After finishing the Iliad, I wanted to jump right into the Odyssey. I had read it back in college, but that was now 15 (yipe!) years ago and I felt that I would approach it with more appreciation of the background, both in terms of the characters I'd become more familiar with in the Iliad and in terms of my increased understanding of ancient Greek culture.
One thing I'd forgotten was how long it takes for Odysseus to appear--not until Book 5, about one-sixth of the way into the epic. I suspect I got a lot more out of the first four books this time around, since they deal with Odysseus's son, Telemachus, visiting other Greek heroes looking for information on his dad. He first travels to Pylos to see Nestor. I may have recognized the name Nestor when I was reading in college, but only after reading the Iliad did I get to know this character, certainly one of Homer's favorites. He (Nestor) is the oldest of the warriors at Troy, and frequently goes into long speeches about how things were done "back in the day." He is both full of sage advice and a windbag, somewhat like Polonius in Shakespeare's Hamlet. After Nestor, Telemachus journeys to Sparta to see Menelaus. I was certainly more familiar with his backstory 15 years ago, but this time I thrilled at the tale of his adventures in Egypt. Could these be distant echoes of the early Greek settlers in the Nile delta, who began trading with the Egyptians and learning of their ancient culture?
When we do catch up with Odysseus, he is pining for home while stuck on the Ogygia, the isle of Calypso. Eventually he does make his way back to civilization with the Phaeacians. Much of the rest of this first half of the poem is taken up with Odysseus's narration of his own adventures to the court of the Phaeacians. This is where most of the familiar elements of the Odyssey take place, such as the Cyclops, Circe, and the Scylla and Charybdis. The high point to me is the journey to the land of the dead in Book 11. Here Odysseus meets famous figures from the past, including Teiresias (the prophet in the Oedipus tales), Heracles, and his now-deceased former comrades like Achilles and Ajax. He also meets his mother in a very poignant scene. It gives me goosebumps thinking back on some of these encounters. For instance, when Odysseus praises Achilles for having become a sort of leader in Hades's realm, he responds (paraphrasing), "I'd rather be a lowly thrall on earth than a king among the dead." The concept of these scenes is so good, and the execution is perfect. They fully justify the modern use of the term "epic."
A word about this edition. W.B. Stanford's notes and commentary are excellent. He gives exactly the sort of information I am curious about. For instance, he might note Sanskrit or Old Irish cognates of rare words, or summarize what is known about (e.g.) ancient Greek houses. The notes in my edition of the Iliad were sufficient, but Stanford's are so much better.
On to the second half of the poem!