Just stumbled on this review I wrote for my online homeschooling column back in 2015 so I thought I'd post it here:
I was excited to get a review copy of Diane Flynn Keith's newly revised Carschooling book. I've been a subscriber to Keith's Clickschooling email service for several years and have always been a fan of her site and her many services for homeschoolers. I even got a chance to see her speak at this year's Minnesota Homeschool Alliance conference, and greatly enjoyed her speech.
That said, I was initially disappointed when I opened the book for the first time. Why? I brought it along on a 30 minute car trip to the grocery store, planning to just open it up to a random page and do fun, educational activities with my kids.
It turns out that this is not really a "open the book to a random page" kind of book. For one thing, each chapter actually lists supplies needed. Supplies?! For the car? Well, yes. Some of the activities require simple tools and materials. Also, you could say there was just too much of a good thing and I easily got overwhelmed. I found myself scanning entry after entry and quickly developed carsickness.
No, this is not just a book of simple activities to play on the road. We already have those in our repertoire, after all. I think most homeschoolers are plenty used to playing ABC games of lists of animals, having impromptu spelling bees and answering made up word problems on the way to the store.
Don't get me wrong -- there are plenty of activities in that vein. They're just updated, more creative versions of those games we're used to in many cases. There are also plenty of activities that don't require any additional materials or preparation. Some of the best ones do require a little bit of preparation, though. The good news is they're worth the trouble!
Carschooling really is like a full curriculum for the car. There are science experiments, physical education activities, math games, geography challenges, foreign language exercises and lots more. Some of the ideas are so creative I couldn't wait to do them with my kids, and the supplies needed (if any) are generally simple and easy to pack for rides.
Here are some examples of activities in the book.
Stretch a balloon over an empty cup as you go up a mountain (you'll need to go up 1000 feet or more) and watch what happens to the balloon. The explanation gives information about how the balloon is like our ears and what's happening.
Sing the "Bottles of Juice on the Wall" song and use math. For instance, "5 bottles of juice on the wall, 5 bottles of juice, you go to the store and buy 3 more, how many bottles of juice on the wall?".
Make crayon rubbings of historical markers you visit.
Do the Skeleton Hokey Pokey. Kids learn the names for their bones and have fun! Here's a sample verse: "You put your right tarsals in, you put your right tarsals out... You do the hokey pokey and give high-fives all around, that's what it's all about."
I found that the perfect way for me to use the book was to browse it at home and put check marks next to entries that looked like fun (you could just as easily use post-it notes for books). I bookmarked the pages of the activities I wanted to do soon with my kids (there were many!) and put the supplies needed in a tupperware box. Just as it's often easier on homeschool moms to loosely plan the day at home than to just wing it, it makes life much easier to have some carschooling ideas already selected before you begin your drive.
It turns out that the book is not what I expected, but much better. The games and activities are arranged by subject and can be tailored to any age. There is additional information on everything from keeping the car organized to avoiding carsickness.
I heartily recommend it to homeschool families with kids of all ages.
We're all really excited to do more of the activities from the book. Now we just need to find a mountain in Minnesota for that balloon experiment...