world where butterflies were believed to be the souls of the dead, Eleanor was regarded as little better than a witch. But her story -- set against a backdrop of war, betrayal and sexual obsession-- is the life of a truly great scientific pioneer, a passionate women far ahead of her time.
June 29, 2011
Beauty AND brains. That is the ideal combination to a man, right? If so, then Eleanor Glanville had it all. Class, as the daughter of a nobleman and intelligence with a love and knack for science. As a female who graduated college with a 4.0 GPA, I welcome ANY book telling the tale of a strong, intellectual female.
Fiona Mountain truly wrote a beautiful work with Lady of the Butterflies. Combining elements of dedicated intelligence with obessesion (Eleanor tends to pick science experimentation over her children at times); Lady of the Butterflies is emotional, vivid, and will leave you clamboring for more details. Which is easy to do, because the novel is a smooth, exciting read. I know we hear this often, but you seriously won't be able to put this one down.
Filled with well-known scientists, this book is both a history lesson and a the plot of period-piece film. Another strong female in history but one not as discussed, Lady of the Butterflies is a must-read.
Fiona Mountain truly wrote a beautiful work with Lady of the Butterflies. Combining elements of dedicated intelligence with obessesion (Eleanor tends to pick science experimentation over her children at times); Lady of the Butterflies is emotional, vivid, and will leave you clamboring for more details. Which is easy to do, because the novel is a smooth, exciting read. I know we hear this often, but you seriously won't be able to put this one down.
Filled with well-known scientists, this book is both a history lesson and a the plot of period-piece film. Another strong female in history but one not as discussed, Lady of the Butterflies is a must-read.
December 2, 2010
This is one of the best pieces of historical fiction I have read in a long time. Impeccably researched and beautifully written, the metaphor of the butterfly is applied brilliantly to this tale of Eleanor Glanville, a woman scientist ahead of her time. Mountain does a very good job of using the available facts (it is a true story) to make a compelling narrative. From the opening where Nell is a misunderstood child, through the trials of war and rebellion, her turbulent love life, and her tussle with the fenland,this novel grips right until her "re-birth" at the end of the book(I won't tell you how). I shall be highly recommending it as a partner-read to those who read my book "The Lady's Slipper" which is also set in the 17th century.
dnf
August 6, 2010Just didn't grab me. Lovely writing style if a bit too descriptive at times.. Author obviously has talent. The problem for me is: I'm not interested in the draining of England's swamps and rivers or Puritans. For me to spend 4 days reading a 500 page novel, it must GRAB me and hold me. This particular tale is too slow for my taste. If was cropped to 300 pages or thereabouts and got to the point, I would probably love it. Thus, DNF.
April 9, 2011
Author Shows Promise But This Novel Is Inconsistant
This is the first novel I've read by Fiona Mountain and it started out well enough. I enjoyed the many details of the period; the story begins with a prologue set in 1695 then starts in earnest in 1662 when Eleanor Goodricke is a nine year old girl growing up in the village of Tickenham, England.
Mountain does an excellent job setting the place and the politics of the period with details about Roundheads, Cavaliers, Puritan values and prejudices, the conflicts over draining the Fens, the tradition of Guy Fawkes Day and beliefs about the natural world including butterflies.
The book itself is beautiful; the cover art on the dust jacket, the end pages with illustrations of butterflies, and the title page with its lovely illustration of butterflies and beautiful lettering. The novel is told in four parts, the page marking each part of the story is illustrated with butterflies in various stages of development and each chapter has a lovely image reflecting the season the chapter takes place in. Even the first letter of every chapter is richly embellished and beautiful. I am a reader who appreciates this type of detail.
Unfortunately the story itself doesn't maintain the same kind of attention to detail. While the beginning is very good and shows great promise the quality falls off rather dramatically around page three hundred and fifteen when it seems to turn itself into a romance novel. A romance complete with characters whose attraction and chemistry does not come across to the reader, events that are unbelievable and lack any feel of authenticity as well as the clichéd turn of events that serve only to stretch tension and suspense but which did nothing but disappoint this reader.
The ending somewhat redeems the story by elaborating on the relationship between Eleanor and James Petiver, the distinguished entomologist. I was looking forward to reading about Eleanor's obsession with butterflies and didn't feel very satisfied in that regard, the ending does shed more light on that aspect of her life. However, even amid the wonder of science and the fascination with observing metamorphosis there is still a moment where events that unfold will only appeal to fans of the cheesy romance novel.
I think this author could have a future writing great historical fiction if she decides to abandon the clichéd techniques of the romance novelist. This was an interesting story and I enjoyed parts of it but was disappointed in the lack of butterflies and the abundance of romance. Fans of romance novels will likely love this novel, for those readers I would highly recommend this book.
This is the first novel I've read by Fiona Mountain and it started out well enough. I enjoyed the many details of the period; the story begins with a prologue set in 1695 then starts in earnest in 1662 when Eleanor Goodricke is a nine year old girl growing up in the village of Tickenham, England.
Mountain does an excellent job setting the place and the politics of the period with details about Roundheads, Cavaliers, Puritan values and prejudices, the conflicts over draining the Fens, the tradition of Guy Fawkes Day and beliefs about the natural world including butterflies.
The book itself is beautiful; the cover art on the dust jacket, the end pages with illustrations of butterflies, and the title page with its lovely illustration of butterflies and beautiful lettering. The novel is told in four parts, the page marking each part of the story is illustrated with butterflies in various stages of development and each chapter has a lovely image reflecting the season the chapter takes place in. Even the first letter of every chapter is richly embellished and beautiful. I am a reader who appreciates this type of detail.
Unfortunately the story itself doesn't maintain the same kind of attention to detail. While the beginning is very good and shows great promise the quality falls off rather dramatically around page three hundred and fifteen when it seems to turn itself into a romance novel. A romance complete with characters whose attraction and chemistry does not come across to the reader, events that are unbelievable and lack any feel of authenticity as well as the clichéd turn of events that serve only to stretch tension and suspense but which did nothing but disappoint this reader.
The ending somewhat redeems the story by elaborating on the relationship between Eleanor and James Petiver, the distinguished entomologist. I was looking forward to reading about Eleanor's obsession with butterflies and didn't feel very satisfied in that regard, the ending does shed more light on that aspect of her life. However, even amid the wonder of science and the fascination with observing metamorphosis there is still a moment where events that unfold will only appeal to fans of the cheesy romance novel.
I think this author could have a future writing great historical fiction if she decides to abandon the clichéd techniques of the romance novelist. This was an interesting story and I enjoyed parts of it but was disappointed in the lack of butterflies and the abundance of romance. Fans of romance novels will likely love this novel, for those readers I would highly recommend this book.
August 26, 2013
2 1/2 stars-
I hate it when I have a love-hate relationship with a book. It makes deciding to keep reading or dump difficult. It also makes rating difficult. I’m going with 3 stars, but my real rating is like 2 ½ stars . I usually round up if I think a book is worth checking out and even though I found some parts of this book irritating I do think it is worth looking into.
The beginning parts were interesting. Eleanor’s relationship with her father was rather fascinating to me. While he was a strict Puritan, he was also open-minded to new ideas and seemed to indulge Eleanor when it came to her education. You would think this would make him likeable, but he was also a complete jerk sometimes. It made him a well rounded character.
Eleanor, however…I don’t know. I liked her sometimes, but other times I just wanted throttle to her. She was just so darn naïve. While, I realize her personality was mostly due to her strict Puritan upbringing and lack of experience as she grew her naivety didn’t go away. Her constant mooning over Edward and then Richard just about did me in. Those are the parts where this book read more like a sappy romance and less as a historical fiction. And this led to weird pacing in the book. The parts that shined were the beautiful scenery descriptions, talk of the political times and Eleanor’s butterfly discoveries, but I felt like I had to wade through all the romance drama to get to those good parts. By the end of the book the only character I really liked was James Petiver, the apothecary who introduced Eleanor to entomology.
While it seems the ending stayed true to life, I had a hard time understanding Eleanor and Richard’s convoluted marriage. I also didn’t understand Eleanor’s decision at the end.
Anyway, by this review it may seem like I didn’t like this book, but for the most part it was likeable. The scientific sections of the book were fascinating. I haven’t read much HF having to do with Puritan beliefs or the politics of this time nor had I even heard of Eleanor and her contributions to science. This book was educational on that front and it led me to google more about her, so it does earn some kudos.
I hate it when I have a love-hate relationship with a book. It makes deciding to keep reading or dump difficult. It also makes rating difficult. I’m going with 3 stars, but my real rating is like 2 ½ stars . I usually round up if I think a book is worth checking out and even though I found some parts of this book irritating I do think it is worth looking into.
The beginning parts were interesting. Eleanor’s relationship with her father was rather fascinating to me. While he was a strict Puritan, he was also open-minded to new ideas and seemed to indulge Eleanor when it came to her education. You would think this would make him likeable, but he was also a complete jerk sometimes. It made him a well rounded character.
Eleanor, however…I don’t know. I liked her sometimes, but other times I just wanted throttle to her. She was just so darn naïve. While, I realize her personality was mostly due to her strict Puritan upbringing and lack of experience as she grew her naivety didn’t go away. Her constant mooning over Edward and then Richard just about did me in. Those are the parts where this book read more like a sappy romance and less as a historical fiction. And this led to weird pacing in the book. The parts that shined were the beautiful scenery descriptions, talk of the political times and Eleanor’s butterfly discoveries, but I felt like I had to wade through all the romance drama to get to those good parts. By the end of the book the only character I really liked was James Petiver, the apothecary who introduced Eleanor to entomology.
While it seems the ending stayed true to life, I had a hard time understanding Eleanor and Richard’s convoluted marriage. I also didn’t understand Eleanor’s decision at the end.
Anyway, by this review it may seem like I didn’t like this book, but for the most part it was likeable. The scientific sections of the book were fascinating. I haven’t read much HF having to do with Puritan beliefs or the politics of this time nor had I even heard of Eleanor and her contributions to science. This book was educational on that front and it led me to google more about her, so it does earn some kudos.
December 31, 2009
This book takes place after the English Civil War. Eleanor is a daughter of a puritan lord of a manor. She had an infatuation of butterflies. After he dies of the plague, she inherits the manor and marries a man called Richard. They have two kids. After he dies, Eleanor marries Edmund, a cavalier. They also have two kids. All the while, Eleanor hangs out with this guy named James who runs an apocathery and is infatuated with butterflies. Then, things go crazy and Eleanor goes to America where she can study butterflies freely and renames herself Hannah.
This whole thing is like a very complicated love story. Should have said "Lady of Lovesickness" instead of "Lady of the Butterflies" Every page seems to be about "Edmund.. Oh, Edmund..." and then suddenly "But Richard is good-looking, too....". Fiona Mountain also devotedly spent a lot of time on the description of lovemaking, too. Its on the teetering edge between a lovestory and a fancy pornography. I wondered from time to time if this was adults only or something. That does not mean it doesn't mention the butterflies. Eleanor is infatuated with them. That is how she meets James and also the source of conflict in a lot of cases. In the end, she goes to America for a new life and the freedom to catch and research butterflies. However, it looks like love life is the main thing and butterflies or fueling it, a secondary thing. Or maybe its just because I'm not an expert on grading and critisizing books.
The issue in this book is that Eleanor likes to collect and study butterflies. Nowadays, it is free to do so and the only problem is that there are no butterfiles. Back then, however, butterflies in England were considered the souls of the dead. Naturally, people in this book found butterfly-catching a little bit odd (witch-odd). But Eleanor does not back down and continues her studies of the insects. This reminds me of our ever-growing problem of stereotypes. We have stereotypes all around us and in this book, it's a nation-wide one. A stereotypes about witches and butterflies, for example. Although we might say that its a free world and people can do whatever they want, we base people on what they do. I think this book reflects on that problem and I wonder when it will ever stop.
This whole thing is like a very complicated love story. Should have said "Lady of Lovesickness" instead of "Lady of the Butterflies" Every page seems to be about "Edmund.. Oh, Edmund..." and then suddenly "But Richard is good-looking, too....". Fiona Mountain also devotedly spent a lot of time on the description of lovemaking, too. Its on the teetering edge between a lovestory and a fancy pornography. I wondered from time to time if this was adults only or something. That does not mean it doesn't mention the butterflies. Eleanor is infatuated with them. That is how she meets James and also the source of conflict in a lot of cases. In the end, she goes to America for a new life and the freedom to catch and research butterflies. However, it looks like love life is the main thing and butterflies or fueling it, a secondary thing. Or maybe its just because I'm not an expert on grading and critisizing books.
The issue in this book is that Eleanor likes to collect and study butterflies. Nowadays, it is free to do so and the only problem is that there are no butterfiles. Back then, however, butterflies in England were considered the souls of the dead. Naturally, people in this book found butterfly-catching a little bit odd (witch-odd). But Eleanor does not back down and continues her studies of the insects. This reminds me of our ever-growing problem of stereotypes. We have stereotypes all around us and in this book, it's a nation-wide one. A stereotypes about witches and butterflies, for example. Although we might say that its a free world and people can do whatever they want, we base people on what they do. I think this book reflects on that problem and I wonder when it will ever stop.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 4, 2013
An engrossing story of passionate relationships, of scientific discovery and of a turbulent period in English history. Add to this a woman fighting for her rights against all the odds made this a winner for me. Based on the factual story of Eleanor Goodricke, a woman born ahead of her time, fearless in her search for knowledge, love, happiness and fulfilment, this book is well-written and excellently researched. I gave it four stars because I thought it perhaps a little too long, but wouldn't hesitate to recommend it to fans of historical fiction.
March 6, 2012
Reviewed By~April
Review Copy Provided By~Publisher
Historical Fiction beautifully brought to life through the eyes of a lovely and talented author, Fiona Mountain. Ms. Mountain takes the true life story, struggles and discoveries of Eleanor Glanville and brings forth an epic story that will mesmerize many, in Lady of the Butterflies.
To be honest, I did not even realize this was a true story based novel until the very end. That knowledge added an extra depth and appreciation to my perception of the story. I am always amazed and transfixed to read stories of how life once was and how horribly women were once thought as (perhaps not "horrible" but demeaning and unimportant, per-say). This life never ceases to amaze and appall me. Lady of the Butterflies takes place during the time frame of 1662 through 1700, a time when woman were taught to be submissive, take on no education and are owned by their husbands to do with what they please - this includes hitting, beating, etc. What is to happen when a young girl is full of curiosity, adventure and with a father who enables such traits by educating her and encouraging her? What is to happen when this girl's father dies by disease and is left with no one who understands how to care for such a child?
This is the life and story of Eleanor Glanville who has always had a deep love and curiosity of life around her. She is a courageous, brilliant and wonderful character who I could not help but fall instantly in love with. Her appreciation of life and the natural God-given gifts provided by nature is lovely and wonderful. I loved her fixation with the butterflies and her unselfishness. I also loved learning about the discovery and usefulness of herbs and the area of apothecary. Lady of the Butterflies was not only an entertaining and emotionally charged story, it was truly interesting and educational.
Lady of the Butterflies is one of those books that tears me. Why? It was extremely well written, engrossing and informative; however, on the flip side, the story was rather long and dragged on at times. Perhaps that is just my perception, but for whatever it is worth, that is my thought. This is a story that goes beyond a historical fictional novel and leans more toward an epic story. The writing is incredibly beautiful, thought-provoking and poetic. While parts did run rather descriptively long, the overall appeal of the story was great. For lovers of historical fiction, I recommend Lady of the Butterflies. Be aware that this is not an overly light read, but one that will satisfy and perhaps even pique an interest to delve further into Eleanor's life and history, her children and husbands, and the true life of other characters within the story. I know that I am anxious to do some research of my own now. I also greatly look forward to reading more works by Fiona Mountain!
Favorite Quote: "In part, no doubt. But as far back as the ancient Greeks, it has been believed that butterflies represent the souls of the dead. They are a token, Eleanor, a promise. A caterpillar begins as a greedy worm, which surely represents the baseness of our life on earth. Then they are entombed, just as we are entombed in the grave. They emerge on glorious wings, just as the bodies of the dead will rise at the sound of the last trumpet on the final Judgment Day. God put butterflies on this earth to remind us of paradise, of His promise of eternal life. To give us hope."
Review Copy Provided By~Publisher
Historical Fiction beautifully brought to life through the eyes of a lovely and talented author, Fiona Mountain. Ms. Mountain takes the true life story, struggles and discoveries of Eleanor Glanville and brings forth an epic story that will mesmerize many, in Lady of the Butterflies.
To be honest, I did not even realize this was a true story based novel until the very end. That knowledge added an extra depth and appreciation to my perception of the story. I am always amazed and transfixed to read stories of how life once was and how horribly women were once thought as (perhaps not "horrible" but demeaning and unimportant, per-say). This life never ceases to amaze and appall me. Lady of the Butterflies takes place during the time frame of 1662 through 1700, a time when woman were taught to be submissive, take on no education and are owned by their husbands to do with what they please - this includes hitting, beating, etc. What is to happen when a young girl is full of curiosity, adventure and with a father who enables such traits by educating her and encouraging her? What is to happen when this girl's father dies by disease and is left with no one who understands how to care for such a child?
This is the life and story of Eleanor Glanville who has always had a deep love and curiosity of life around her. She is a courageous, brilliant and wonderful character who I could not help but fall instantly in love with. Her appreciation of life and the natural God-given gifts provided by nature is lovely and wonderful. I loved her fixation with the butterflies and her unselfishness. I also loved learning about the discovery and usefulness of herbs and the area of apothecary. Lady of the Butterflies was not only an entertaining and emotionally charged story, it was truly interesting and educational.
Lady of the Butterflies is one of those books that tears me. Why? It was extremely well written, engrossing and informative; however, on the flip side, the story was rather long and dragged on at times. Perhaps that is just my perception, but for whatever it is worth, that is my thought. This is a story that goes beyond a historical fictional novel and leans more toward an epic story. The writing is incredibly beautiful, thought-provoking and poetic. While parts did run rather descriptively long, the overall appeal of the story was great. For lovers of historical fiction, I recommend Lady of the Butterflies. Be aware that this is not an overly light read, but one that will satisfy and perhaps even pique an interest to delve further into Eleanor's life and history, her children and husbands, and the true life of other characters within the story. I know that I am anxious to do some research of my own now. I also greatly look forward to reading more works by Fiona Mountain!
Favorite Quote: "In part, no doubt. But as far back as the ancient Greeks, it has been believed that butterflies represent the souls of the dead. They are a token, Eleanor, a promise. A caterpillar begins as a greedy worm, which surely represents the baseness of our life on earth. Then they are entombed, just as we are entombed in the grave. They emerge on glorious wings, just as the bodies of the dead will rise at the sound of the last trumpet on the final Judgment Day. God put butterflies on this earth to remind us of paradise, of His promise of eternal life. To give us hope."
October 18, 2010
"What was the point of living if it was not to learn? There were things I wanted to know, that I couldn't live without knowing, couldn't die not knowing, or not at least without trying to find out." - Eleanor Glanville, Lady of the Butterflies
Fiona Mountain's debut novel Lady of the Butterflies is based around the life of entomologist Eleanor Glanville.
Eleanor grew up on the moors in Somerset, and was made heiress of Tickenham Court at her Puritan father's death. Eleanor was educated by her father in a manner that was unconvential for the time, teaching his daughter about the developing sciences as much as religion, and with little focus on "female tasks". This upbringing encouraged Eleanor's fascination with the natural world, and with butterflies in particular.
After her marriage to her first husband, Edmund Ashfield, and with plans in the works to drain the moors for prime grazing land doomed to fail, Eleanor's interest in butterflies wanes as she settles into domestic life and becomes a mother. However, at Edmund's sudden death she establishes a friendship with London apothecary James Petiver, whose interest and knowledge of butterflies re-sparks Eleanor's obsession.
Her second marriage to Richard Glanville proves disasterous, and so Eleanor distracts herself in the collection and recording of butterfly specimens. Through this process the connection between the condition of natural habitats and butterflies was made. It was also these collections that made her famous, some of which can now be seen in the British Natural History Museum, and which lead to the naming of the Glanville fritillary in recognition of her efforts.
However, Eleanor's family did not share this appreciation. They used her interest in butterflies to found claims that she was not of sound mind in order to turn over her will and claim her estate.
Whilst Eleanor's exact fate has not been established, Fiona Mountain provides one of the most inspriring and clever endings to Eleanor's story that truly reflects her passion and determination to be free, like the butterflies she dedicated her life to admiring. This is not just a novel about a woman with an interest in butterflies: It is a story about the amazing and inspiring life of a woman who refused to be dictated to and restricted by convention, and whose tireless work in the study of butterflies has provided us with the understanding necessary to ensure their survival.
A beautiful story, impeccably written, and highly recommended.
Fiona Mountain's debut novel Lady of the Butterflies is based around the life of entomologist Eleanor Glanville.
Eleanor grew up on the moors in Somerset, and was made heiress of Tickenham Court at her Puritan father's death. Eleanor was educated by her father in a manner that was unconvential for the time, teaching his daughter about the developing sciences as much as religion, and with little focus on "female tasks". This upbringing encouraged Eleanor's fascination with the natural world, and with butterflies in particular.
After her marriage to her first husband, Edmund Ashfield, and with plans in the works to drain the moors for prime grazing land doomed to fail, Eleanor's interest in butterflies wanes as she settles into domestic life and becomes a mother. However, at Edmund's sudden death she establishes a friendship with London apothecary James Petiver, whose interest and knowledge of butterflies re-sparks Eleanor's obsession.
Her second marriage to Richard Glanville proves disasterous, and so Eleanor distracts herself in the collection and recording of butterfly specimens. Through this process the connection between the condition of natural habitats and butterflies was made. It was also these collections that made her famous, some of which can now be seen in the British Natural History Museum, and which lead to the naming of the Glanville fritillary in recognition of her efforts.
However, Eleanor's family did not share this appreciation. They used her interest in butterflies to found claims that she was not of sound mind in order to turn over her will and claim her estate.
Whilst Eleanor's exact fate has not been established, Fiona Mountain provides one of the most inspriring and clever endings to Eleanor's story that truly reflects her passion and determination to be free, like the butterflies she dedicated her life to admiring. This is not just a novel about a woman with an interest in butterflies: It is a story about the amazing and inspiring life of a woman who refused to be dictated to and restricted by convention, and whose tireless work in the study of butterflies has provided us with the understanding necessary to ensure their survival.
A beautiful story, impeccably written, and highly recommended.
March 20, 2016
At a little over 650 pages, it's a long book, but as this is essentially the tale of a person's life, you can't expect it to be short. I did really enjoy this book although I've got to admit that I got to a certain point and I just wanted to be finished reading this book, so I ploughed on through it this morning so that I got to the end.
Set in the late 1700s after the English civil war, this is the fictionalised account of a real person's life - Eleanor Goodricke. She was born to a small estate in Sommerset where the land was marshy and would flood every year. Land drainage has been happening elsewhere in the country, and it is threatening to come to her lands, for there is money to be made in agriculture. It was interesting to read in this respect for the history of the land, particularly now as we are having increasing troubles with flooding in the UK and the realisation is slowly creeping up on people that we need to let the land be more natural if it is to cope with flooding (and yes, planting trees is a good idea). I also really enjoyed reading about Eleanor's life, in particular her lifelong fascination with butterflies. She was an early entomologist, and didn't get to branch out in the field as much as her interest and her ability could have taken her, simply because she was a woman. She also suffered with narrowmindedness and superstition because she was a woman who dared to have an interest - which made her a bit odd and therefore a handy target for people with axes to grind.
From childhood the book goes through her two marriages to two very different men, and an intellectual love affair, before ending in a solution that has to be entirely fictional, because no one actually knows what happened to her. I have to say I rather like the way Mountain decided to conclude Eleanor's later years. There are large sections in this book that are very heavy of emotions, oh-how-I-love-him, and all the feelings and thoughts of her sex life... so it does feel that it's tripping up into standard historical heavy-breathing romance. Which in some ways is realistic in that the life of the wife was something she would have done, perhaps one of the biggest passions she was "allowed"/"accepted" to have. But I also wish there had been more about all the natural history aspects and her entomologist life. But even in the relationships side of things, it's not all painted in shades of rose, but these men and women are complex characters, none completely good or bad, and many damaged by the effects of the civil war and subsequent rebellions.
Set in the late 1700s after the English civil war, this is the fictionalised account of a real person's life - Eleanor Goodricke. She was born to a small estate in Sommerset where the land was marshy and would flood every year. Land drainage has been happening elsewhere in the country, and it is threatening to come to her lands, for there is money to be made in agriculture. It was interesting to read in this respect for the history of the land, particularly now as we are having increasing troubles with flooding in the UK and the realisation is slowly creeping up on people that we need to let the land be more natural if it is to cope with flooding (and yes, planting trees is a good idea). I also really enjoyed reading about Eleanor's life, in particular her lifelong fascination with butterflies. She was an early entomologist, and didn't get to branch out in the field as much as her interest and her ability could have taken her, simply because she was a woman. She also suffered with narrowmindedness and superstition because she was a woman who dared to have an interest - which made her a bit odd and therefore a handy target for people with axes to grind.
From childhood the book goes through her two marriages to two very different men, and an intellectual love affair, before ending in a solution that has to be entirely fictional, because no one actually knows what happened to her. I have to say I rather like the way Mountain decided to conclude Eleanor's later years. There are large sections in this book that are very heavy of emotions, oh-how-I-love-him, and all the feelings and thoughts of her sex life... so it does feel that it's tripping up into standard historical heavy-breathing romance. Which in some ways is realistic in that the life of the wife was something she would have done, perhaps one of the biggest passions she was "allowed"/"accepted" to have. But I also wish there had been more about all the natural history aspects and her entomologist life. But even in the relationships side of things, it's not all painted in shades of rose, but these men and women are complex characters, none completely good or bad, and many damaged by the effects of the civil war and subsequent rebellions.
June 24, 2010
"Lady of the Butterflies" is the story of a woman, Eleanor Glanville, whose love for butterflies an all things beautiful ultimately causes trouble for her.
It’s amazing how many topics this book touched on. I enjoyed the description of the development of science (insects), the belief of spontaneous generation, the brief history of being a physician versus an apothecary, the treatment of malaria, marsh drainage, the process of declaring someone insane, religions of the time, etc.
I found the book very enjoyable except for the main character, Eleanor Glanville. The author describes her as a highly intelligent and inquisitive woman who cares for her land the people. In reality, I find that though Eleanor doesn’t seem to care as deeply as she thinks she does. Eleanor claims to have so much love for her children, her men, and her land. In reality, she is always chasing after whatever/whoever she wants and it is so easy for her to discard her responsibilities and her past. Even her pursuit of butterflies took a back seat while she was more or less content with her married life. Not to mention that she didn't seem alarmed at all about the disappearance of her beloved butterflies with the draining of the Fens and considered draining her own land for profit.
I don't really care for the metaphor of worms/butterflies/Eleanor making their/her own coffin and then being reborn. I think it might be more fitting to say that Eleanor flits from one pretty flower to another, and another like a butterfly. Or perhaps that Eleanor pinches and kills every butterfly she catches, and she will never catch enough butterflies.
The ending of the book was completely unexpected and I liked how it changed the entire book. =)
I loved how many different historical topics the author touched on in this book. It is not just another book about battles and property ownership. As a gardener who has a problem with caterpillars destroying my plants, I have to admit that the author made caterpillars and butterflies beautiful (or as beautiful as they could be in my eyes).
I received this book from Library Thing Early Reviewers.
It’s amazing how many topics this book touched on. I enjoyed the description of the development of science (insects), the belief of spontaneous generation, the brief history of being a physician versus an apothecary, the treatment of malaria, marsh drainage, the process of declaring someone insane, religions of the time, etc.
I found the book very enjoyable except for the main character, Eleanor Glanville. The author describes her as a highly intelligent and inquisitive woman who cares for her land the people. In reality, I find that though Eleanor doesn’t seem to care as deeply as she thinks she does. Eleanor claims to have so much love for her children, her men, and her land. In reality, she is always chasing after whatever/whoever she wants and it is so easy for her to discard her responsibilities and her past. Even her pursuit of butterflies took a back seat while she was more or less content with her married life. Not to mention that she didn't seem alarmed at all about the disappearance of her beloved butterflies with the draining of the Fens and considered draining her own land for profit.
I don't really care for the metaphor of worms/butterflies/Eleanor making their/her own coffin and then being reborn. I think it might be more fitting to say that Eleanor flits from one pretty flower to another, and another like a butterfly. Or perhaps that Eleanor pinches and kills every butterfly she catches, and she will never catch enough butterflies.
The ending of the book was completely unexpected and I liked how it changed the entire book. =)
I loved how many different historical topics the author touched on in this book. It is not just another book about battles and property ownership. As a gardener who has a problem with caterpillars destroying my plants, I have to admit that the author made caterpillars and butterflies beautiful (or as beautiful as they could be in my eyes).
I received this book from Library Thing Early Reviewers.
November 30, 2011
I've been wanting to read Lady of the Butterflies for about a year and was afraid that I had built up the book too much in my head. When I finished reading, I realized that it was well worth the wait.
Lady of the Butterflies is about a woman who really existed: Eleanor Glanville, who was a Entomologist in the 17th century who studied butterflies. The book was part historical fiction, part romance, with Eleanor falling deeper and deeper in love with Richard Glanville, best friend of her husband Edmund.
Another relationship that this book focused on was Eleanor's friendship with James Petiver, who she corresponded with about the study of butterflies. Out of all the characters in this book, James was my favorite. I loved his passion for learning, he won my heart right away.
Of course, this being the 17th century, the term 'witch' was thrown about and anyone (especially a woman) who did anything out of the ordinary was labeled one. All it took was one person to start the rumor and it took off like wildfire. Unfortunately, this happened to Eleanor, all because of her love of butterflies and nature. It made me mad that a woman couldn't take up an interest without people thinking she's batty.
The book dragged in places, but I never lost interest. By the end, I was sobbing like a baby by a absolutely heartbreaking scene. I was content with the ending, which was both happy and heartbreaking.
Historical liberties were taken, such as the character of Richard - which from my brief research - who was abusive and out of his freakin' mind, but in the book he was a more romantic character who had bouts of a dark personality. That seemed to be the only thing that bothered me, but I managed to focus on this fictional version of Richard.
Very satisfying historical fiction book about a very strong and intelligent woman.
Lady of the Butterflies is about a woman who really existed: Eleanor Glanville, who was a Entomologist in the 17th century who studied butterflies. The book was part historical fiction, part romance, with Eleanor falling deeper and deeper in love with Richard Glanville, best friend of her husband Edmund.
Another relationship that this book focused on was Eleanor's friendship with James Petiver, who she corresponded with about the study of butterflies. Out of all the characters in this book, James was my favorite. I loved his passion for learning, he won my heart right away.
Of course, this being the 17th century, the term 'witch' was thrown about and anyone (especially a woman) who did anything out of the ordinary was labeled one. All it took was one person to start the rumor and it took off like wildfire. Unfortunately, this happened to Eleanor, all because of her love of butterflies and nature. It made me mad that a woman couldn't take up an interest without people thinking she's batty.
The book dragged in places, but I never lost interest. By the end, I was sobbing like a baby by a absolutely heartbreaking scene. I was content with the ending, which was both happy and heartbreaking.
Historical liberties were taken, such as the character of Richard - which from my brief research - who was abusive and out of his freakin' mind, but in the book he was a more romantic character who had bouts of a dark personality. That seemed to be the only thing that bothered me, but I managed to focus on this fictional version of Richard.
Very satisfying historical fiction book about a very strong and intelligent woman.
November 19, 2013
WARNING: SPOILERS!
I enjoy historical fiction, and having read quite a bit set during this time period (mid to late 17th century), and having some experience reenacting this time period with my geeky husband and friends, I found this novel especially fun. I also really enjoyed the fact that our heroine--a real historical figure--was ahead of her time. But at the center of this novel is a love triangle that really didn't do it for me. Eleanor falls in love with two men: One is Edmund Ashville, a kind and gentle man that her guardian intends for her to marry, and the other his best friend, the dashing Cavalier Richard Glanville. The formula here was boring. She marries Edmund and swears not to betray him, even though she constantly longs for Richard. When Edmund dies, Eleanor believes her sin of secretly wanting another man is the cause, and so she now swears never to see Richard again. Five years later she relents when he saves her life, and she marries him. He proceeds to become every bit the jealous, mercurial, wounded brat he always promised to be, and their marriage is as passionate with fighting as with loving. Ultimately, his insecurities win out, and he naturally turns to his sour stepson and a whore he's been seeing on the side, both of whom help him hatch a plan to have her declared insane so they can take her estate away. Honestly, I might have given this book another star if it hadn't turned so predictably bad in the last third or so.
I enjoy historical fiction, and having read quite a bit set during this time period (mid to late 17th century), and having some experience reenacting this time period with my geeky husband and friends, I found this novel especially fun. I also really enjoyed the fact that our heroine--a real historical figure--was ahead of her time. But at the center of this novel is a love triangle that really didn't do it for me. Eleanor falls in love with two men: One is Edmund Ashville, a kind and gentle man that her guardian intends for her to marry, and the other his best friend, the dashing Cavalier Richard Glanville. The formula here was boring. She marries Edmund and swears not to betray him, even though she constantly longs for Richard. When Edmund dies, Eleanor believes her sin of secretly wanting another man is the cause, and so she now swears never to see Richard again. Five years later she relents when he saves her life, and she marries him. He proceeds to become every bit the jealous, mercurial, wounded brat he always promised to be, and their marriage is as passionate with fighting as with loving. Ultimately, his insecurities win out, and he naturally turns to his sour stepson and a whore he's been seeing on the side, both of whom help him hatch a plan to have her declared insane so they can take her estate away. Honestly, I might have given this book another star if it hadn't turned so predictably bad in the last third or so.
April 13, 2015
Although this author is classified as a Romance writer, I hesitate to limit this book by calling it a romance novel. It is definitely a cut above the average historical romance in that the romance is inherently used to illustrate the role of women at the time and it manages to deal with a number of themes not usually addressed in a romance. The obviously extensive and well done research alone set it apart. Based on an historical character, it is a well and believeably imagined story of how a woman so out of step with and ahead of her times might have dealt with the limitations placed upon her.I will even forgive the pretty fairytale ending as being slightly possible given her character and her circle of freinds and supporters.
I would recommend to anyone interested in women's history, conservation and science, and English history. Not a great piece of literature but a well written, fun and informative read.
I would recommend to anyone interested in women's history, conservation and science, and English history. Not a great piece of literature but a well written, fun and informative read.
April 4, 2010
I thoroughly enjoyed reading The Lady of Butterflies for allowing me to view the world of a female scientist in the 1680's to 1700's. At times, I felt the story line to be bland with too much of the day-to-day living, but then I decided that Fiona Mountain wanted the reader to see that in spite of all her accomplishments, Eleanor Granville lived a simple life that centered on her children and the butterflies. The novel inspired me to research Eleanor Granville and to learn that Fiona Mountain followed the actual life fairly closely. So many of the events of the story and Granville's real life are alarming, such as the plight of married woman and her property and the views/beliefs/superstitions of the common folk. I am distressed that those beautiful creatures, the butterflies, no longer abundantly populate the world.
May 20, 2011
I think a more accurate description of this book would be historical romance rather than historical fiction. I loathe historical romances, but kept reading this one because of the interesting portrayal of cultural oddities of the time period; origin of marriage contracts, the superstitious belief that butterflies are the souls of the dead, discovery of metamorphosis, explanation of the political climate, etc, but somehow the writing seems to slip back and forth and can't decide what kind of book it really wants to be. I've almost given up on it a few times, but the fact that the novel is based on a real woman piques my curiosity enough to finish it. Readers who love historical romances may dislike it for what I consider its only redeeming qualities.
July 22, 2013
Bonus points for being based on a true story. I didnt realize that this was an actual unsolved historical mystery until I was done with the book. Knowing that this was based on a true story made me appreciate the characters so much more. I love reading about progressive, independent women, and even more so when they its based in truth. Such an interesting portrayal of a woman balancing religion and science, her traditional duties and progressive ideals.
September 9, 2021
A beautiful historical Classic Novel by fiona Mountain.
Born into a world seething with treachery and suspicion, Eleanor Goodricke grows up on the Somerset Levels just after the English Civil Wars, heiress to her late mother's estates and daughter of a Puritan soldier who fears for his brilliant daughter with her dangerous passion for natural history - and for butterflies in particular.
Her reckless courage will take her to places where no woman of her day ever dared to go. Her fearless ambition will give her a place in history for all time. But it is her passionate heart which will lead her into a consuming love - and mortal peril.
Born into a world seething with treachery and suspicion, Eleanor Goodricke grows up on the Somerset Levels just after the English Civil Wars, heiress to her late mother's estates and daughter of a Puritan soldier who fears for his brilliant daughter with her dangerous passion for natural history - and for butterflies in particular.
Her reckless courage will take her to places where no woman of her day ever dared to go. Her fearless ambition will give her a place in history for all time. But it is her passionate heart which will lead her into a consuming love - and mortal peril.
March 21, 2013
I read the background about the heroine prior to beginning the novel. What an amazing woman! The story begins with Eleanor outdoors where she longs to be. She loves studying the insects, the animals and birds but most especially she loves butterflies. Her mother and sister have died and she has only her father who cultivates and encourages her love of the outdoors and studying all things scientifically. When he becomes ill with ague (malaria), she is devastated. He dies and she grows up studying always as he would wish her to do.
Growing up on the moor, she collects insects, plants and whatever she wants to investigate. Her guardian is the man from whom her father borrowed money. He wants her to marry someone who will drain the marsh to make the land more valuable. She falls in love with Edmund Ashfield, a handsome calm individual who is intrigued by her interests. Eventually they marry. When Edmund dies of ague, too, Eleanor is heart broken. Even though she is strongly attracted to his best friend, Richard Glanville, who loves her she avoids him for five years.
Because her interests are so different from other women of her class, Eleanor is viewed as being strange. Rumors begin circulate about her being a witch and/or mad but she ignores them. She continues her study of butterflies and cultivates a friendship with James Petiver who shares her fascination of these lovely creatures.
The life of this unusual woman is fraught with sadness and conflict. She finds happiness with her children and butterflies. I loved the story - perhaps because Eleanor had the courage to follow her interests in spite of those around her. She is brought to trial and declared insane. Fine, fine read.
Growing up on the moor, she collects insects, plants and whatever she wants to investigate. Her guardian is the man from whom her father borrowed money. He wants her to marry someone who will drain the marsh to make the land more valuable. She falls in love with Edmund Ashfield, a handsome calm individual who is intrigued by her interests. Eventually they marry. When Edmund dies of ague, too, Eleanor is heart broken. Even though she is strongly attracted to his best friend, Richard Glanville, who loves her she avoids him for five years.
Because her interests are so different from other women of her class, Eleanor is viewed as being strange. Rumors begin circulate about her being a witch and/or mad but she ignores them. She continues her study of butterflies and cultivates a friendship with James Petiver who shares her fascination of these lovely creatures.
The life of this unusual woman is fraught with sadness and conflict. She finds happiness with her children and butterflies. I loved the story - perhaps because Eleanor had the courage to follow her interests in spite of those around her. She is brought to trial and declared insane. Fine, fine read.
August 12, 2013
Lady of the Butterflies tells the story of Eleanor Glanville, the first female etomologist. Taking place shortly after the English Civil War, Eleanor is orphaned and heir to a grand estate. As a child she loved studying nature while exploring the moors, in particular butterflies and their life cycle. In those days butterflies were thought to represent souls of the dead, and because of her fascination with the winged insects, she was rumored to be a witch. Throughout her life she marries and is widowed, then marries again. Her second husband has her committed as insane in efforts to take possession of her estate.
The marriage/romance parts of the book read like the style of Diana Gabaldon's Outlander … rather steamy in parts. While escaping from her husband's abusive treatment and hiding to avoid being confined to an asylum she meets James Petiver, a botanist, who helps disguise her as a man so that she can sit in at the Temple Coffee House Botany Club. He becomes her ally and together they discover and name butterflies. One is named The Glanville Fritillary in her honor.
There is a great deal of scientific background in this novel along with passionate romances. This historical novel is full of drama and danger, making it a page turner. I never knew about Eleanor before, a truly fascinating woman.
The marriage/romance parts of the book read like the style of Diana Gabaldon's Outlander … rather steamy in parts. While escaping from her husband's abusive treatment and hiding to avoid being confined to an asylum she meets James Petiver, a botanist, who helps disguise her as a man so that she can sit in at the Temple Coffee House Botany Club. He becomes her ally and together they discover and name butterflies. One is named The Glanville Fritillary in her honor.
There is a great deal of scientific background in this novel along with passionate romances. This historical novel is full of drama and danger, making it a page turner. I never knew about Eleanor before, a truly fascinating woman.
October 18, 2010
This book is based on the true story of Eleanor, a woman in the late 17th century that was fascinated by entomology and butterflies. She was considered to be somewhat of a witch during those days and totally ostrasized by her community and family. I was excited to learn more about the history of this science and how much was pure speculation at that time. It was also interesting that Nell, as she was called, was the only woman that had any interest in this science. That part was very fascinating. I didn't, however always enjoy the storyline. I don't know if it was the writing, or the fact that her life seemed much too romanticized, that it lost my attention. I found myself skimming through pages to get to the heart of the story and to get to the climactic parts.
Nell had a very turbulent life, moving from one relationship to another, and having children along the way. I was confused by the fact that she professed to be so attached to those children, having once crossed the country over a two weeks time to retrieve one, and then by the end---threw it all away.
I didn't love this book, but learned a bit about the science of that era----and had to appreciate it for that reason. Maybe the story seemed more fiction than fact---too embellished...some of it just didn't ring true.
Nell had a very turbulent life, moving from one relationship to another, and having children along the way. I was confused by the fact that she professed to be so attached to those children, having once crossed the country over a two weeks time to retrieve one, and then by the end---threw it all away.
I didn't love this book, but learned a bit about the science of that era----and had to appreciate it for that reason. Maybe the story seemed more fiction than fact---too embellished...some of it just didn't ring true.
February 18, 2011
It has taken me a while to read this book, but that's not because it wasn't interesting. On the contrary, it was probably a bit too interesting. I say that because every time I would go to read it, I would find myself pretending that I was Eleanor Glanville, and I would become so wrapped up in this book. The ending definitely was not what I was hoping for, but it wasn't necessarily bad. Throughout the story, I was really rooting for Eleanor to come out on top in the end, and even though it wasn't exactly what I was hoping for her, she was happy and that is all that matters. You know the author has done an excellent job when you are able to put yourself into the shoes of the main character. Excellent book and I highly recommend it.
October 5, 2010
This novel charts the live of Eleanor Glanville, a seventeenth-century entomologist with a particular interest in butterflies. I was wary of this novel at first, as I had no interest in reading a five-hundred-page biology of butterflies, but I discovered Eleanor's tumultuous personal life to be as interesting as she apparently found butterflies.
The primary virtue of this novel was the rich historical setting. Fiona Mountain does an excellent job of bring late 17th-century England alive and her narrative is rich in detail. The issue of draining the wetlands on Eleanor's lands and the turbulent historical background help bring Eleanor's world to life. I thoroughly enjoyed this fictionalization of Eleanor Glanville and I am interested in reading more about her.
The primary virtue of this novel was the rich historical setting. Fiona Mountain does an excellent job of bring late 17th-century England alive and her narrative is rich in detail. The issue of draining the wetlands on Eleanor's lands and the turbulent historical background help bring Eleanor's world to life. I thoroughly enjoyed this fictionalization of Eleanor Glanville and I am interested in reading more about her.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews