Entertaining and challenging mini-mysteries by Hy Conrad (5 stars)
Almost Perfect Crimes is the first of two books by Hy Conrad that contain mini-mysteries in the style of lateral puzzles. it was followed by Whodunit - You Decide!, which is a similar title. Hy Conrad has also produced many shorter mini-mystery stories, such as the single-page narratives found in compilations like Little Giant Book of Whodunits and Little Giant Book of Mini-Mysteries. The mysteries in Almost Perfect Crimes and Whodunit - You Decide! are much more developed, challenging, and interesting, and have more elements to them.
The book is divided into several sections:
1. Introduction: a brief explanation of how to use the book.
2. The mysteries: 15 mysteries, each outlined in about two pages. In most cases your challenge is to figure out who the murderer is, and how or why.
3. Evidence: clues for each mystery are provided, arranged under relevant headings like Affidavits, Autopsy Reports, Crime Scene Reports, Lab & Hospital Reports, Examinations, Searches, Research, Wills & Insurance.
4. Analysis of Evidence: this section gives some preliminary conclusions to help you towards the final answer.
5. Solutions: the solutions to each mystery, including an explanation for each.
Some cases are easier than others, but most of them will require you to read all the evidence and the preliminary analysis, and even then some of them are very hard to figure out. But even if you don't solve the mysteries, they are highly entertaining to read, because in most cases the solution is very satisfying. If you like whodunits and a good murder mystery, you'll enjoy this book as a good read, but it will especially appeal to people who enjoy trying to figure out whodunits and puzzles for themselves.
While the sequel Whodunit has 12 mysteries, Almost Perfect Crimes has 15 mysteries, and on the whole I found the ones in this earlier book to be more plausible and solid all round. The only disadvantage of this book is the set-up. The evidence is sprinkled around through various sections, so you need to keep flipping pages backwards and forwards to read back over the clues for each case. And you’ll be doing that in your quest for the solution, since often it's small details that are important to notice to solve the case. Whodunit improved on this set-up by putting all the evidence for each case in one spot, making that book slightly easier to use than this one.
The puzzles remind me somewhat of the cases in the board game 221B Baker Street, and will appeal to a similar audience (although the ones in this book are definitely harder and more rewarding than the board game). I've also used these mysteries in a party setting, where we tried to solve a mystery as a group, which is a great way to use these as well. This book should appeal to anyone who enjoys murder mysteries and lateral puzzles, and is a thoughtful collection of 15 mysteries. For maximum enjoyment, follow the advice in the book - just enjoy one a day, rather than attempting them all in one sitting!