Disappointing, in a word. After the excellent first three books of the series, it seems Abnett lost momentum with this one.
It has some interesting aspects and plot threads, but the bulk of what Abnett focuses on is mediocre.
The novel opens with the Ghosts in a methodical combat operation against a heavy cultist presence on the Shrine World Hagia, sacred in the Sabbat System, as the birth planet of Saint Sabbat, a woman who Gaunt himself idolised. Not a bad premise, and I’m sure the other books will keep up with this idea of the Sabbat Martyr – after all, the second omnibus is called The Saint -- but for several reasons this entry in the series didn’t work. The main one is that the central plot relies on not one, but two Deus Ex Machina’s. The first occurs when following the orders of the Lord Commander Lugo, who’s impatient with Gaunt’s methodical leadership in taking back the shrine world, Gaunt is forced to push men forwards. The cultists are on the run, and on the verge of a total massacre, a unit of guardsmen finds themselves the victims of a warp-driven Chaos device which sucks their souls and turns Hagia into a beacon for an immense warp-bound Chaos Space Marine fleet. Lugo blames this on Gaunt, a convenient scapegoat, and a planet-wide evacuation is planned.
The novel ends with the Ghosts and allies in what appears to be their last fight, with absolutely no hope, holed up on Hagia’s shrine monument to the martyr. And how does Abnett resolve this. Pretty simply, actually, another Deus Ex-Machina warp device which annihilates the cultist forces and waylays the encroaching Chaos force. Sure, the Ghosts have to work for the Deus Ex Machina, but it feels contrived, and is fundamentally why the novel fails.
I have hope that the next novel will be a return to form of Abnett. There are some interesting threads set up in this one. Gaunt’s descent into alcoholism and despair, his loss and return of faith, being a big one. Sergeant Gol Kolea realising his children, who he thought killed on Vervunhive, did survive, and are in the care of Caffran and Tona Criid, who’ve become surrogate parents of a kind. Gol might even have a potential love interest in the medic Ana Curth, and Commisar Hark is a good addition to the cast – another honourable commissar who pays respect to Gaunt. Rawne’s vengeance is still coming, and Bragg, well, he’s in bad shape, but I think he’s alive. At least for now.
Then there’s Larkin, one of the best characters in a sense, who in this book’s been dealing with the borderline-psychotic Cuu and competition from the female Vervunhiver who’s name escapes me.
All in all, a mediocre entry for the series, but it sets up some significant plot lines, so I am content.