Rating:: minus 3
I do not like to write reviews on this site but I need this personal reference guide. Goodreads are an Amazon shell and no more than a department of Kindle. To settle my stomach, I watched YouTube's The Little Platoon analysis of Rings of Power. He is sometimes (almost always) a wonderfully detestable English ass. He opens his essay with a horrible, racist assault on all things Welsh but he then balances that with an insightful, brutal description of a certain Bezos. 🙂 That not being enough, I also watched Lily Simpson, Shannon Makes, Biz Barclay, Alt Shift X, Mia Mulder, Alysotherlife, Acollierastro, Alizee, Crow Caller, May Moon Narrowboat, The Bands of HM Royal Marines, Sarah Millican, JohnTheDuncan, Acollierastro, Bernadette Banner, Wizards and Warriors, NerdForge, Morgan Donner, Stewart Hicks, Munecat, May, Kayama - Carmina Slovenica, TheClosetHistorian, Crecganford, Overly Sarcastic Productions, Kazachka.
I like the character cast of the series. The weaknesses of the magical world characters came to the fore at least two books ago. They are consistent but their political structure and culture have created stupid characters. This is a great example of the failure of feudalism. Using this world as a lens, European histories between ninth and sixteenth centuries are less romantic but make more sense. That is a simplistic assertion but I think that it works for an initial revaluation of the period.
By book three the romance had become a major plot thread and by book four it had become the main concern of the major characters and that continues. The banter, the constant fantasizing and body image issues are irritating. The banter moves the story towards RomCom at times during dramatic action scenes. It breaks the immersion in what should be tense moments with adolescent back and forth between two or more adults. The urgency is undercut, the adults seem idiots and the stakes are reduced to seeming inconveniences. For the romance reader, that is a minor tradeoff. For the urban fantasy reader, the story arc is sidetracked. 😐
The US military have been and continue to be the only representative of government at any level. There is no reaction from characters that magical and human beings are imprisoned with no trial and certainly no civilian oversight. Magical or human beings are held for decades but it is acceptable because they are criminals, even when they have done nothing criminal. The logic runs that the military only imprisons criminals. The detainees are criminal because they are imprisoned. That mirrors the American justice system but while limited, there are sometimes avenues available for challenging nasty civilian practices. That magical creatures accept that their freedom is at the whim of soldiers, is frightening. Ultrasecret prisons on US territories are even illegal, I think. All minorities and women lacking means in America must live in constant dread.
A journalist embarrassed the US government through exposing not only their allowing military to murder on foreign deployments but their coverup. Instead of prosecuting offenders and creating a culture of accountability, they let these people loose into broader American society. That might be a fact worth thinking about or I suppose it can be ignored and one can purchase another American flag. Julian Assange is in the Belmarsh prison (UK) for no credible charges, which was admitted by the US government. An Australian citizen persecuted for years by successive US governments, in a British prison. Added to the Guatanamo Bay prison's continued use and its worldwide infamy, this part of the book does not make a pleasant background. 😐 Watching the latest Belmarsh Conference on YouTube is very disturbing but enlightening.
The last background issue is the nature of the magical worlds. Are these spread across multiple universes or do they share the Earth's universe? The answer leads to other questions about distance and how interaction was originally initiated, since portals can only be opened to a place visited before. The use of "smirk" instead of other types of facial expressions or smiles, was totally overused. A smirk can denote several emotional states but as used it reduces reactions to the level of teen reactions.
The series delivered a fun adventure despite holes in the world building and plot. By this book, I had continued to read because the story was interesting and I had few options. For a romance reader, it may be perfect. If there were more urban fantasies on film, I might not have read past book two. 😐 Unfortunately, I have not seen very many urban fantasies on the streaming services and their other fantasies tend to the awful. The science fiction are somewhat better written than their low end print cousins and are definitely more entertaining.
I began using YouTube a little more than two years ago searching for better science fiction. I really liked the shorts on the DUST and Omeleto channels, which made my dislike of low end print greater. I was swamped by the educational and lifestyle channels but did finally stumble upon the book channels. 😍 These are friendly communities of curious, thoughtful readers who love all of the bookish experience. They are sure to appeal to any reader and I have listed some below. I also found sponsor spots on educational, essayist and documentary channels for dedicated educational video sites. I was surprised finding some of my favourite essayists and entire lecture series, in addition to documentary series on some of these sites. Nebula, Wondrium and Epic History TV are a few and I feel that all are worth a look.
I need a break before finishing the review, which means another YouTube visit. This next was brought to you by SandRhoman History, Jill Bearup, Bernadette Banner, Abbie Emmons, Merphy Napier, Dark Seas, Science of Science Fiction, The Stitchery, DUST, History Calling, The British Museum, Hazariel Costumes, Survive the Jive, Sound of Music Flashmob - Antwerp, Bella Ciao - Nikolay Kutuzov, Ro Ramdin, MANDY.
I had become accustomed to my science fiction reviews attracting a loose network of American nutcases, though they seem to have crawled back under their rocks over the last year. These self-described libertarians 😆, NeoNazis and white nationalist snowflakes are allergic to strong pushback. Urban fantasy is also probably too complex for them. On the off chance one ventures out from low end US science fiction, Claes Rees Jr/cgr710 declared that They have "won" (?).
I think that suggests that They realize that They needn't continue their flood of vile sexual and racist comments to the young boater and her mother, the Oxford Astrophysicist, the Swedish essayist or any of the many other female creators of channels which I mention. Using my name for some of them was disturbed but increasing the world's store of unpleasantness was truly disgusting. They at least have presented to the wider world, the perfect portrait of the aggrieved American man-child, blissfully unaware that "Facts don't care about your feelings"). 🤔
For details about Amazon/Goodreads policies, see my review of "Dark Horse", a good novel by Diener or Powers of the Earth, a badly written salute to the January 6, 2021 hero by Travis Corcoran (US veteran, Employee of an unnamed US agency, a decidedly committed proponent of the return of chattel slavery and with some connection to Putin's fascistic Russia).
To Claes Rees Jr/cgr710, Travis Corcoran/UP and company.
Slava Ukraini !!! --ta-- Slava Geroyam !!!
My YouTube picks of the moment.
The Life Guide, Verilybitchie, Ben and Emily, Travelling K, Wizards and Warriors, Mandy, Part Time Hobbit, The Chloe Connection, Jabzy, Dutchy, Silicon Curtain, Mia Mulder, Books and Lala, Chris and Shel, Truth to Power, Lily Simpson, James Somerton.
About Goodreads, please consider treating this site as potentially hostile. 😐
Ominous music begins. 🙂 The above member experiences were bad but after my review of Powers, Amazon employees joined the fray in support of a pro-slavery tirade. Given the Amazon treatment of their employees, it is a logical intervention. They actually seem to have managed to involve Australian Intelligence services at Pine Gap Centre in investigating a customer, myself. Bizarre. Read the reviews that I mentioned above and decide the danger.
If you do not write a negative review of popular bad science fiction titles, you may not be targeted. Still it might be prudent to remove lurkers (those friends on your list, who never post), minimize profile information, use Goodreads messaging sparingly and screenshot the odd and/or ugly. A scan of negative science fiction reviews, especially from female readers should be both frightening and enlightening. While both employees and certain members suffer from neither social nor moral restraint, it may be more important to not forget that they are American. Ominous music ends. 🙂
May we all find Good Reading! 😊
I am not overly familiar with YouTube but these are some of the channels that are favourites.
Sailing Melody, Some More News, Owen Jones, Nini Music, Up and Atom, Kiko10061980, Real Time History, AllShorts, Weir on the Move, Philosophy Tube, Prime of Midlife, The Operations Room, Jean's Thoughts, Mrs Betty Bowers, Sabine Hossenfelder, Michael Lambert, The Templin Institute, Lilly's Expat Life, The Amber Ruffin Show, NerdForge, Skip Intro, Up and Atom, Between the Wars, Alt Shift X, Dominic Noble, The Who Addicts, Acollierastro, Nomadic Crobot, Foster on the Spectrum, Ula and Josh, Arvin Ash, Elvis The Alien, Randy Rainbow, Claudia Boleyn, iiluminaughtii, Rebecca Watson, Kris Atom, Shaaba, A Day of Small Things, Kate Robson, Sasha Yanshin, With Olivia, Beautifully Bookish Bethany, Lily Alexandre, Daniel Greene, Abby Cox, Karolina Zebrowska, A Cup of Nicole, What Vivi did next, Climate Town, J. Draper, IL Neige, Cambrian Chronicles, Autumn's Boutique, Abbie Emmons, Robwords, History with Cy, Kurzgesagt, What Vivi did next, Cruising Alba, Ben and Emily, Eckharts Ladder, Lady of the Library, Deerstalker Films, Skip Intro, Jake Broe, Mauler, Kings and Generals, Tara Mooknee, Dr Becky, The Welsh Viking, Renegade Cut, The History Chap, Book Furnace, Knowing Better, The Piano Guys, Of Elves and Droids, Cass Ellis, Jay Exci, Kai Zammit, Sideprojects, That Stars War Girl, T. A. Summers, Overly Sarcastic Productions, The Leftist Cooks, Leeja Miller, NerdForge, Jessie Gender, The Narrowboat That James Built, Pike & Shot Channel, Malinda, Lives and Histories, J. Draper, Fantasy and World Music by the Fletchers, Amanda the Jedi, Xiran Jay Zhao.
I wish you a great morning, a fun afternoon, a pleasant evening, a splendid night and may we all continue learning.
A person loudly shouting for Freedom, while denying the same to others is not Human.
Meditations, Dark Sisters