What do you think?
Rate this book
The Phantom of Pemberley: A Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery
Happily married for over a year and more in love than ever, Darcy and Elizabeth can’t imagine anything interrupting their bliss-filled days. Then an intense snowstorm strands a group of travelers at Pemberley, and terrifying accidents and mysterious deaths begin to plague the manor. Everyone seems convinced that it is the work of a phantom—a Shadow Man who is haunting the Darcy family’s grand estate.
Darcy and Elizabeth believe the truth is much more menacing and that someone is trying to murder them. But Pemberley is filled with family guests as well as the unexpected travelers—any one of whom could be the culprit—so unraveling the mystery of the murderer’s identity forces the newlyweds to trust each other’s strengths and work together.
Written in the style of the era and including Austen’s romantic playfulness and sardonic humor, this suspense-packed sequel to Pride and Prejudice recasts Darcy and Elizabeth as a husband-and-wife detective team who must solve the mystery at Pemberley and catch the murderer—before it’s too late.
**Not a part of the "Murder Mystery" series, this is a stand-alone book**
Darcy and Elizabeth believe the truth is much more menacing and that someone is trying to murder them. But Pemberley is filled with family guests as well as the unexpected travelers—any one of whom could be the culprit—so unraveling the mystery of the murderer’s identity forces the newlyweds to trust each other’s strengths and work together.
Written in the style of the era and including Austen’s romantic playfulness and sardonic humor, this suspense-packed sequel to Pride and Prejudice recasts Darcy and Elizabeth as a husband-and-wife detective team who must solve the mystery at Pemberley and catch the murderer—before it’s too late.
**Not a part of the "Murder Mystery" series, this is a stand-alone book**
409 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2010
85 people are currently reading
1852 people want to read
About the author
Regina Jeffers
132 books707 followersRegina Jeffers, an award-winning author of historical cozy mysteries, Austenesque sequels and retellings, as well as Regency era romances, has worn many hats over her lifetime: daughter, student, military brat, wife, mother, grandmother, teacher, tax preparer, journalist, choreographer, Broadway dancer, theatre director, history buff, grant writer, media literacy consultant, and author. Living outside of Charlotte, NC, Jeffers writes novels that take the ordinary and adds a bit of mayhem, while mastering tension in her own life with a bit of gardening and the exuberance of her “grand joys.”
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 178 reviews
March 24, 2021
This story ends at 95% when the author discusses the research behind her premise and introduces us to another story as well as her other works.
This tale is full of angst...edge of your seat tension! There is not much romance although Darcy and Elizabeth have their moments of teasing and of debate and affection. Elizabeth demands her say and her part as an equal. She refuses to allow Darcy to hide some of the horror of what is occurring from her.
Pemberley becomes a haven for a number of people when a winter storm fills up the inn in Lambton. Lydia is there by invitation. Lady Catherine and Anne are also there and Anne is involved in an event which could, like Lydia's elopement, mean her and her family's disgrace. Anne sees it as finally becoming independent of her mother.
Murder comes to visit and it claims more than one victim. There are also missing items, some significantly large, and the sudden appearance and then disappearance of a man more than once. This leads to the renewing of an old superstition about there being a phantom at Pemberley. Anne's companion claims to have seen the "phantom" and thus, Darcy lines up all the male employees for her to identify him, as he was wearing Pemberley livery. She fails.
I don't want to spoil this story as with any mystery the clues provided are part of the enjoyment of the reader acting as detective all on their own. I have to say that I guessed part of the mystery early. That does not take away from the magnificent job this author did with this story.
I highly recommend this story...whether you are a lover of JAFF or of mysteries or both.
This tale is full of angst...edge of your seat tension! There is not much romance although Darcy and Elizabeth have their moments of teasing and of debate and affection. Elizabeth demands her say and her part as an equal. She refuses to allow Darcy to hide some of the horror of what is occurring from her.
Pemberley becomes a haven for a number of people when a winter storm fills up the inn in Lambton. Lydia is there by invitation. Lady Catherine and Anne are also there and Anne is involved in an event which could, like Lydia's elopement, mean her and her family's disgrace. Anne sees it as finally becoming independent of her mother.
Murder comes to visit and it claims more than one victim. There are also missing items, some significantly large, and the sudden appearance and then disappearance of a man more than once. This leads to the renewing of an old superstition about there being a phantom at Pemberley. Anne's companion claims to have seen the "phantom" and thus, Darcy lines up all the male employees for her to identify him, as he was wearing Pemberley livery. She fails.
I don't want to spoil this story as with any mystery the clues provided are part of the enjoyment of the reader acting as detective all on their own. I have to say that I guessed part of the mystery early. That does not take away from the magnificent job this author did with this story.
I highly recommend this story...whether you are a lover of JAFF or of mysteries or both.
April 15, 2021
This struck me as a strange mixture of Ten Little Indians (a.k.a And Then There Were None), the movie Murder by Death, and a sequel to Pride and Prejudice.
A widely disparate group of travelers find themselves stranded at Pemberley because of an intense snowstorm. There are a few strange, unexplained occurrences and eventually multiple mysterious deaths, creating an atmosphere of fear and distrust among those in residence - sort of like Ten Little Indians.
As in Murder By Death, everything is explained in a rush at the end, both with information that had been withheld during the story and with misinformation that is finally corrected. Some people are not who they seem to be, least of all the murderer. I had an educated guess and came up with the correct suspect early in the book, but I'd rejected him when other information in the story seemed to directly contradict that possibility ... until the end, when it turned out I was right. Unfair!!
Of course, the hero and heroine here are the now-married Darcy and Elizabeth post Pride and Prejudice. There are several brand new characters, but others from P&P are part of this assembly, including Lydia Wickham, Colonel Fitzwilliam, Georgiana Darcy, Lady Catherine, Anne de Bourgh and Mrs. Jenkinson.
Darcy and Elizabeth are very much in love, as the reader is reminded often. They do seem overly affectionate in public for members of their class during this historical period - but since the tone is gothic and somewhat melodramatic throughout, perhaps the exaggeration is intentional.
The writing itself is good and flows well with no errors that I noted, so it's easy to read. I really did enjoy the story itself, with all its well-defined and diverse characters, to a point. As you can tell from what I wrote above, though, I was very frustrated when all was explained. Perhaps, as in Murder By Death, it actually was intended to be murder mystery parody, but it didn't read that way to me.
*MINOR SPOILER AHEAD* I've just got to say... There are SO many clues early on indicating there must be secret passages behind the walls, long before that fact is revealed to the reader. Darcy and Elizabeth are supposed to be clever and intelligent, but it never occurs to either of them. What makes even less sense is that Darcy's steward apparently does know about them but never thinks to mention them. The explanation is that he thought Darcy was already aware of them, but c'mon!
A widely disparate group of travelers find themselves stranded at Pemberley because of an intense snowstorm. There are a few strange, unexplained occurrences and eventually multiple mysterious deaths, creating an atmosphere of fear and distrust among those in residence - sort of like Ten Little Indians.
As in Murder By Death, everything is explained in a rush at the end, both with information that had been withheld during the story and with misinformation that is finally corrected. Some people are not who they seem to be, least of all the murderer. I had an educated guess and came up with the correct suspect early in the book, but I'd rejected him when other information in the story seemed to directly contradict that possibility ... until the end, when it turned out I was right. Unfair!!
Of course, the hero and heroine here are the now-married Darcy and Elizabeth post Pride and Prejudice. There are several brand new characters, but others from P&P are part of this assembly, including Lydia Wickham, Colonel Fitzwilliam, Georgiana Darcy, Lady Catherine, Anne de Bourgh and Mrs. Jenkinson.
Darcy and Elizabeth are very much in love, as the reader is reminded often. They do seem overly affectionate in public for members of their class during this historical period - but since the tone is gothic and somewhat melodramatic throughout, perhaps the exaggeration is intentional.
The writing itself is good and flows well with no errors that I noted, so it's easy to read. I really did enjoy the story itself, with all its well-defined and diverse characters, to a point. As you can tell from what I wrote above, though, I was very frustrated when all was explained. Perhaps, as in Murder By Death, it actually was intended to be murder mystery parody, but it didn't read that way to me.
*MINOR SPOILER AHEAD* I've just got to say... There are SO many clues early on indicating there must be secret passages behind the walls, long before that fact is revealed to the reader. Darcy and Elizabeth are supposed to be clever and intelligent, but it never occurs to either of them. What makes even less sense is that Darcy's steward apparently does know about them but never thinks to mention them. The explanation is that he thought Darcy was already aware of them, but c'mon!
April 17, 2022
Audiobook Review
I enjoyed the Audible version of this book pretty well. The narration by Rebecca Courtney was really good and I would have rated her performance higher if not for a few notable exceptions. She gave Anne a horrible lisp. In the story, Georgiana has a cold and it sounds like it which is fine. However, she still sounds like she has a cold ten plus days into it. That voice got old. I felt like the narrator wasn’t familiar with Wickham’s character, who is supposed to be so charming and irresistible to women. She also gave him a lisp. It just didn’t work for me.
The story is good and held my interest throughout.
I enjoyed the Audible version of this book pretty well. The narration by Rebecca Courtney was really good and I would have rated her performance higher if not for a few notable exceptions. She gave Anne a horrible lisp. In the story, Georgiana has a cold and it sounds like it which is fine. However, she still sounds like she has a cold ten plus days into it. That voice got old. I felt like the narrator wasn’t familiar with Wickham’s character, who is supposed to be so charming and irresistible to women. She also gave him a lisp. It just didn’t work for me.
The story is good and held my interest throughout.
June 24, 2011
Since this was a freebie from B&N for the Nook, I guess I cannot complain too much....but I am going to provide my somewhat detailed opinion so someone else in my situation may choose something else form the freebie shelf.....
Let's start with, I enjoy Jane Austen, although I am not really a fanatic. I have even enjoyed some of the quirky Austen-themed novels of present-day girls transported to Austen England, etc. Therefore, when I found myself with nothing to read and spotted The Phantom of Pemberley on my shelf, I opened it up.
On the positive side, it is a mindless, fast read. That's all the positive I can say.
I understand from the author notes that Ms. Jeffers is a teacher and Austen enthusiast. Given that background, I would think she could have done a better job of maintaining some accuracy to the time and to the well-established characters. After about 100 pages, I was very bothered by something, which I had trouble placing. I soon realized it was the lifting of entire blocks of language from Austen - specifically Pride and Prejudice - and how out of place it sounded inserted into Ms. Jeffers' text. Her writing contained too much 21st century bias to make the story believable or even readable without argument from my subconscious. I soon understood it not to be just the prose that was "off," but the characters' behavior as well: significant and continual PDA (as in public display of affection)- I just don't think it would have happened in regency England - no matter how in love the married couple was - I certainly don't think that type of impropriety would have been exhibited by Elizabeth and Darcy.
Then, she seemed to have gotten all the characters wrong: Darcy as a love-besotted wimp, Elizabeth allowing the disgraced Lydia (of all her sisters) to visit, Lady Catherine as an impotent dowager clinging to the last of her resources. It just didn't sit well with me.
And there was the plot-line. Wickham issues aside, the idea that no one of consequence would know that there were secret passages inside the home is bordering on ridiculous, and the explanation even worse. Darcy and Wickham were off-siders as children, but one has extensive knowledge and experience with the passageways and the other is....oblivious? I believe that even the author recognized this deficiency, so she added that one servant who was aware, but then this one knowledgeable person doesn't say anything about it - not even after after 3 murders have been committed, hmmmm......
I see why the book is free - and I am slightly less stunned about the American educational crisis knowing that this author is a teacher.
Bottom line, there are a number of entertaining Austen-inspired works out there. For a real Austen enthusiast, I recommend taking the time to find those and giving this a pass.
Let's start with, I enjoy Jane Austen, although I am not really a fanatic. I have even enjoyed some of the quirky Austen-themed novels of present-day girls transported to Austen England, etc. Therefore, when I found myself with nothing to read and spotted The Phantom of Pemberley on my shelf, I opened it up.
On the positive side, it is a mindless, fast read. That's all the positive I can say.
I understand from the author notes that Ms. Jeffers is a teacher and Austen enthusiast. Given that background, I would think she could have done a better job of maintaining some accuracy to the time and to the well-established characters. After about 100 pages, I was very bothered by something, which I had trouble placing. I soon realized it was the lifting of entire blocks of language from Austen - specifically Pride and Prejudice - and how out of place it sounded inserted into Ms. Jeffers' text. Her writing contained too much 21st century bias to make the story believable or even readable without argument from my subconscious. I soon understood it not to be just the prose that was "off," but the characters' behavior as well: significant and continual PDA (as in public display of affection)- I just don't think it would have happened in regency England - no matter how in love the married couple was - I certainly don't think that type of impropriety would have been exhibited by Elizabeth and Darcy.
Then, she seemed to have gotten all the characters wrong: Darcy as a love-besotted wimp, Elizabeth allowing the disgraced Lydia (of all her sisters) to visit, Lady Catherine as an impotent dowager clinging to the last of her resources. It just didn't sit well with me.
And there was the plot-line. Wickham issues aside, the idea that no one of consequence would know that there were secret passages inside the home is bordering on ridiculous, and the explanation even worse. Darcy and Wickham were off-siders as children, but one has extensive knowledge and experience with the passageways and the other is....oblivious? I believe that even the author recognized this deficiency, so she added that one servant who was aware, but then this one knowledgeable person doesn't say anything about it - not even after after 3 murders have been committed, hmmmm......
I see why the book is free - and I am slightly less stunned about the American educational crisis knowing that this author is a teacher.
Bottom line, there are a number of entertaining Austen-inspired works out there. For a real Austen enthusiast, I recommend taking the time to find those and giving this a pass.
October 13, 2010
It drives me crazy when someone criticizes an author for adding parts of the original story line to sequel. That is why I buy a Jane Austen variation. I want MORE Austen. And despite what some believe, MANY people in the world are not familiar with Austen's works. Therefore any writer using her story lines MUST explain the relationships between the characters while establishing a new beginning. Plus, possibly, the author's publishing company requires that the person add Austen's language.
This is a tightly written mystery...full of twists and turns. Just when you think you have it figured out, a red herring takes you another way. If you are looking for a book to fill your hours, this is the one for you.
This is a tightly written mystery...full of twists and turns. Just when you think you have it figured out, a red herring takes you another way. If you are looking for a book to fill your hours, this is the one for you.
March 9, 2019
Anything that Ms Jeffers writes is worth reading so I would recommend it.
Reread: Loved this book. I reread it to be prepared for His Irish Eve and am glad that I did.
Reread: Loved this book. I reread it to be prepared for His Irish Eve and am glad that I did.
January 18, 2018
I enjoyed this one.
November 2, 2023
Original and interesting story line where Wickham has multiple personalities. 3.75 stars
Long at times, a few grammatical errors.
As original as the story was, I didn’t find myself staying up late or rushing through pages to see what would happen next. Regardless, good story overall.
Long at times, a few grammatical errors.
As original as the story was, I didn’t find myself staying up late or rushing through pages to see what would happen next. Regardless, good story overall.
May 25, 2011
Warning: Contains a spoiler
So "Pride and Prejudice" is my favorite book of all time. As a result, I have looked down with scorn at the books by authors who have attempted to extend the Elizabeth and Darcy story for their own gains. Then B&N offered this book free for the Nook and I decided to give it a try if for no other reason than to inform myself of this genre of books and, hey, the price is right!
I can sum up the book in one word: AWFUL
Details of my opinion: First of all, you cannot read 3 pages without there being an extended paragraph gushing about how much Elizabeth and Darcy love each other; were nothing before each other; feel they could walk on clouds; and other such sappily romantic things to the point that you want to throw up. Once I got beyond this, I was still stuck on how poorly the book was written. It just appeared amateurish, especially when comparing it to the original novel it stole the characters from. Next, I feel they changed the characteristics of some key characters from the original novel, which irked me. Also, the conflict in the original novel had to do with society norms, class standards, relationships, etc. This novel made the conflict murder, not just one murder but many. Hard to equate the two books.
Spoiler alert in the next statement, so stop reading this review if you actually think you may read this book:
Finally, the book completely "jumped the shark" (I know you like the Happy Days reference). Mr. Wickham was once again the bad guy, but in a completely different way. In P&P, Wickham was a ladies’ man, gambler and a schemer. his crimes were his debt and ruining the reputations of ladies. In this book, his crimes are murder, assault, and theft and the reason he has seemed to fall to such depths of depravity is that he suffers from Multiple Personality Disorder. REALLY!??! The suave, debonair ladies man from the first novel has multiple personality disorder that makes him kill????? I can't support that. The author puts an appendix in the book noting that multiple personality disorder (or dissociative identity disorder as it is now called) has been recognized as a condition in some circles for over 200 years, but i think it is a huge stretch in this book.
So overall, I hated the book and I now feel I can look at this genre of novel with more educated scorn and contempt.
So "Pride and Prejudice" is my favorite book of all time. As a result, I have looked down with scorn at the books by authors who have attempted to extend the Elizabeth and Darcy story for their own gains. Then B&N offered this book free for the Nook and I decided to give it a try if for no other reason than to inform myself of this genre of books and, hey, the price is right!
I can sum up the book in one word: AWFUL
Details of my opinion: First of all, you cannot read 3 pages without there being an extended paragraph gushing about how much Elizabeth and Darcy love each other; were nothing before each other; feel they could walk on clouds; and other such sappily romantic things to the point that you want to throw up. Once I got beyond this, I was still stuck on how poorly the book was written. It just appeared amateurish, especially when comparing it to the original novel it stole the characters from. Next, I feel they changed the characteristics of some key characters from the original novel, which irked me. Also, the conflict in the original novel had to do with society norms, class standards, relationships, etc. This novel made the conflict murder, not just one murder but many. Hard to equate the two books.
Spoiler alert in the next statement, so stop reading this review if you actually think you may read this book:
Finally, the book completely "jumped the shark" (I know you like the Happy Days reference). Mr. Wickham was once again the bad guy, but in a completely different way. In P&P, Wickham was a ladies’ man, gambler and a schemer. his crimes were his debt and ruining the reputations of ladies. In this book, his crimes are murder, assault, and theft and the reason he has seemed to fall to such depths of depravity is that he suffers from Multiple Personality Disorder. REALLY!??! The suave, debonair ladies man from the first novel has multiple personality disorder that makes him kill????? I can't support that. The author puts an appendix in the book noting that multiple personality disorder (or dissociative identity disorder as it is now called) has been recognized as a condition in some circles for over 200 years, but i think it is a huge stretch in this book.
So overall, I hated the book and I now feel I can look at this genre of novel with more educated scorn and contempt.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 22, 2011
Why, why, why, WHY do so many authors of this genre insist on pairing Geoogiana with Col. Fitzwilliam?!?! I understand that cousin marriage was done in Jane's day. Anne and Darcy were supposed to marry. Mr. Collins proposed to Lizzie. Fanny Price ended up with her cousin. However, we are no longer in that time period, and now cousin romance is seriously unappealing! Add to this the fact that he is Georgiana's co-guardian. This adds a creep factor. Oh yeah, and he's OLD. (Don't give me the that's the way it was excuse. Instead refer to my that's-not-how-it-is-now argument!) Let's also add the fact that Georgiana is timid & shy, while Fitzwilliam is cheery and friendly. He was drawn to Elizabeth- who is mature and outgoing. Now we are to believe that is he going to fall for a mouse of a girl. I am DONE with this idea. Note to authors: Don't do this ever again.
July 12, 2021
A fantastic mix of P&P sequel and mystery, taking place in Pemberley.
Due to a winter storm a mix of individuals take refuge at Pemberley, including Lydia. Items going missing, mysterious accidents and a male figure disappearing into nothingness all contribute toward drama enfolding in the most violent manner.
Very well written. While the big bad is not really a surprise, the mode of his behavior is quite a surprise and unique in the JAFF genre.
Worth a read if you like mystery and suspense with your P&P!
Due to a winter storm a mix of individuals take refuge at Pemberley, including Lydia. Items going missing, mysterious accidents and a male figure disappearing into nothingness all contribute toward drama enfolding in the most violent manner.
Very well written. While the big bad is not really a surprise, the mode of his behavior is quite a surprise and unique in the JAFF genre.
Worth a read if you like mystery and suspense with your P&P!
April 3, 2011
I think I enjoyed the character development more than the actual mystery. Dr. Darcy's admiration for Elizabeth was obscenely romantic *swoon*. It was interesting take on the futures of Lydia Wickham, Anne DeBourgh and Georgiana Darcy. I would have liked to have seen some loose ends tied up - but over all it was a fun read.
April 6, 2017
I loved this murder mystery story. It was full of angst and multiple murders occurred. There were many people involved, each one with a different agenda and a backstory. I enjoyed discovering multiple layers of deceit and disguise, though I understand that it might have been a bit confusing for some readers. But it is what I expected from this kind of story.
My favorite part of the book was the relationship between Darcy and Elizabeth: strong, faithful, passionate and very sweet. I enjoyed their interactions very much. The original characters were very well written and engaging.
My favorite part of the book was the relationship between Darcy and Elizabeth: strong, faithful, passionate and very sweet. I enjoyed their interactions very much. The original characters were very well written and engaging.
September 2, 2024
I thoroughly enjoyed this, was totally in the dark about some things, completely surprised about others and annoyed that Darcy simply didn’t catch on to certain things he ought to have known or at least suspected, and horrified at Elizabeth’s courage. Loved it a very thrilling read.
August 23, 2011
In The Phantom of Pemberley, Regina Jeffers, author of several books including The Scandal of Lady Eleanor, continues the much endeared love story of the key characters of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy.
The Phantom of Pemberley takes place a little over a year after Elizabeth and Darcy’s wedding and both are happily settled in their match. The novel begins with Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy getting ready to head into town to pick up Elizabeth’s sister, Lydia. Although Mr. Darcy still harbors bad feelings toward his wife’s sister, Lydia Wickham, and her husband, George Wickham, he makes an effort to welcome his sister-in-law sans her husband to his home for a short visit. If you recall, Wickham had convinced Darcy’s 15-year-old-sister, Georgiana, to elope with him in order to get his hands on her inheritance.
As in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Act 1, Scene 4, “Something is rotten in the state of Denmark,” Jeffers gives us a sense of forewarning when an impending winter storm arrives. After they set to town to pick up Lydia, the Darcys are forced to extend their home to a group of stranded guests due to an already fully occupied inn. While gracious in their roles of playing host and hostess to the group, the atmosphere in Pemberley takes a sudden change for the worse when a murder is committed. The realization that a murderer is walking among them has Mr. Darcy and his wife hurrying to find him or her before they strike again.
Jeffers cleverly brings back Lady Catherine de Bourgh, adding a constant thorn at Elizabeth’s side, much to Mr. Darcy’s chagrin. However, Lady Catherine de Bourgh has her own problems, which is why she showed up at the Darcys, hoping to involve Darcy in preventing a scandal involving her daughter, Lady Anne.
Jeffers commands the language of the period, gives us a fresh plot, and even weaves in pieces of Pride and Prejudice. Though I suspect Jeffers wanted to give readers who had not read P&P a little pre-history of the beginnings of Darcy and Elizabeth, I believe this was not crucial to the plot of her story. However, Jeffers does over emphasize Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy’s relationship, creating a constant overflow of sentimentalities between the two that can be distracting to the reader.
I still enjoyed reading the book, especially experiencing the creativity of many of these writers. I love to see that both Lydia and Lady Catherine were up to their usual obnoxious selves, Jeffers captured their true nature. For all you fans that pitied Lady Anne and would have liked to have seen more of her, this is the book to read. Lady Anne eventually comes into her own right as she stands up against her bullying mother and finds happiness.
Contrary to other reviews, I found the ending a pleasant surprise, especially learning the murderer was not whom I suspected. Anytime a book can surprise me is a great plus for me, besides shouldn’t reading be in the mind of the beholder—in other words we can’t always please everyone.
Check out Jeffers’ The Scandal of Lady Eleanor. Though filled with explicit sex, the story was not only enjoyable, but fresh, including her brilliance in introducing the men of “The Realm”, a secret society of the British government. These are gallant men who not only fight for their country, but for the women who capture their hearts.
Sincerely,
Miguelina Perez
The Phantom of Pemberley takes place a little over a year after Elizabeth and Darcy’s wedding and both are happily settled in their match. The novel begins with Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy getting ready to head into town to pick up Elizabeth’s sister, Lydia. Although Mr. Darcy still harbors bad feelings toward his wife’s sister, Lydia Wickham, and her husband, George Wickham, he makes an effort to welcome his sister-in-law sans her husband to his home for a short visit. If you recall, Wickham had convinced Darcy’s 15-year-old-sister, Georgiana, to elope with him in order to get his hands on her inheritance.
As in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Act 1, Scene 4, “Something is rotten in the state of Denmark,” Jeffers gives us a sense of forewarning when an impending winter storm arrives. After they set to town to pick up Lydia, the Darcys are forced to extend their home to a group of stranded guests due to an already fully occupied inn. While gracious in their roles of playing host and hostess to the group, the atmosphere in Pemberley takes a sudden change for the worse when a murder is committed. The realization that a murderer is walking among them has Mr. Darcy and his wife hurrying to find him or her before they strike again.
Jeffers cleverly brings back Lady Catherine de Bourgh, adding a constant thorn at Elizabeth’s side, much to Mr. Darcy’s chagrin. However, Lady Catherine de Bourgh has her own problems, which is why she showed up at the Darcys, hoping to involve Darcy in preventing a scandal involving her daughter, Lady Anne.
Jeffers commands the language of the period, gives us a fresh plot, and even weaves in pieces of Pride and Prejudice. Though I suspect Jeffers wanted to give readers who had not read P&P a little pre-history of the beginnings of Darcy and Elizabeth, I believe this was not crucial to the plot of her story. However, Jeffers does over emphasize Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy’s relationship, creating a constant overflow of sentimentalities between the two that can be distracting to the reader.
I still enjoyed reading the book, especially experiencing the creativity of many of these writers. I love to see that both Lydia and Lady Catherine were up to their usual obnoxious selves, Jeffers captured their true nature. For all you fans that pitied Lady Anne and would have liked to have seen more of her, this is the book to read. Lady Anne eventually comes into her own right as she stands up against her bullying mother and finds happiness.
Contrary to other reviews, I found the ending a pleasant surprise, especially learning the murderer was not whom I suspected. Anytime a book can surprise me is a great plus for me, besides shouldn’t reading be in the mind of the beholder—in other words we can’t always please everyone.
Check out Jeffers’ The Scandal of Lady Eleanor. Though filled with explicit sex, the story was not only enjoyable, but fresh, including her brilliance in introducing the men of “The Realm”, a secret society of the British government. These are gallant men who not only fight for their country, but for the women who capture their hearts.
Sincerely,
Miguelina Perez
January 6, 2012
I believe the subtitle of this books should be "The Awesome, Unflinching Adventures of Mary Sue Darcy" - because, as written by Jeffers, Elizabeth Darcy is super-human. The same woman who was rather choked up in Pride and prejudice to learn of her little sister's scandal was able to take mysterious murder in her own home with stride. The implication is that she and Darcy have such an amazingly, perfect, loving relationship that she need never cry again. In fact, the lingering on the relationship is too, too detailed and involved. While the book claims to be in Regency style, it does lend itself to too much drawn-out information about the bedroom life of the Darcys.
Aside from the saccharine perfection and constant doting of our main characters, and the fact that everyone in the book - including unsavory characters - thinks that Elizabeth is the best person on Earth, the mystery aspect leaves much to be desired. I am an avid mystery reader as well as an Austen fan. I was excited to discover that the two had been combined. That said, some rules for good mystery writing were not followed here. I will not give away the plot for those who wish to read this despite all of the negative reviews, but the author cheats on the mystery. The reader is deliberately deceived, and not in a clever way. There might be one fleeting sentence in the book where you stop and think "Oh, is the author going there? Really? That would be a cop-out." Yes, she does go there. It is patently annoying. However, I believe she may have known that what she did was cheating, because there is an entire afterword that explains away/tries to excuse the cheat that was used. In addition to the cheat, Darcy is completely ignorant of the detailed workings of his household, which doesn't ring at all true.
I will say that some of the characters Jeffers introduces are interesting, albeit transparent. There is a point in the middle of the book where one forgets briefly how cloying the first third of the book had been, and actually has hope for the rest of the story. That point ends. The reader is left with a situation where flawless, superhuman Elizabeth does things she would not be physically and emotionally capable of, Darcy is so besotted with his wife and finding opportunities to bed her that he misses what is right under his nose, and a completely implausible and ridiculous "answer" to the mystery is presented.
Aside from the saccharine perfection and constant doting of our main characters, and the fact that everyone in the book - including unsavory characters - thinks that Elizabeth is the best person on Earth, the mystery aspect leaves much to be desired. I am an avid mystery reader as well as an Austen fan. I was excited to discover that the two had been combined. That said, some rules for good mystery writing were not followed here. I will not give away the plot for those who wish to read this despite all of the negative reviews, but the author cheats on the mystery. The reader is deliberately deceived, and not in a clever way. There might be one fleeting sentence in the book where you stop and think "Oh, is the author going there? Really? That would be a cop-out." Yes, she does go there. It is patently annoying. However, I believe she may have known that what she did was cheating, because there is an entire afterword that explains away/tries to excuse the cheat that was used. In addition to the cheat, Darcy is completely ignorant of the detailed workings of his household, which doesn't ring at all true.
I will say that some of the characters Jeffers introduces are interesting, albeit transparent. There is a point in the middle of the book where one forgets briefly how cloying the first third of the book had been, and actually has hope for the rest of the story. That point ends. The reader is left with a situation where flawless, superhuman Elizabeth does things she would not be physically and emotionally capable of, Darcy is so besotted with his wife and finding opportunities to bed her that he misses what is right under his nose, and a completely implausible and ridiculous "answer" to the mystery is presented.
April 16, 2011
Newly married Elizabeth Darcy is about to experience her first true Derbyshire winter. A big snowstorm is on its way and is expected to keep residents of all the neighboring counties inside and immobile for a few days. Arriving just in time for this terrible blizzard is Darcy's aunt, Lady Catherine, with her daughter Anne and her daughter's companion, Mrs. Jenkinson, and Elizabeth's sister, Lydia Wickham. When Darcy goes to pick up Lydia at the Lambton Inn, he generously offers to provide shelter for four additional guests who have no place to stay. Elizabeth and Darcy are now faced with the difficult task of entertaining eight snowbound guests, two of which include a boisterous and bored Lydia Wickham and a seriously displeased Lady Catherine!
Soon after the arrival of these eight guests, strange things start to occur... items go missing, a harmful trap is discovered, and a murder is committed... Who is behind it all? Is it one of the “unexpected” guests? A disgruntled employee? Someone out for revenge? Or, is it truly a phantom?
To continue reading, go to: http://janeaustenreviews.blogspot.com...
Soon after the arrival of these eight guests, strange things start to occur... items go missing, a harmful trap is discovered, and a murder is committed... Who is behind it all? Is it one of the “unexpected” guests? A disgruntled employee? Someone out for revenge? Or, is it truly a phantom?
To continue reading, go to: http://janeaustenreviews.blogspot.com...
could_not_finish
June 26, 2011The author tries a little too hard to copy Austen's "voice" and it fell very flat for me.
"'Must we?' Elizabeth Darcy gave her husband an expectant look. 'I so enjoy being alone with you--away from the responsibilities of Pemberly.'"
Flat yet nauseatingly sappy. Not a good combination for me.
The phrases from Austen's original work that were inserted actually distracted me rather than adding to the book. It was quickly turning into a game of Spot the Original Phrasing.
"Darcy took in her countenance. Hers was a face he had once described as being one of the handsomest of his acquaintance, but now he considered that compliment a slight to the woman. Her auburn hair, her fine sea-green eyes, her pale skin, her delicate features, and her heart-shaped face made her a classic beauty, and Darcy thought himself the luckiest of men."
I have to admit that it somehow seems wrong to read about Elizabeth and Darcy in bed together as well.
I think I read the first chapter and decided life was too short. Moving on.
"'Must we?' Elizabeth Darcy gave her husband an expectant look. 'I so enjoy being alone with you--away from the responsibilities of Pemberly.'"
Flat yet nauseatingly sappy. Not a good combination for me.
The phrases from Austen's original work that were inserted actually distracted me rather than adding to the book. It was quickly turning into a game of Spot the Original Phrasing.
"Darcy took in her countenance. Hers was a face he had once described as being one of the handsomest of his acquaintance, but now he considered that compliment a slight to the woman. Her auburn hair, her fine sea-green eyes, her pale skin, her delicate features, and her heart-shaped face made her a classic beauty, and Darcy thought himself the luckiest of men."
I have to admit that it somehow seems wrong to read about Elizabeth and Darcy in bed together as well.
I think I read the first chapter and decided life was too short. Moving on.
July 15, 2019
I will preface this by saying, I'm not a Jane Austen purist. I tried reading P&P but she was just too wordy for me. I did however enjoy the movie. Anyway, I read the reviews on Goodreads prior to starting this book and I ALMOST didn't listen. The reviews were scathing but had one common theme--it wasn't like the original P&P/Jane Austen-ish enough. So I gave it a try and must say, I actually enjoyed it. Darcy and Elizabeth got on my nerves just a bit with all of the romance (I was in the mood for purely mystery) but I enjoyed them for the most part. The mystery was interesting and I never quiet knew who the phantom was. I had my ideas but it didn't fit what I was hearing. I was struck once everything was revealed. Although I enjoyed this read, it was not perfect. The author took too long to set the scene. The occupants of Pembereley were at times obtuse--i.e. about how the phantom moved around. I will say, if you're a HUGE fan of Austen/P&P, you have to approach this with an open mind, perhaps disassociate it from Austen. I found it very enjoyable.
Story and Narration: 4
Story and Narration: 4
May 2, 2011
I'm always skeptical when I pick up a book that claims to continue Elizabeth and Darcy's story post-Pride & Prejudice. I have never made it more than ten pages into one, and I figured this book would be the same. More anachronistic attitudes and behaviors, speech, and actions on the part of the characters I love so dearly...but actually, this book stayed as true to the original as I think it could have. I liked the character development of those from the actual book - Lady Catherine, Anne, Georgiana, etc. all were much more fully formed. While I found some of the more progressive character developments a bit out of place given the setting, it wasn't some violent departure from Jane Austen's novel and I loved how long of a book it was. It took awhile to read, but it was an enjoyable experience the entire time.
April 8, 2021
Regina Jeffers is one of those authors that never disappoints. I believe I've read every JAFF book she's written and I have yet to find one that I didn't really enjoy. This story was fantastically full of twists and turns that sends the reader guessing at who the culprit is, who the next victim will be, and just who exactly is the true target and why. I couldn't wait to finish the book and was sad when I did, which in my opinion, is the sign of a very good book.
July 1, 2016
I liked this book. The mystery is intriguing. The characters are familiar.
December 26, 2023
The Phantom of Pemberley
This variation is filled with just about every possible intrigue one can imagine. The background: a severe winter storm descends upon Derbyshire just as the Darcys were picking up Lydia Wickham who has travelled from Newcastle. The inn at Lambton has filled up due to the changing weather conditions. Among those stranded are the two that travelled with Lydia, a Mr. Nigel Worth and Mrs. Evelyn Williams, Lord Stafford and his mistress. With Lydia’s insistence, the coach’s travelers are invited to Pemberley and since Lord Stafford is a friend of his cousins, they too are invited to wait out the storm. Thrown into the mixture comes Lady Catherine de Bourgh and her daughter Anne along with her faithful servant, Mrs. Jenkinson. Needless to say, Darcy is less than thrilled with list of characters that have taken refuge at Pemberley. Righty so, because strange things begin to happen as the harsh weather descends upon the great estate. Strange sightings of shadowy figures, figures appearing in rooms where doors are locked, and murders are beginning to add up throughout the estate. Some of Pemberley’s inhabitants proved to be staunch defenders helping Darcy try to figure out what was going on, but others were part of the strange goings on. Hidden within the dark depths of Pemberley was a evil with mixed personalities all bent on revenge. When the weather begins to clear, Sir Phillip Spurlock, the magistrate, is summoned. As the investigation continues and various characters are revealed, the phantom perpetrator identified, Elizabeth Darcy needs to keep her wits about her if she is to escape the phantom menace. Wounded, but not dead as the killer had hoped, Darcy defeats the killer. As the inhabitants of Pemberley begin to recover, Mr. Bennet and the Bingleys are sent for as they are needed to aid with Lydia’s recovery. As the weather settles in Spring, Pemberley awaits the birth of hopefully the heir to Darcy estate.
This variation is filled with just about every possible intrigue one can imagine. The background: a severe winter storm descends upon Derbyshire just as the Darcys were picking up Lydia Wickham who has travelled from Newcastle. The inn at Lambton has filled up due to the changing weather conditions. Among those stranded are the two that travelled with Lydia, a Mr. Nigel Worth and Mrs. Evelyn Williams, Lord Stafford and his mistress. With Lydia’s insistence, the coach’s travelers are invited to Pemberley and since Lord Stafford is a friend of his cousins, they too are invited to wait out the storm. Thrown into the mixture comes Lady Catherine de Bourgh and her daughter Anne along with her faithful servant, Mrs. Jenkinson. Needless to say, Darcy is less than thrilled with list of characters that have taken refuge at Pemberley. Righty so, because strange things begin to happen as the harsh weather descends upon the great estate. Strange sightings of shadowy figures, figures appearing in rooms where doors are locked, and murders are beginning to add up throughout the estate. Some of Pemberley’s inhabitants proved to be staunch defenders helping Darcy try to figure out what was going on, but others were part of the strange goings on. Hidden within the dark depths of Pemberley was a evil with mixed personalities all bent on revenge. When the weather begins to clear, Sir Phillip Spurlock, the magistrate, is summoned. As the investigation continues and various characters are revealed, the phantom perpetrator identified, Elizabeth Darcy needs to keep her wits about her if she is to escape the phantom menace. Wounded, but not dead as the killer had hoped, Darcy defeats the killer. As the inhabitants of Pemberley begin to recover, Mr. Bennet and the Bingleys are sent for as they are needed to aid with Lydia’s recovery. As the weather settles in Spring, Pemberley awaits the birth of hopefully the heir to Darcy estate.
November 13, 2025
very original p/p plot!
Greatly admire this author’s work, & this variant doesn’t disappoint. ODC is totally in love with each other, devoted to the success of Pemberly & to their families’ happiness. during the 1st chapter became vexed @ Lydia’s greed. I can confess didn’t understand the significance of Lydia flirting w/fellow passengers on the mail coach as she travelled to visit Lizzy to ask for $ to help sustain her marriage (iykyk), but the ending certainly brought that exchange into vivid focus! Quite cleverly done. Poor foolish Lydia and her overwhelming need to be center of attention brings disaster to Pemberly; all the while exposing several visitors weakness during a snow storm (how’s that for a u should read this clue). Kinda reminded me of a well done ‘who done it’ on our National Public TV channel.
Basics: Lydia comes to beg $ to keep George W happy, at same time many unexpected visitors arrive during heavy snow storm needing shelter; unexpected personal tragedies exposed & deaths bc of this confluence. EBD is rather wishy washy despite being devoted to FD (always fretting Darcy will send her away bc of her lack of connections, ties to the badly behaved Wickhams, & the presence of more eligible titled & wealthy Ladies of the Ton during storm forcing ppl in close proximity — & revealing lovelorn hopes. It sounds like a mess, but promise it all makes sense last third of the book with an ending which shocked me in a good way (teach me to skim! lol) will read again. Great job. Def recommend to JAFF fans
Greatly admire this author’s work, & this variant doesn’t disappoint. ODC is totally in love with each other, devoted to the success of Pemberly & to their families’ happiness. during the 1st chapter became vexed @ Lydia’s greed. I can confess didn’t understand the significance of Lydia flirting w/fellow passengers on the mail coach as she travelled to visit Lizzy to ask for $ to help sustain her marriage (iykyk), but the ending certainly brought that exchange into vivid focus! Quite cleverly done. Poor foolish Lydia and her overwhelming need to be center of attention brings disaster to Pemberly; all the while exposing several visitors weakness during a snow storm (how’s that for a u should read this clue). Kinda reminded me of a well done ‘who done it’ on our National Public TV channel.
Basics: Lydia comes to beg $ to keep George W happy, at same time many unexpected visitors arrive during heavy snow storm needing shelter; unexpected personal tragedies exposed & deaths bc of this confluence. EBD is rather wishy washy despite being devoted to FD (always fretting Darcy will send her away bc of her lack of connections, ties to the badly behaved Wickhams, & the presence of more eligible titled & wealthy Ladies of the Ton during storm forcing ppl in close proximity — & revealing lovelorn hopes. It sounds like a mess, but promise it all makes sense last third of the book with an ending which shocked me in a good way (teach me to skim! lol) will read again. Great job. Def recommend to JAFF fans
September 12, 2023
In the face of adversity, it helps to know that you have a partner to help see you through it! Elizabeth Bennet married Fitzwilliam Darcy, and this story takes place less than one year following their marriage. The young couple are deeply in love and determined to face all of life's obstacles together, as it should be.
Author, Regina Jeffers has become one of my favorite writers as I have come to love her Regency Romances, particularly her retelling and variations of the Jane Austen classics. "The Phantom of Pemberly" is one of her best! There are just so many things happening in this book, including murder and mayhem at Pemberly, a collasal snowstorm stranding unknown visitors at Pemberly, an announcement of ODC, and so much more. The plot, sub-plots, and plot twists kept me on the edge of my seat! I loved our usual characters, and the new characters added to this book were so interesting and refreshing! I can't wait for the next great adventure on which she will take me!
Author, Regina Jeffers has become one of my favorite writers as I have come to love her Regency Romances, particularly her retelling and variations of the Jane Austen classics. "The Phantom of Pemberly" is one of her best! There are just so many things happening in this book, including murder and mayhem at Pemberly, a collasal snowstorm stranding unknown visitors at Pemberly, an announcement of ODC, and so much more. The plot, sub-plots, and plot twists kept me on the edge of my seat! I loved our usual characters, and the new characters added to this book were so interesting and refreshing! I can't wait for the next great adventure on which she will take me!
May 30, 2025
2025 is still a good read.
*****
HAPPILY MARRIED for over a year and more in love than ever, Darcy and Elizabeth can’t imagine anything interrupting their bliss-filled days. Then an intense snowstorm strands a group of travelers at Pemberley, and terrifying accidents and mysterious deaths begin to plague the manor. Everyone seems convinced it is a phantom's work—a Shadow Man who is haunting the Darcy family’s grand estate. Darcy and Elizabeth believe the truth is much more menacing and that someone is attempting to murder them. The story is a good read with a good narration. ( I "read" the Audible edition.)
*****
A Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery by Regina Jeffers
1. The Phantom of Pemberley (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #1)
2. Christmas at Pemberley (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery 1.5?)
3. The Disappearance of Georgiana Darcy (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #2)
4. The Mysterious Death of Mr. Darcy (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #3)
5. The Prosecution of Mr. Darcy's Cousin (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #4)
6. Darcy's Passions: Pride and Prejudice Retold Through His Eyes (#6)
7. Darcy's Temptation: A Sequel to Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice (7)
*****
HAPPILY MARRIED for over a year and more in love than ever, Darcy and Elizabeth can’t imagine anything interrupting their bliss-filled days. Then an intense snowstorm strands a group of travelers at Pemberley, and terrifying accidents and mysterious deaths begin to plague the manor. Everyone seems convinced it is a phantom's work—a Shadow Man who is haunting the Darcy family’s grand estate. Darcy and Elizabeth believe the truth is much more menacing and that someone is attempting to murder them. The story is a good read with a good narration. ( I "read" the Audible edition.)
*****
A Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery by Regina Jeffers
1. The Phantom of Pemberley (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #1)
2. Christmas at Pemberley (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery 1.5?)
3. The Disappearance of Georgiana Darcy (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #2)
4. The Mysterious Death of Mr. Darcy (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #3)
5. The Prosecution of Mr. Darcy's Cousin (Pride and Prejudice Murder Mystery, #4)
6. Darcy's Passions: Pride and Prejudice Retold Through His Eyes (#6)
7. Darcy's Temptation: A Sequel to Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice (7)
May 13, 2020
I want to try another book in this series because my main issue was not the writing. I loved the interplay that Ms. Jeffers wrote between Elizabeth and Darcy. Their banter was perfection.
The reason this book is not higher rated for me is the plot. It went off the rails for me in the final act and it got weird.
I will not post spoilers but the resolution of the mystery did not work for me as a reader. It brought everything else in the book down for me.
I plan to give this series another chance because I loved the way many of the characters were written. I am hoping that with the mystery from this novel out of the way, the next will be more enjoyable.
The reason this book is not higher rated for me is the plot. It went off the rails for me in the final act and it got weird.
I will not post spoilers but the resolution of the mystery did not work for me as a reader. It brought everything else in the book down for me.
I plan to give this series another chance because I loved the way many of the characters were written. I am hoping that with the mystery from this novel out of the way, the next will be more enjoyable.
November 5, 2021
Got about half way through and then skimmed to the ending, which was pretty silly. Listen, if you're going to make one of the original characters a murderer, own it properly. Be proud of it! Don't hide it behind a disease you've decided to introduce in this book. *eye roll*
Beyond the ludicrous premise behind the murders, this book suffered from pacing and length. It could and should have been shorter, with a faster pace. Also, I got from the first few pages that this version of Darcy & Elizabeth like to fuck. Got it. Oh, but there was more--in case you ever wondered if they like to fuck. Yes, yes they do.
Beyond the ludicrous premise behind the murders, this book suffered from pacing and length. It could and should have been shorter, with a faster pace. Also, I got from the first few pages that this version of Darcy & Elizabeth like to fuck. Got it. Oh, but there was more--in case you ever wondered if they like to fuck. Yes, yes they do.
July 8, 2020
I am always in love with the writing style of Regina Jeffers, she has a way of keeping true to the characters while also showing you more of them. This book was a wonderful mystery, it kept you wondering how the villain (or villains) would be caught and how exactly they knew each other. You were given glimpses, just enough to answer a little of one of your questions but adding in several more.
It will keep you guessing until the end, telling yourself that you will read just one more chapter. :-)
It will keep you guessing until the end, telling yourself that you will read just one more chapter. :-)
October 13, 2025
This was a fun book, and considering its length and that I was interested enough to finish it, I think that's worth 4 stars. I was hooked for a while, until maybe two-thirds of the way through when I just lost interest in the central mystery. By then I had become more absorbed in the secondary plot lines and felt they were competing too much with the phantom plot. Since I wanted to know how it ended, I forced myself to finish it. In the end, it was a clever story with more twists and turns than I was expecting. I would be interested in reading more from this author.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 178 reviews