I was really hopeful when I bought this book, based on its synopsis, and I'm glad it didn't disappoint.
There were a lot of upsides. It has a LOT of gemstone information (being a gem geek like Andie, the main character, I was particularly looking forward to that part, although I don't have any shiny certificates proving I'm an educated expert, sadly), and I can tell the author's done her research. (Most notably, the fact that red spinel is often confused for rubies, and why.) The main character lives in Louisville, Kentucky, which is relatively close to my neck of the woods. And Andie is smart, sassy, and very funny - my favorite kind of heroine.
There were a couple of leaps in logic in the book, but for the most part it had a cohesive and easy to follow plot. Though I did guess who the bad guy was before the big reveal, the author was very clever about the little clues she left and I really had to do a lot of work to figure it out early. The characters are very engaging, the plot interesting, and like I said, the author did a lot of research about gemstones and behind-the-scenes television work to make everything very realistic. I also like how she included Max, who's a good character to bring up questions about gemstones for those readers who aren't as interested in that aspect, or perhaps just don't know that much. (I especially like how she chose a gem as well-known as garnet, which is typically thought of as red, to play this out. I was smiling and cheering when Andie told Max and the S.T.U.D. viewers it comes in other colors as well, including orange, purple, and green. I forgive her for saying it doesn't come in blue, since it was published before a deposit of blue garnet was discovered.)
Each of her locales, from New York, to Louisville, to Myanmar, were very well described. It wasn't hard at all for me to see, smell, hear, taste, and feel everything right along with the characters. I especially liked it when they went to the mine in Myanmar, and Andie was thinking about how antiquated and hard the mining practices are there and other places, too. Sometimes it's easy to forget all the hard work people do to get these beautiful treasures out of the ground, and how little they make to feed their families doing it. I like how she brought this up delicately, being honest about it without tipping it too far either direction.
Despite all the wins in this book (and there were a TON), I did feel the book missed in a few aspects. Being from the south, and close to the area where this takes place, I'm familiar with the area and the local dialect. I really do believe she made the characters too Southern - she went a little overboard sometimes with the accent and verbiage, particularly for this part of the country. The other big no-no was when she referred to Andie's most helpful jeweler's tool as a jeweler's "loop," when the correct term is jeweler's "loupe." I was severely disappointed when I read that repeatedly, especially since she'd done so well with the gemstone aspect of the book. Most readers might not notice it, but for those of us who are interested in gems and jewelry, it's definitely a wince-factor. My only other complaint is that she misidentified Alexandrite - the rarest gem in the world, also a color-change gem - as a member of the garnet family. It is, in fact, a member of the chrysoberyl family. Also, Burmese rubies cannot be exported into America at this time (and at the time of publishing), though Burmese spinel can. But since Burmese rubies are truly gorgeous, I can understand why she ignored this import rule for the sake of the book.
Altogether, this was a really interesting and well-written book, despite the overdone Southern-isms and the "loop" instead of "loupe" faux-pas. I would recommend this book to others, especially those who like a smart mystery, exotic locales (they go to Myanmar!), and fun, engaging characters. I look forward to reading book 2!