Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Chocolate Roses

Rate this book
She’s in love . . .
he’s out of reach . . .
Is there any hope?

Janie Rose Whitaker’s world revolved around her chocolate shop until Roger Wentworth and his young daughter moved into the apartment across from Janie’s. Anyone would think Roger fit the mold of the “perfect” guy, but soon Janie discovers secrets that could keep them apart forever. Though she resists getting involved in Roger’s complicated life, they are drawn further into a bittersweet relationship.

You will laugh, cry, and crave chocolate as you read this LDS parody of the classic novel 'Jane Eyre.'

234 pages, Paperback

First published March 31, 2010

2 people are currently reading
267 people want to read

About the author

Joan Sowards

24 books34 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
29 (15%)
4 stars
57 (30%)
3 stars
65 (34%)
2 stars
25 (13%)
1 star
10 (5%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews
Profile Image for jyweniverel.
620 reviews
September 9, 2011
I loved reading this book. Jane Eyre is one of my favorite classics so I was a bit taken aback that someone would try (and succeed!) in making a modern day version of the tale.

Janie is brutally honest about herself, it makes me wish that I could be like that, unfortunately we live in the real world, and everyone does love chocolate.

I liked how Emily and Flo became best of buds. Instead of just mentioning casually that Janie owned a dog, Flo was made into a main character in herself, and if you can't tell, I am a dog-lover.

This book is a, "I don't want it to end, but I need to know what happens!" book. I enjoyed reading it immensely.
Profile Image for Mara.
664 reviews
April 22, 2010
Chocolate Roses is a cute, light LDS (mormon) romance. This modern re-telling of Jane Eyre is creative, sweet and tastefully done.

One thing I would have like to see was more of a friendship develop between Janie and Roger. For most of the book, I felt that their relationship was very one-sided and based purely on how georgeous Roger looked as he remained oblivious to Janie and her many charms.

I am excited to see what this author will do next and will pass this one around to all my book friends.
Profile Image for Malina.
7 reviews
July 11, 2010
Having never read Jane Eyre or an lds book before, I had low expectations for this book, but was pleasantly surprised. It held my interest.
Profile Image for Leah.
103 reviews
July 13, 2010
I LOVED this book, I thought it was hilarious and very tender...loved it, loved it, loved it.
Profile Image for Heidi Pack.
524 reviews8 followers
December 15, 2017
I was worried it would be a terribly predictable parody, with the un-original character names, but it was sweet and interesting.
Profile Image for Hila.
435 reviews4 followers
February 15, 2022
2.5 rounded.

Romance isn't my typical preferred genre, but thought I'd try one for Valentine's Day. A friend had given me this, so I tried it out. It just felt too unbelievable for me.
Profile Image for Charlene.
Author 1 book95 followers
August 27, 2012
Janie Whitaker is in looovveee. With a man she sees for a few minutes every week, when he comes in to buy some chocolate to be delivered to a mysterious person at a mental institution. He barely acknowledges her, barely knows that she is there, yet she has an instant infatuation with him because he’s extremely handsome and has very sad eyes. Not really the stuff of inspiring romance - I could have used a little more character development with Roger Wentworth. He is a good man of course, but since Janie hardly knows him, I hardly know him. The book has an LDS slant, and most of the main characters are Mormons, with one character converting in the book. Not being of that faith myself, I was a little confused at some of the things Mormons do as part of their religion, but it is not a major part of the book.

There is some intrigue with the secret Mr. and Mrs. Wentworth are keeping, but Janie does know fairly early on that Mr. Wentworth is married and she does her best to fight her feelings for him. That conflict then is pretty straightforward, and I had a hard time feeling much sympathy with Janie since she knew what she was getting into. This novel is a modern update of Jane Eyre, (there are also quotes from the original novel, heading each chapter) but the whole thing felt very sanitized, and Mr. Wentworth seemed more like a cardboard cutout of a character for Janie to project her feelings on to. And I suppose because she was Mormon, Janie was far too concerned with obtaining a husband sometimes and that made me admire her character less. The supporting characters - mainly the ones who work in the shop with Janie - were more entertaining and the more oblique nods to characters in Jane Eyre (like John, the Baptist, Trevor, and Janie’s dog, Flo) made me smile because I appreciated their inclusion in the story. Overall, this story was quite passion-less for me; I didn’t feel particularly moved by the characters, or their predicament, the main interest it held for me was in how aspects of Jane Eyre were worked into the story.
Profile Image for Tristi.
Author 228 books190 followers
July 29, 2010
When I first learned that Joan Sowards had written an LDS romance novel based on the novel "Jane Eyre," I was immediately intrigued. I remember reading "Jane Eyre" when I was seventeen and had my wisdom teeth out. Swooning over the dark and brooding Mr. Rochester was the only thing that made my recovery bearable. And Timothy Dalton did a very good job in the movie, much better than Orson Welles did, and ... well, this review isn't about Timothy Dalton, so we'll save him for another day.

"Chocolate Roses" is the story of Janie Rose Whitaker, a young lady who has devoted her life to building the success of her chocolate shop. She thinks about romance and marriage, but those things just don't seem to be in her stars. But she certainly does look forward to the one day a week when Mr. Roger Wentworth comes in to buy a chocolate rose. Her heart starts to pound, her breath quickens ... well, can't really blame her, when he's as good-looking as he is.

When he moves in to the apartment next door, along with his cute little daughter, Janie has the chance to get to know him a little closer up. She likes what she sees, but his mood swings are off-putting, and when she learns his deep, dark secret, she suddenly understands why he acts the way he does.

I enjoyed this light-hearted parody. I did wish that the ending had been drawn out a little more and didn't conclude so quickly, but all in all, this is a nice summer read and I'm sure you'll find plenty of opportunities to sneak a handful of M & M's while reading it. It would be almost wrong not to ...
Profile Image for Marsha Ward.
Author 42 books60 followers
September 28, 2010
Although the subtitle of Chocolate Roses by Joan Sowards is A Jane Eyre Parody, I didn't find the satiric aspects in the work that the word parody brings to my mind. I found Joan's novel to be much lighter than the original by Charlotte Bronte, but I would have called it a contemporary re-setting, or, given Joan's credentials as a consummate musician, an arrangement of Jane Eyre.

Extracting a simpler plot from Jane Eyre for her novel was a good trick, and Joan pulled it off. She peopled the work with interesting minor characters and sub-plots that made the whole an enjoyable read.

I liked Janie Whitaker; she was spunkier than Jane Eyre, and I found her to be in much the same circumstances as me long years ago: single and older than I thought I'd be before I found love and marriage. I'd macheted my way through many of the same emotions, and made similar bargains with God as Janie did. I'm glad she held onto her values despite the internal pressures, the gossips, and the jealousy swirling around her.

Mr. Roger Wentworth (a tip of the hat to Jane Austen?) was a genuinely good man in a tragic situation, not the brooding, older man who tried to pull the wool over the eyes of a naive young woman and the community like Mr. Rochester did. I write conflicted characters who try to do the right thing, so I liked him, too.

I like satisfying endings.

I like chocolate.

What's not to like in this novel? Go buy it.
Profile Image for Betsy Love.
Author 53 books50 followers
June 6, 2011
I finished this book last night, late, really late. While the book is a parody of Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte, it does not have the dark, foreboding style of Bronte's novel.

Set in Mesa, Arizona the story revolves around...you guessed it...chocolate roses. The mysterious Roger Wentworth comes into Janie's chocolate shop and orders a chocolate rose to be sent to a gated mansion on Val Vista, and he always takes with him a whimsical chocolate piece, the first for his insane wife, Winnie and the second for his charming four year old daughter, Emily.

When Roger moves into the condos where Janie lives, she is further drawn into the intrigue of not only the mystery surrounding Winnie, but also those who will stop at nothing to convince Roger to change his story as a witness to a murder.

I love the first person view point of Janie Whitaker as she tells her tail. I felt as if Janie had asked me to pull up a chair in her shop while she told me all about her adventures, sharing her inner most thoughts as if I was her sweet sister, Kylee. Everything about the character kept me grounded in the story. It was fun to watch in shocked amusement as she received two proposals in one week, one of which paralleled the story line of the original Jane Eyre to marry and travel to India.

(SPOILER ALERT) I was not surprised by the fire which destroyed the mansion, and killed Roger's wife.

I loved the book. It's my favorite one of Joan's, so far.
687 reviews8 followers
April 5, 2014
(Genre:LDS Fiction/Romance) 2 stars. Meh. I was rather lukewarm about this one. This book is listed as a "LDS Jane Eyre Parody" and it was okay. Not "bad", but not really good either.
Jane and her sister Kylee are orphans that were raised by their eccentric Aunt Lucy. Upon reaching adulthood, the sisters open up their own chocolate shop. Kylee (the older sister) is married with 3 children while Janie is 27 and single. The highlight of Janie's week is Tuesday-that's when HE comes in the shop. Roger Wentworth is a very handsome man in a suit that comes to the shop every Tuesday to order a chocolate rose to be delivered to one Winnie Wentworth. Janie is besotted with Roger even though they have never had a conversation beyond his buying his chocolate. She knows nothing about him or his life, but she is in love. When he moves in next door with his 4 year old daughter, Janie is sure it is fate-they are meant to be together.
If you are familiar with Jane Eyre, then you can see where everything is going. While I liked some of the side characters that worked in the shop, I found myself just not connecting with Janie and Roger. I had a hard time understanding her infatuation with Roger just based on his looks and their limited conversations. Since I wasn't falling for him, I couldn't understand why she would :). However, I may have been overly hard on it based on how I much I love the original "Jane Eyre" novel and its main characters.
Profile Image for Joyce.
Author 22 books587 followers
July 2, 2010
I'd give this book 4.75 stars, if Goodreads would let me!

Chocolate Roses, by Joan Sowards, bills itself as “A Jane Eyre Parody” for LDS readers. Now, I have read Jane Eyre, and have even watched an adaptation on PBS, but both have been a very long time ago. So I’ll be honest…I had to look up a summary on Wikipedia.com to remind myself how the story went. Chocolate Roses can be enjoyed in its own right, but having at least a glancing familiarity with Jane Eyre will heighten your enjoyment even more.

The protagonist of Chocolate Roses, Janie Rose Whitaker, is a wonderfully well-rounded character, as is her best friend and roommate, Flo the Great Dane. (Yes, I’m talking dog here!) This book is full of humor, sure to tickle many a reader’s funny bone, as well as romance and yes (being true to Jane Eyre) unavoidable tragedy. All are handled with a delightfully deft hand that makes this book very hard to put down.

Chocolate Roses is clearly aimed at an LDS reading audience, being chockfull of LDS cultural and doctrinal references. But any church-going reader of any faith will likely find much to relate to here, too.

Summary: One of the best LDS novels I’ve read in a very long time!
Profile Image for Margaret Larsen Turley.
83 reviews25 followers
May 14, 2010
Joan Sowards has been a friend to me for nearly twenty five years. Our relationship started with my asking help to notate some music on a computer program. She gave her time to me selflessly and was generous with her advice and skills in guiding me when I needed it. When my cousin Kerry Blair introduced me to ANWA in 1998 it was a warm surprise that our mutual friend Joan Sowards was part of the Daytimer’s Chapter.

Joan’s new Book Chocolate Roses not only sounds good enough to melt in your mouth, it looks good enough to eat. It has been fun hearing the developing stages as we critiqued passages in our chapter meetings month to month. I’m very happy for Joan that her wonderful Jane Eyre Parody has made it to the bookstore shelves. The Heroine, Janie Rose Whitaker’s world revolved around her chocolate shop until Roger Wentworth and his young daughter moved into the apartment across from Janie’s. Anyone would think Roger fit the mold of the “perfect” guy, but soon Janie discovers secrets that could keep them apart forever. Though she resists getting involved in Roger’s complicated life, they are drawn further into a bittersweet relationship. This novel will make you laugh, cry and carve chocolate if you didn’t before.
Profile Image for Taffy.
983 reviews62 followers
June 7, 2010
Good, clean LDS romance with intrigue, humor and chocolate.

Janie and her sister own and run a high end chocolate store. Every Tuesday, a very handsome and mysterious man enters the shop and orders a chocolate rose to be delivered. Janie has a crush (obsession) on the man. Events take an interesting turn when he and his daughter moves in next door to Janie. Add the mystery of who the rose goes to, quirky characters and a crime and you have the mixture of a good story.
The only problem I had was in my own head. I kept trying to compare it to Jane Eyre and that aspect of the book didn't work for me. The similarities were: reclusive older man with daughter; the main character is older; a crazy wife and fire.
I did like the Jane Eyre quotes at the beginning of each chapter. I didn't recognize quite a few of them so now I really want to reread Jane Eyre.
This story is a quick, witty read.
You know what would be cool with this book? A Kara's chocolate :)

Rating: PG
L: None
S: None
V: Kidnapping scene
Profile Image for Sheila (sheilasbookreviewer).
1,464 reviews55 followers
August 1, 2010
The main character Janie is likable from the start. She is 27 years old and still single. In the LDS world, that is not necessarily a fun thing to be. I can say this, because at 27 I was still single. I could relate to everything she was lamenting about. The thing I loved about Janie, is the way that she tries so hard to include humor into her outlook on life. Her best friend is her dog "Flo", her great Dane. I haven't read a book in a long time, where a pet had so much personality! Flo is her best friend that is always there for her, keeping her sane throughout the story.



Another great aspect of this book, is how well Joan writes all of her characters, not just the main female and male leads. All of the people who work in Janie's chocolate shop are also well developed and have fun side stories.

To read the rest of my review for Chocolate Roses go to my blog
at:
http://whynotbecauseisaidso.blogspot....
Profile Image for Katie (hiding in the pages).
3,503 reviews328 followers
November 18, 2010
I remember reading Jane Eyre for the first time in high school and absolutely falling in love with the story and characters. I also fell in love with Pride and Prejudice and have read many parodies of that story, but never one based off of Jane Eyre. When I saw this one, I knew I had to read it, although sometimes the retellings don't live up to the classic.

I was very pleasantly surprised! Janie and her sister, Kylee, were orphaned and raised by an aunt. After graduating from college, they took their inheritance and opened up a glamorous chocolate store. A "brooding," quiet, mysterious man comes in like clockwork each week to purchase some chocolate and Janie falls for him. I love how Ms. Sowards took such a beloved classic story and modernized it. I loved the characters, the relationships, and the mystery. I loved that Flo, the dog, had such a big part in the story. I really enjoyed everything about this book and didn't want it to end!
Author 4 books22 followers
August 7, 2010
Many authors are currently rewriting Jane Austin's works with a modern twist. Most of those are thinly-disguised updates that are poor imitations of the original. "Chocolate Roses", however is fresh and original. Janie Rose Whitaker is a complex and interesting character, a mix of independence and self-doubt.

Joan Sowardsmanages to infuse this story with tragedy, comedy, and romance. Not only will LDS readers find a clean, compelling, and fun read, but this story can be enjoyed by readers of all faiths. Take your time and savor this book just like gourmet chocolate.....without the calories!

I enjoyed this book so much I ordered Joan's previous book, "Haunt's Haven", and am in the middle of savoring every word.
Profile Image for LuAnn.
Author 13 books62 followers
January 24, 2011
Someone in marketing obviously didn't know the definition of Parody when they added the subtitle "A Jane Eyre Parody" to this absolutely delightful novel. A parody is also called send-up, spoof or lampoon, in contemporary usage, is a work created to mock, comment on, or make fun at an original work, its subject, author, style, or some other target, by means of humorous, satiric or ironic imitation. In no way did this book do any of those things. It did, however, provide a well-told story that parallels the plot of Jane Eyre, one of my favorite novels. I loved the characters, I laughed in all the right places, and left the book with a dozen of so of my friends in mind who I wanted to immediately recommend the book to for a fun read.
Profile Image for Georgiann Hennelly.
1,960 reviews25 followers
May 10, 2011
Janie and her sister own and run a high end chocolate store.E very Tuesday a handsome mysterious man comes in and orders a chocolate rose to be delivered. Janie has a crush on the man. When he and his daughter move in next to Janie events take an interesting turn. Once you add the mystery of who the rose goes goes to, a crime, and some quirky characters. And this is a wonderful story. I f you love chocolate, intrigue and romance you,ll love this book. Looking forward to reading more books by Jean Sowards.
Profile Image for Kristyn.
413 reviews17 followers
February 25, 2011
This book labeled as a Jane Eyre parody and an LDS Romance, made me wonder how it was going to work to have and LDS woman in love with a married man. It worked well! This book shows that friendship is the most important thing, and what all relationships should be based on. Her writing style was a little different. It was like having someone sit down with you and tell you their story out loud. I really liked it, and yes, it does make you want to eat chocolate. A cute romance novel and chocolate is a good combination!
Profile Image for Alyson.
1,375 reviews2 followers
July 1, 2010
I was pleasantly surprised by this book. I'd seen in reviews on goodreads that many prefered the author's first book so I was prepared to be disappointed. I've found in life that if I have low expectations of books or movies that I often end up enjoying them.

I enjoyed this book more for the writing style and humor of the main character, Janie, than for the romance. I chuckled to myself many times. It was very clever.

Profile Image for Tamera Westhoff.
1,091 reviews6 followers
May 21, 2011
I liked it, but I was very scared to read it. I remember the plot of Jane Eyre and wasn't sure how that would translate happily to an LDS novel. I am very glad that I am married, because if I was "older" and single and attracted to a married man, YIKES! I was sorry to see the wife die, and how much Janie was so depressed when she couldn't have "her" man. I think this was very well-written, I just don't like the whole coveting after someone else's husband (or wife), no matter what.
Profile Image for Shauna.
975 reviews23 followers
November 11, 2012
WOW! This book was GOOD!
Janie is a chocolatier and she has a favorite customer!
He comes to the store every Tuesday at 9:00am and orders a chocolate rose...
Then the story takes a swirling, chocolaty spin...
9:00am Tuesday morning customer
turns into the new neighbor
turns into friend
turns into "off limits"
turns into...
I won't give it away...you MUST READ!
Sweet, clean romance with rich morsels of humor.
It will leave you savoring in it's delectable, deliciousness :)
Profile Image for Sarah Beggs.
Author 6 books2 followers
March 11, 2013
I really enjoyed Chocolate Roses by Joan Sowards! In fact, I enjoyed it so much that I wished I had time to read it straight through. Sowards' humor throughout the read and description of the various locations in this book were right on. I could easily envision the mystery, love, and heartache of love and love lost which she shares to build to a surprising and fulfilling climax. I wish the chocolate shop she writes about existed, I would surely be a fan of it as well!
Profile Image for Heather.
243 reviews15 followers
June 22, 2010
I am not a big chocolate lover (I would rather eat potato chips), I absolutely hate dogs that slober in massive quantities, and I have never read Jane Eyre. However, I found this book to be quite cute. I loved the chapter quotes from Jane Eyre at the beginning of each chapter - maybe that should be my next book to read!
Profile Image for Annalisa.
386 reviews
August 9, 2010
This is an entertaining modern day LDS parody of Jane Eyre. While I don't remember reading Jane Eyre it has now inspired me to do so with each of the quotations listed in the chapter headings. Be prepared to crave chocolate as you follow chocolatier Janie Whitaker and her interesting relationship with the handsome and mysterious Roger Wentworth.
2 reviews9 followers
October 26, 2010
I wanted to like this so much, because I love Jane Eyre. However this was a disappointing novel. I didn't like the relationship between Roger and Janie, I felt underwhelmed. I didn't buy that they actually cared about each other. Janie was just a creepy stalker, and Roger just used her as a babysitter until his wife died. I'm being a little dramatic, but I just didn't like it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Kacey Kendrick Wagner.
212 reviews5 followers
January 24, 2011
I don't really like LDS fiction...
And I don't really like Jane Eyre...
So, no surprise that I didn't really like this modern day LDS Jane Eyre parody. In fact, I never would have picked this up to read on my own. (I read it for book club.) But, it was a quick read...and definitely wasn't as bad as I thought it was going to be. So that's saying something!
Profile Image for Erin.
87 reviews
February 7, 2011
I liked it...except for the ending. It was so predictable (even with it being a Jame Eyre parody) that I cringed when I stuttered through the ending. I enjoyed all of the characters and appreciated the LDS theme and how the author often "spoke" to the reader. Overall it was a sappy, clean romance novel that caught my interest and held it until the end.
Profile Image for Christina Tarbet.
79 reviews12 followers
April 28, 2012
Seriously! That is how it ends?!? I wanted so much more and I totally let down when I got to the last page. . .but I'm thinking the story I read wasn't complete. The story was good. Fun and enjoyable. I haven't read Jane Eyre in a REALLY REALLY long time so I didn't have anything to compare it to. Good characters. Chocolate-YUM!!! It was a quick read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.