That's right, folks. I wandered right back to that farmhouse and got taken in pretty handily for the last adventure of Jane and Scarlett. I will admit, I was just as surprised as anyone that I got into these books, given my disdain for so much 'reality' television and THE HILLS, but I will once again tout the talents of Lauren Conrad. She knows how to write a pretty entertaining story filled with drama. SUGAR AND SPICE wraps up the series fairly well, though I will admit that I didn't feel as satisfied as I wanted to feel regarding the end of Jane and Scarlett's story. I wanted a satisfying ending with some oomf. What I got was more a sort of satisfying ending with more of a 'meh'.
SUGAR AND SPICE picks up a few weeks after SWEET LITTLE LIES ended. Jane and Scarlett are besties again, but they're dealing with some residual problems from the last book. Jane isn't speaking to Madison, but the producer of L.A. CANDY sees that as a ratings opportunity, putting them in the same scenes whenever he can much to Jane's protests. It doesn't help that Madison is spinning the story to make herself look like the victim. Not to mention that Caleb, Jane's high school boyfriend, has come back into her life, even though she's sworn off men. Scarlett isn't faring much better. She still hates USC, and while she and Liam are still very hot, his inability to be on the show is making things difficult, especially since the show seems to want to edit all of her interactions with Caleb's friend Naveen to seem less than innocent. But they aren't the only girls with problems. Gaby is being unduly influenced by a scheming publicist, and Madison is fighting off a blackmailer with a terrible secret. If that secret got out, it could take down Madison's reputation for good. And then Jane finds out that maybe the control she has over her life is an illusion the show wants her to have....
I had a couple of large criticisms with this book that made it fall below the first two. First and foremost, as much as Madison did terrible and rotten things in the first book, a sympathetic portrait has been drawn now, so I couldn't enjoy the horrible rain of crap that falls upon her in this book. I thought that she got her just desserts when Jane stopped talking to her. Sure, she isn't a good person, but when you find out WHY she isn't a good person (and when they introduce a foil who is even WORSE) I really started feeling bad for her. The good news is that Conrad's other series, THE FAME GAME, follows Madison, so I just have to assume that she has a redemptive cycle (of sorts) coming her way. Another criticism I had was about poor Gaby, one of my favorite characters in the series. Conrad turns her into an easily manipulated bobble head, and while that does sound like something that would happen to Gaby, she had always been very sweet and kind in the first two books, so to see her do some less than savory things made me very upset. I want to know if she and Scarlett are still friends at least. That was definitely my least favorite story to follow. And then there was Jane, who is still pretty blind about how reality TV works, only now she has her old boyfriend back in the picture. How convenient that he decided he wanted to be in her life again after she was a breakout TV star. COME ON, JANE. As much as she wasn't as clueless by the end of it all, she was still maddeningly clueless about so many things.
HOWEVER, the reason this book gets three stars from me (not the 3.5 the other two got), is because of Scarlett and her storylines. One storyline was about how unhappy she is at USC, and her decision to transfer schools, even though that means leaving her best friend and boyfriend behind. I liked the fact that she wanted more for herself than some TV show, and even though she too got a little sucked in, come on. It's Scarlett. I was never worried for her. I also liked her storyline with Liam, the ousted cameraman she fell head over heels for in SWEET LITTLE LIES. This novel explores the difficulties of living a 'reality TV' life but wanting just a normal relationship. And I really like Scarlett and Liam as characters, both individually (admittedly you really only see Liam when he's with Scarlett, but you get hints of more to him than that) and when they are together. So that relationship was what saved this book from total disappointment.
I wish that I could say that SUGAR AND SPICE was the perfect topper for this series, but I didn't think it lived up to the last two. That being said, I will no doubt read THE FAME GAME just so I can see what becomes of Madison. Because of all the characters, I'm rooting for Madison the most, if only because I want her to find herself and to figure out that she doesn't need this crap to be successful. I have little hope for that. But I want things to work for her. So ultimately I have to tip my hat to Lauren Conrad. She has officially created a character that I really do care about, so much so that I want her to be okay. Sigh. I guess I have a new soap author I resent and revere at the same time.