Feels a little ridiculous to give goodreads stars to John Milton. So, my stars can be for the reader, Simon Vance. Without him I would be nowhere with this.
What to say in response to PL? I could go into womanist rant mode. But that would be boring and SO already done. Milton had a thing for child brides. Enough said.
Then there's my discomfort with his polemics, especially against the Catholic Church. But, a little historical perspective reminds me that's the way they rolled in those days. Especially J.M., who wrote more political/ecclesiastical tracts than poems.
So I am just going to state the obvious. John Milton was the Jack White of his day. I think Rolling Stone would call him "genre-bending," since he took blank verse (itself relatively new) and ran with it like a frickin' badass. He broke all the rules, but ended up sounding better than everyone else. I guess the rule breaking was part of the art.
Also, he had some really imaginative ideas, story-wise. Theologically correct? Weell... some yes, some no. But, imagine an angel eating, by way of "transubstantiation." Dorian March music in hell. A cave in heaven that contains light and darkness, so that the heavenly beings can have day and night. The earth being tilted, by angels, after the fall!
And a Satan who becomes "stupidly good" for a moment, upon seeing Eve's beauty. I'm told that Satan's character is controversial, because of these momentary lapses of evilness. I wouldn't call it heretical, myself. He does always end up choosing to do the evil thing, doomed forever by pride and despair.
Maybe the point, for Milton, was that he was afraid there was a little bit of the rebel Satan in himself -- or that others might think so? After all, Milton was allied with king-killers and Protestants. So he draws a careful distinction between rebellion against God, who is always just and good, and man, who can be tyrannical and corrupt.
In any case, Satan is nothing if not theatrical, and it does make the story pretty enjoyable. Thanks for a great rendering of The Great Story, J.M.