While I'm Falling deftly captures the moment a child realizes that growing up means being responsible for your parents' mistakes -- and preventing yourself from making the same ones. Laura Moriarty keeps getting better and better." -- Jodi Picoult, author of Handle with Care In While I'm Falling, Laura Moriarty presents a compelling depiction of how one young woman's life changes when her family breaks up for good. Ever since her parents announced that they're getting divorced, Veronica has been falling. Hard. A junior in college, she has fallen in love. She has fallen behind in her difficult coursework. She hates her job as counselor at the dorm, and she longs for the home that no longer exists. When an attempt to escape the pressure, combined with bad luck, lands her in a terrifying situation, a shaken Veronica calls her mother for help -- only to find her former foundation too preoccupied to offer any assistance at all. But Veronica only gets to feel hurt for so long. Her mother shows up at the dorm with a surprising request -- and with the elderly family dog in tow. Boyfriend complications ensue, along with her father's sudden interest in dating. Veronica soon finds herself with a new set of problems, and new questions about love and independence. Darkly humorous, beautifully written, and filled with crystalline observations about how families fall apart, While I'm Falling takes a deep look at the relationship between a daughter and a mother when one is trying to grow up and the other is trying to stay afloat.
Laura Moriarty earned a degree is social work before returning for her M.A. in Creative Writing at the University of Kansas. She was the recipient of the George Bennett Fellowship for Creative Writing at Phillips Exeter Academy in New Hampshire. She lives in Lawrence, Kansas. http://www.lauramoriarty.net/bio.htm)
The angst of the mother-daughter relationship is thoroughly explored in this book as only the skillful writing of Laura Moriarty can do. However, also contained in this book is exploration of an example of how a long time marriage can end up in divorce. The book is structured around the parallel actions of a mother and her daughter, and as things develop their lives appear to be mirror images of each other. They both make mistakes, and they are both "falling" from their former lives into a potentially sad future. The question is, will the daughter be doomed to suffer similar consequences to those of her mother? Conversely, can the mother learn from the daughter?
The mix of family relationships includes the father, a second daughter (sister), a prospective new step mother, and of course a whole host of other characters who add suspense, love, empathy and confusing complications to the story. Anybody who has experienced the tensions of college student life -- study time versus party time -- will be able to identify with the first person narrative of Veronica, the daughter who is a student at KU. Anyone who has experienced a marriage breakup will probably be able to identify with some of the feelings expressed in the story of Veronica's mother and father as well.
The themes contained in this book will touch the lives of many readers. For those who finish the book, I believe it will enhance appreciation of their relationships with friends and family, and it will encourage their nurturing of personal relationships with loving care.
The book contains some references to and quotes from George Eliot's Middlemarch that literature buffs can appreciate. It would be an interesting exercise to compare the two novels. That brings to mind my favorite George Eliot quotation. "It's never too late to be who you might have been." That quote fits well with this book.
Another thought I had while listening to this book, "Youth is wasted on the young," (George Bernard Shaw). This book also seems to be saying that experience is wasted on the old.
I'm feeling like I'm in kind of a slump here. The past several books I've read have just been too unbelievable and all the plot-wise events have felt convenient and contrived. This one was not an exception.
For starters, the whole ice storm/accident/trucker pick up event was unnecessary. I think Moriarty was trying to add suspense, but then the trucker just lets her out anyway. Kind of ridiculous. And then, Jimmy was the thug that bullied her like they were in 3rd grade. Totally unbelievable series of events. Certainly he would be bad, but how is he gonna bill her? And keep demanding rides?
Also, too convenient that the one person she knows on campus is Haley/Simone who is also Jimmy's girlfriend (and so finds out about Natalie) and whose mom used to be friends with Natalie.
The Marley character was unnecessary (annoying neighbor from a TV sitcom, really), just there to fuel Veronica's disappointment in herself as a caring person when she blows up. Even if she had to be there, having her mom recently deceased was too much.
I found it distracting that there were 2 chapters from Natalie's POV. I get what Moriarty is trying to say about the sacrifices that mothers make (both as people and workers), but I felt like allowing Natalie to give her perspective but not Dan (the father) was a bit slanted.
If you’ve read The Rest of Her Life, you already know that Laura Moriarty has such an easy command of language that not a lot needs to happen in her books for them to seem gripping. While I’m Falling is no exception. To over simplify, a college student, Veronica, struggles with a pre-med course load and her parents divorced resulting from her mother’s indiscretion. Veronica makes one bad choice after another over the course of a pretty crappy weekend. Her mom, Natalie, is reeling from the financial consequences of the implosion of her marriage. In the hands of lesser authors the story reads like chick lit, but Moriarty’s rendition focuses more on the complex relationships within families mostly that of a mother and a mature daughter.
Moriarty is a local Kansas writer and I like that she sets her novels in the area where I live. She certainly understands the pulse of campus life and her protagonist, Veronica, deals not only with the pressures of college, but those of her disintegrating family. At one point in the novel she explains, "I was still screwing up. I couldn't stop. It was like I was in free fall." We have all had those moments when a series of events go so badly that the rug is literally pulled out from under our feet and we fall flat on our asses. This happens to several characters in this novel and the plot centers on how they face those crisis. Moriarty does a fine job of focusing on the lives of these women and their inter-relationships. In the novel, we discover that it is when the world looks bleakest and when important things have been lost that we are offered an opportunity to reevaluate our lives and discover alternative paths. This story speaks on a variety of levels about women's lives and the choices we make. I thought to give this to my daughter to read, but the passages describing Veronica's battle with Organic Chemistry were still too raw in my own daughter's experiences in her pre-med classes to find this novel entertaining! Everything she writes about the pressures and competition in that class are uncomfortably accurate.
Disappointed in this one. Theme is things falling apart: Veronica's parents marriage and her college classes are out of control. Then she makes some bad choices and those get out of control. For me the premises and situations of this book were so unimaginative. Like if the author was in a hurry and said to herself, "Okay, how can I give my character Veronica a really shitty day? Like this: She'll get in a car wreck and she'll throw a party that gets out of control. And I'll have her cheat on her boyfriend so that relationship falls apart." About the characters, the parents were written okay, but Veronica's friend and boyfriend were just there to say to Veronica the exact thing that she needed to help her move along in the story. So cliche. I could talk about all the other cliches, like when the mom moves into a cheap apartment that smells like curry, and the wholesome, charming, highschool homecoming queen who is different now—she is goth. It was so predictable: the cute guy in the dorm whom she hooks up with, and everything else.
What I liked most about this book was its completeness. Sometimes authors find the laziest possible way to define a problem and then solve it--especially in modern fiction--but Moriarty really took her time developing the story and the characters. She made me care about the people in the book. She gave their lives depth and meaning, so it was easy to relate to them.
I was especially impressed that Moriarty was able to create a believable relationship between a mother and her two daughters. Each character was unique--and uniquely flawed. But because their flaws were revealed through complex issues and dilemmas within the story, I found myself empathizing with all three.
There were a couple of questionable parts in the story when I couldn't quite believe that a certain character would respond the way she did, but, overall, I very much enjoyed reading this book.
Veronica Von Holten is a pre-med student at the University of Kansas and is struggling through an already tough semester when she gets the news that her parents are divorcing. The stress leads her to a couple of bad decisions over a long weekend, which are only the beginning of an upheaval that will change her life: Her plans, her goals, her relationship with each of her parents. When her mother shows up at her dorm room, homeless, elderly dog in tow, Veronica is pushed nearly to the breaking point. Her sister lives in California, so for the first time it’s up to Veronica to deal responsibly with other people’s problems. Moriarty creates multifaceted, realistic characters, presenting them sympathetically without glossing over their flaws. Neither parent is blameless in the split; each is wounded and at times selfish, but decent enough to not make things worse than they have to be. The plot of “While I’m Falling” is less ripped-from-the-headlines than the ones in Moriarty’s previous novels — not that a timely plot is bad — but in this book a closer focus on the characters allows a deeper look into their fears and hopes without the distraction of a larger issue. There’s a little of that near the end, but the book is about family: what the people in it owe each other, and what they should be able to offer each other freely. Moriarty’s dialogue rings true and her exploration of emotions, particularly Veronica’s, strikes the right tone for empathy. Without dropping into melodrama, “While I’m Falling” puts faces on a family breakdown, allowing us to observe as everyone gets up, dusts off, and starts to figure out where to go next.
SOOO disappointing. I read Laura Moriarty's first novel, Center of Everything, and just loved it to pieces. But both her follow ups have been meager at best and this last one is just not good. The pacing is unbelievably slow (despite a good start) and the actions of everyone involved seem more forced than realistic and certainly repetitive. Three hundred pages is essentially dedicated to a one week time period where a college age girl gets in trouble with her one-time house sitting job, struggles with her parents, her grades, and her way in life. I'm a decade past college so it's really frustrating to read. Just not enough character growth, really. She had a party and has to clean up? And it's a challenge? BOO.
Then there's the dog. The newly divorced mother considers putting the elderly, but still in decent shape, dog down because she's moving into an apartment that does not accept dogs. You lost me there and never got me back. Considering a dog over an apartment? Seriously? I know how terribly difficult it is to rent with dogs - I have two large breeds - but I have never considered for even a second putting the dogs down or giving them away for a place to live. Ridiculous. Unsympathetic. And a reader who will never go back to this author.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I really loved the writing style, the characters and most of all, of course, the story itself. It portrays the relationship of a family in the middle of a divorce and perspectives and thoughts of each member and generation. Each of the characters’ stories were on one or another level relateable and really helped me immerse myself in the story. This is a heartbreaking story, and although I would not have picked this up if it was not a recommendation, I can only recommend it wholeheartedly myself now.
I am a huge fan of Laura Moriarty, and I was not a bit disappointed with her latest offering, "While I'm Falling." It is wonderfully relationship driven and fast moving. Ms. Moriarity creates very real, multifaceted characters and has us caring about them before we know it. I sometimes gauge a book by how many times it makese me cry, and this one made me cry twice which is a very good sign. Lol
This is the story of pre-med student Veronica Von Holten and her family. Veronica is struggling and wondering if pre-med is really for her when she learns that her parents are divorcing because her always dependable mother has allegedly had an affair. While dealing with her parents' break up and problems in school, she makes a series of poor decisions over a weekend. It is at this time that her mother shows up at her dorm with the dying family dog and no place to go. Veronica is pushed to the brink. While the story is told from Veronica's perspective, we are also treated to some perspection from her mother which was perfect and necessary.
I really loved this book and as a bookseller will definitely be recommending it to my customers.
Veronica's father finds Roofer Guy in the marital bed, and decides to divorce her mother. As a result, Mom starts on one of those downward slides where everything just snowballs into A Bad Life. Veronica, in college as a pre-med, is heading in the same direction. Not doing her job as an RA well, not getting Organic Chemistry, just Not Doing in general.
The problem is that I just didn't feel sorry for her. I know what depression can be like, and yet there was a part of me that wanted to say "Grab hold of yourself - snap out of this!". It just felt that Veronica didn't want her life to be better, that she just didn't care. Since she wasn't sympathetically drawn as a character, I just didn't care. Which is a pity, because my first thoughts were that this book might make a nice progression up from Sarah Dessen's oeuvre for my students.
I discovered this author by chance while searching to see if the 'other Moriarty' might have a new title out. I was pleasantly surprised to discover a new friend I can read when I'm taking a break from my usual mystery and suspense genre. 'While I'm Falling' is a realistic look at the end of a marriage a d the effect it has on each member of a family. It's not depressing, but it is realistic. People make some dumb decisions, some decisions that seem reasonable at the time but set in motion events that have (or almost have) bad consequences. It,s the story of a daughter coming to know her mother as a person, coming to grips with her own needs rather than just fulfilling those of others, and coming to learn that her actions affect other lives for good or bad. I'll definitely be reading more by this author.
Added 5/26/15. I decided to read this book after I enjoyed this author's other novel, The Chaperone.
6/15/15 - I forgot to update this review after reading this book. The plot concerns a divorced mother who is having financial difficulties. She turns to her daughters for help. The book held my attention for the most part, but I didn't find it pleasurable. I don't enjoy reading about people's depressing troubles... but I suppose that's the stuff of novels.
I don't like the title of the book because it's too vague.
I had to read this book in one evening because I had miscalculated when it was due back at the library, and luckily it was a quick read. A nicely done mother/daughter story, enjoyable if not memorable. But what's up with this woman's book covers? This one: one half of a girl with her red hair blowing in wind, snow and dead grass behind her. "The Center of Everything": one half of the face of a pretty redhead lying on grass. "The Rest of Her Life": the back of the head of a russet-haired girl staring at grass. If you didn't know better, you'd think she's writing a series of books about a redhead with a severe facial deformity and an obsession with fescue.
We heard this author read at Watermark Books in Wichita a couple weeks ago and the selection she was reading was so exciting that the lady across from me was actually biting her nails! But really it's just a sweet family story about changes. With a very strong message that all women should work, no matter what their circumstances. The author mentioned that she'd read the book "The Feminine Mistake" that was all about that. Good, good author! Have enjoyed all 3 of her books and heard her speak twice. And she's from Kansas -- a creative writing professor at KU.
The plot offers no surprises and the story itself is pretty ordinary but what makes Moriarty's novel a worthwhile read is her ability to make her characters come to life. This has been true with all three of her books, I get the characters, understand the motivations that drive them and thus, the course of their actions.
When everything in your life seems to be going the opposite of how you want it to be, you just have to let go and understand that the universe is trying to tell you to make some changes.
This book brings back memories from college, some good but others not so good. Veronica is a dorm resident adviser, but she isn't going a good job. She's distracted by her very nice boyfriend but is failing organic chemistry. I could relate: I didn't fail but it consumed two quarters and was the hardest class I ever took. The bigger issue is her parent's divorce. The book was depressing at times. I wanted to say to Veronica and her mother, "Don't do that, it's a bad decision." Veronica, especially, makes a series of decisions that just get her deeper and deeper in trouble. Her mother deals with her own difficulties with Veronica's help and then she in turn assists her daughter. The family dynamics are portrayed well but some of the other plot points seem a bit too obvious.
I am such a naturally positive person and this book was a real struggle for me, so many storylines of negative events, characters making bad choices. It just never came together and I kept hoping things would get better. This was my first book by this author and I'm reluctant to try another. #strugglebus
I accidentally picked this book thinking it was a Lianne Moriarty book. I realized i was mistaken but still wanted to read it. I thought it was well written but my goodness it was a bit depressing. Some people have no luck and continue to make poor choices. Goodness prevails
Extremely well written! I had trouble putting it down. A local author and she has a KU MSW ,like me, made it more compelling to read! She is very gifted writer that makes you “feel” the challenges in the lives of the characters. I usually don’t read this genre, but found it very readable and enjoyable.
I like Laura Moriarty. I really do. She's really, really nice and her first novel, The Center of Everything, was quite good. I had a lot of hopes for her. I scooped her second novel up right away. Huge disappointment. And when the third, While I'm Falling came out, I was slow to buy it and even slower to get around reading it. Word came out that a fourth novel was on its way, so I thought I better get to it.
Another huge disappointment.
Did I mention I really like Laura Moriarty? 'Cause I do. It's just that The Center of Everything was good; and The Rest of Her Life (TRoHL) and While I'm Falling (WIF) were not.
Now, this review is about WIF, but it easily applies to TRoHL. And since I didn't write a review for the earlier book, this counts as a review for both. The problem with both books is that there isn't much of a story. There's potential for a story, but it just never develops into anything that should be longer than thirty pages. Another problem with both novels is that they're filled with unlikable characters. I don't mean characters that are bad human beings, because those can be fun; rather, characters that are incessantly whiny in an annoying way and bring nothing of quality to the world of literature. Imagine a book about Bella Swan having a bad week: That's the premise of WIF. WTF?
Despite having been so disappointed two times in a row, I am still a fan of Moriarty's. I think she definitely has potential and I can't help but blame some outside force for the decline. I will be reading The Chaperone when it is released in June. Something tells me this will be the one that brings her out of her slump.
A well-written account of a family in turmoil. Life is a neatly wrapped package for the Butterfield family. A happy marriage with two daughters, one a highly successful lawyer and the younger pre-med. The future looks settled for the couple and their children in their well-ordered world, until the father returns from a business trip and finds a strange man in his bed. His world shattered, he divorces his wife, and the family slowly unravels, the skeins of their lives pooling into a giant puddle of despair. Like a game of dominos, each member of the family's life is knocked out of whack, so that their plans dissolve, leaving them rudderless. This was a great depiction of the death throes of a family, the struggle to come to grips with their imploding world. The road twists, skewing judgement, allowing the accepted rules of behavior to warp. Each one is faced with their derailment, and Moriarty does a fantastic job by giving each character a different voice. Veronica is left to sink, her parents wrapped up in their own disillusionment and pain, selfishly letting her flounder until common sense resurfaces. Both Veronica and her sister learn to see their parents as real people who's lives have taken a surprising turn. Astonishingly poignant, frighteningly real, this is a story about coping and learning to accept one's limitations by opening their eyes and being honest with themselves.
Not really sure what drew me to this book, I think I just like reading about people who are having breakdowns and their life is just going downhill to make me realize that my life isn't that bad. How sad that I need a novel to remind me of that. It's just a reminder that no matter how bad things look, they can always be worse. This book is about Veronica who is a pre-med student in college and is having a bit of a breakdown. And things only get worse when her parents get a divorce and her mother ends up homeless with the half dead family dog. Veronica and her mother kind of help each other realize that no matter how crappy things might be, if you work at it, it will turn around for the best. I liked the mom, and felt sorry for her as well, because she's almost 50 and has to crash in her daughter's dorm room because she can't get into a new apartment for awhile. How awful for a parent to have to admit that to their child. What I liked was how she managed to stay upbeat. Or at least act like she was. If I was her, I would have lost my mind. Maybe she did and was just stressed out to the point where you can't feel the stress anymore. Like you are high or something. Anyway, I liked it. The chapters are bit to long, and even though it's pretty short, it does kind of feel like it goes on forever. But other than that, it was decent.
First let me start by saying, the writing is flawless, nothing to say about it at all, if it seems I'm stalling your correct in your assumptions. I'm just going to say it then, I have never read a more depressing novel ever. I hated the lawyer husband from the start, but yet thought at one point he seemed at least better able to deal with the girls, I was mistaken, however All the characters were held in contempt equally. This was a very sobering look at a family coming apart in a very desperate manner. Hated how I kept trying to hope for a light in these peoples misery, and wishing the ex husband a Malay because I don't feel he of all people deserves to be happy, sorry I know that sound vindictive so be it, I feel do to his neglect of his wife, she lost herself in raising kids and taking care of both elderly parents where he did not, and then for him to have lost any interest in his wife was even more of a betrayal than any affair could have been. We all strive for human connection to another and to be respected, loved and cherished. This for me was an emotionally sad and depressing book, read at your own risk of emotional downward spiral into sad.....
This book is about a college girl named Veronica who is faced with some hard times. Her father came home from a business trip and found another man in his home, and needless to say her parents ended up divorcing. Veronica has trouble with the divorce because it is like all she has ever known is slowly disappearing. She now has choices to face such as where she is going to spend holidays and who is she going to go visit first next time. Veronica's mother is very heartbroken by everything and at one point she ends up almost broke and homeless. Veronica's sister is married and living in California, so she is having to deal with all of this on her own. She feels very alone and she also has a lot of resentment towards her mother at first. She is a RA in her dorm and is struggling to pass some of her classes. I enjoyed reading about Veronica and her family. This is a book that starts off very quickly from the first chapter which I enjoyed, but like most books it has some slow parts. All in all, I do recommend this book.
This author first came to my attention when her book The Chaperone received fanfare upon its publication, but apparently she's been writing for a while now. A friend of mine is friends with the author personally, and she lives in and sets some of her books in the Kansas City/Lawrence area, so there's that extra sense of connection. This is a good chick lit kind of book about the various ways life can fall apart for a family going through a divorce. The protagonist, Veronica, is trying to hold it together in college, and her mother is simply trying to hold it together, period. Going through a period in my life where difficulties have snowballed to present even more calamity collectively than they would have individually, I could relate to this book. It all works out in the end for this family, and it probably will for mine as well.