As the seasons change, very little else does. Except maybe Hino needing to put something over his tank top. But when you have a steady diet of sugar from Nishimura and Takada, do you really need that much more?
I mean… maybe? It’s not quite that derivative, as Udachi is forced to wrestle with her newfound friends and the possibility of losing them to something as prosaic as her dreams and ambitions.
That’s probably the most interesting storyline of this particular batch, honestly, as it changes the characters but keeps the same formula as Udachi is being pretty obvious about liking Hino and he’s… definitely Hino. His dad made me laugh though - apple not falling far from the tree and all that.
I admire the way this series is playing a bit of a long game even as it keeps doing the same things over and over each volume, with minor adjustments here and there. It is, in addition to the cute moments between our leads, ultimately a story about maturing and kids maybe getting a little better than they were before.
Kasahara, in particular, is growing a lot in the face of Nishimura’s enjoyment of her company after the sports day that saw Kasahara’s return to running. The way this is handled with Kasahara refusing to pick on Nishimura and Nishimura becoming incredibly Takada-esque in her cluelessness was a hoot.
I think that if you aren’t into this series’ vibe you won’t suddenly find this is the radical new direction that changes things. My principal complaint - that these kids are way more into romance than seems likely at that age - remains the same. And we don’t get a lot of variation.
Still, the parts that do deviate are fun. There’s a bomb scare, sort of, that just goes wildly out of control in the way that only grade school imaginations can possibly achieve.
The kids’ teacher also has a moment where he very smartly uses technology to achieve a really charming moment for his class and it’s kind of nice to have a shout-out to what great teachers can do. The whole thing is both sweet and funny.
I don’t think is the greatest triumph in manga, necessarily, as sometimes it gets the grade school aspects just right (the incredibly pointless rival clubs the boys form, for example, is drowning in verisimilitude) and other times it feels these characters are all four years older at least.
But it definitely has its heart in the right place and there are worse things than watching a shy, bullied girl make friends with the help of a well-meaning goofball who probably cares for her even more than he thinks.
4 stars - mildly repetitive, but with a good message and some diversions from the norm that add a little oomph, which is strong enough for me to keep giving it a recommend.