-Thanks to Liveright Publishing and Goodreads for providing me with an Advance Reading Copy of this novel, scheduled to hit the market in a couple of months time, September 6th 2022. Here goes my honest review...-
This was definitely a mixed bag. I struggled some with it in the first half, but ended up growing quite fond of the story and the characters, even though I mostly hated them, to be honest.
My main problem with this story is its verbiage: tons and tons of unnecessary words, sentences and pages, too much beating around the bush to convey just a couple basic ideas regarding fame and human nature (yes, there's some interesting ideas here, but they are not as far as profound as the author wants them to be... or makes them look like).
Now, the thing is this story is narrated in the first person, our storyteller being the royal scribe Seger Jovi, who is basically a contradictory doofus; a writer that certainly has lots of trouble with oral communication, and is in the clumsy side, with a very grandiose idea of himself and his talents. This results in the most tedious prose at times, with endless pointless sentences and lots of learned words here and there. And while I can admit this is very fitting when considering the kind of personality that is telling the story, I also felt that it was just excessive and had me questioning if the author can really write in a different manner... and one more relatable at that.
Actually, here's what another reader had to say regarding one of Giraldi's previous works, 'Hold the Dark: "Giraldi wrote this book as if he had a thesaurus on his lap and burning desire to use every adjective and adverb he could find." I sure agree with this idea, which just makes me feel that the affectation of Seger is actually that of his creator, and this certainly is a minor issue for me as a reader (and yes, I will admit this probably has a lot to do with the fact that English is my second language... but still, I rarely have to go check the dictionary as often as I had to while reading this, if ever).
So, all in all and as I said at the beginning, a mixed bag. Some interesting ideas here, but nothing revolutionary, and some odd characters that are sure worth the reading, if only for their clownish value. All in all, it was entertaining enough, regardless of it being too heavy handed on the elaborate vocabulary.
Wouldn't go running to get another title by the same author...