Every life requires a spiritual foundation. "Grandfather, you left this..." Julio lifted the leather-bound journal and stepped toward the old man. "It is yours now," said Antonio, with a gleam in his eye. "I've lived my life according to the twelve principles recorded in it. And if you will apply its principles as I did, your success will be greater than you could ever imagine." Be a minister in the marketplace. Terry Felber has written a parable that will transform your life and your business. Many years ago, this ago book helped Dave Ramsey rediscover the marketplace as a mission field--and merchants as ministers. Now let it open your eyes to the opportunities for service and leadership all around you. Are you ready for a change? The Legend of the Monk and the Merchant will change the way you see yourself, your job, and your purpose. Now includes personal and small group study guide.
This modern fable teaches that businesspeople play an important role in doing God’s work by financially supporting the church. Although I agree with that, and the book makes a few other worthwhile points, I was disappointed to find that it teaches the unbiblical prosperity theology (AKA prosperity gospel, AKA health and wealth gospel). For examples, see Principle 1: “Work Hard and God Will Prosper You”, and Principle 2: “Financial Prosperity is Connected to Soul Prosperity.” With unbiblical lessons like these, I can’t recommend this book.
Although some Bible references are listed at the end of the book, many statements are made without references and without adequate explanation. I realize that it’s meant to be written as an easy-to-read story, but I found it far too shallow.
This quote from near the end of the book sums up the main point: “God has designed a special relationship between businessmen and leaders in the church. We, as businessmen, can provide the provision for the vision of the priests.”
Parts I liked or agreed with • “Your vocation is your calling. It’s the thing that you were born to do. And when you do it, it’s not really work at all.” • “When Jesus was talking to the rich young ruler, He was dealing with him specifically, not with everyone generally. Jesus knew that the young man had made an idol out of money, and He wanted the man to be free. He knew that the only way for the many to be free was to get rid of the thing that held him captive.” • “Jesus encountered other men of considerable wealth and never asked them to sell all their things. Zebedee, Zaccheus, Matthew the tax collector, the Roman officer, and Nicodemus, just to name a few.” • “God desires for your soul to prosper above all else.” • Sometimes difficulty means God is closing a door, but more often it means He’s testing our character or preparing us for something.
Parts I disliked or disagreed with • Referring to kingship in Rev. 1:6, the book says, “A king is like a man who runs a business.” I believe the Bible refers to believers as “kings” to show that we rule and will rule with Christ in His kingdom (Luke 22:29, Jam. 2:5, Rev. 5:10, Rev. 22:5, Rev. 2:26-27). • “Principle 1: Work Hard and God Will Prosper You.” • The book applies Deut 28:1, quoted as “God promises wealth to those people that love Him and keep His commands,” which in context is said to Israel, to all Christians. • The book applies 3 John 2, a letter to Gaius which begins, “Beloved, I wish you prosperity and good health, even as your soul prospers,” to all Christians. • “Unless He specifically calls you to a vow of poverty, as your relationship with Him grows, then He wants you to prosper financially.”
• The book says that Psalm 37:4, “Delight yourself in the Lord, and He will give you the desires of your heart,” “means that if you are delighting him Him, seeking after Him and honoring Him, His desires will more naturally become your desires.” The book also references Matt. 6:33. • “Principle 2: Financial Prosperity is Connected to Soul Prosperity.” • The book says that Matt. 5:5 means, “He [God] wants us to be meek toward Him, not toward men.” • The book says that Rom. 13:8, “Owe no man but for your love,” means, “you are never to owe money. If you want to buy something, but don’t have the money for it, you don’t buy it.”
Part I’m unsure about The “eye of the needle” referred to small doors in Jerusalem’s gates that required a camel to crawl through on its knees. So, it wasn’t impossible for a camel to go through, but it was difficult.
Notes on Prosperity Theology My wife was reading Money Possessions and Eternity by Randy Alcorn at the same time I was reading this book, and she recommended it. I read the chapter on Prosperity Theology and made these notes:
• If God wants all His people to be materially successful, why weren’t Jesus, the disciples, Paul, and others? • In the New Testament, the Greek word “ploutos” is used 11 times to refer to spiritual, not material, riches: Rom. 11:33, Eph. 1:18, Phil. 4:19, Col. 1:27. • God doesn’t promise material success to His people. See Job 1:8, Job 42:7, Luke 16:19-31, Luke 6:20-25, 2 Tim. 3:12, 1 Pet. 5:9, John 15:18-20, Matt. 10:16-20, John 16:33, Luke 14:33, Phil. 3:7-8.
Other verses to consider: Luke 12:15 and Matt. 6:19-21.
This was an excellent business book. It is relatively short, but interesting. It should be required reading for all business majors.
I do not believe that the prosperity gospel is preached here. The points are supported by Bible verses.
It gives wise Biblical business advice. It would be helpful to anyone in business.
An added benefit to this book is the section of discussion questions at the end. This allows for discussion and ways that each person can make their own unique, life-long business plan.
Kudos to the author for making a very interesting book out of a usually dry topic.
This book carries so many valuable life lessons. It discusses money from a biblical perspective and also breaks down common misconceptions about verses taken out of context. It wasn’t the most thrilling of books, but the message is important and it told what it was supposed to. It was also super short (I read it in one sitting), so there’s no reason to not at least try reading it if you want to learn more about how God and money are connected.
In reading this book, it was very interesting I had a hard time putting it down. It lists 12 principles for successful living, that are all based on scripture. No this isn't your typical "self-help" book, this book has a very fascinating tale of a young man and his adventures. This is a book that you should read if you want to remind yourself of what is important in life and in business. I found myself imagining myself in the shoes of Julio who is the young man that is being told the story by his grandfather. I started reading this book because it was listed as a book on Dave Ramesy's library. I recommend this book to anyone that wants to learn how to succeed in both your personal and professional lives, read this book. I will keep this book in my library forever and will on occasion go back and reread it. I suggest you read it too.
This book hit me in a way that not many books can. I see why some churches keep this book on their shelves, and Dave Ramsey makes his team read it!
The Legend of the Monk and the Merchant is a book that tells a wonderful story about growth, learning, wisdom, and how it passes from one person to another. It also is a story of how the ideas of business in the eyes of religion may be a little off, and vice versa. Whether you are going into business for yourself or not, this is a great book to add to your arsenal of wisdom strengthening books, hands down.
Not sure what I expected from this book but it didn't deliver so I was pretty disappointed. A modern book of advice written in the style of Marcus Aurelius - no thanks.
A great parable about how being in the marketplace doesn't disqualify you from having a ministry. The story portion is told easily and fluidly; the study guide presents thoughtful commentary and asks some deep questions. A quick read with a lot to chew on!
Basic and good. Dave Ramsey loves this book, and I can see why. Short read, so it doesn't go very deep on the subjects of working in business, building wealth, giving, and more. There are good principles here, told in a short, somewhat entertaining fable.
Get out of debt -- and stay out of debt forever. That principle alone would solve the financial problems of just about every struggling American. But most people don't want to be humble enough to submit to such a basic principle as that.
Give 10% to the church. Would have liked to see him push for giving significantly above and beyond 10% throughout one's working years....rather than suggesting that generous giving is done in the form of end-of-life bequests.
Other reviewers have noted the book espouses the Prosperity Gospel. That may be true. But, financial prosperity (or peace) does not necessarily equal great wealth. I work as a financial planner/advisor. We have a number of clients whom few would refer to as affluent: they have never earned more than $50,000 in their lives, yet they paid off debt, gave generously, and saved aggressively. Those folks have been able to build modest wealth -- and that modest wealth is abundant wealth in relation to their lifestyle.
This was a fantastic book, I loved it. I always love material that counters the "evil rich" nonsense. I wish I had read something like this years ago.
I don't understand why schools don't make books like this required reading, yet they can't seem to get books full of death and darkness into kid's hands fast enough.
The story centers around a Catholic family, but isn't condescending toward other denominations/religions. Though the principles are mostly Christian in nature they could easily be applied to most secular ventures.
I felt like it avoided the prosperity doctrine pitfall. Nowhere in the book does it say riches are guaranteed.
Good, solid principles, but the ending was rather cliche:
"The Legend of the Monk and the Merchant was only just beginning."
*winces*
Only, only use that phrase if you're going to do an epilogue after the final chapter, otherwise the reader is going to be slightly put out that they didn't actually get to read the legend that the book so proudly proclaims to be about. The least Felber could have done was write a lengthly author's note about how to apply the principles in real life, rather than telling us that:
"Just as Antonio passed on the Twelve Keys to Successful Living, it s now your turn to share 'The Journal of a King' with others."
This is such a great book!! I love how it is told in a story. It makes it more interesting. We get to experience all the things that the characters experience and all the lessons that he learned. I would recommend taking notes when reading this book. I would try to apply the lessons learned in this book to my life. This book opened my eyes to a lot of things that I would have never thought of. If you want to create a successful habit then I would encourage you to read this book. But don't stop there!! Keep reading other books like this one!!
I've been a listener of Dave Ramsey's radio show for a long time, and this book embodies his principles in a short fable format. The fable itself was well-written and enjoyable...a grandfather passing on his knowledge of scripture and business sense on to his grandson. In the back of the book, the actual Biblical references are listed. I think these principles would apply even if one wasn't a person of faith. It's common sense advice that anyone could use and apply to his/her life. It was definitely worth reading for the hour or so it took to finish.
Felber tells a story of a wealthy merchant named Antonio who is passing on life lessons to his grandson as they walk through Renaissance period Rome., Julio. Antonio was adopted by a monk named Felip, and raised in a monastery until he was 16. When the time came to decide what he would do with is future, Felipo encouraged Antonio to spend a summer with his good friend Allesio, a very wealthy trader. Anotnio thought he would become a monk, as he loved the Lord and wanted to serve him. However, after the summer with Allesio, Antonio decides that he wants to be in the business world. As Antonio becomes one of the wealthiest traders in the world, by creating and producing a new world currency, he visits Alessio every three years to be taught a new lesson. Allesio’s lessons are centered around serving the Lord with your wealth and business. He helps Antonio overcome the guilt her feels from his wealth, and explains how the world needs Monks to support Merchants, and Merchants to support the work Monks do. These lessons come full circle when Allesio guides Antonio to fund the building of St. Peter's Basilica in Rome, the same magnificent Basilica that Antonio brings Julio to at the end of the story. Antonio learns 12 principles from his mentor Allesio, and is now passing them on to Julio. The 12 Principles are 1. Work Hard and God will prosper you, 2. Financial prosperity is often connected to soul prosperity, 3. A man must do whatever he can to provide for his family, 4. Trials develop your character preparing you for increased blessings, 5. Take responsibility for problems that are the result of your own bad decisions. Don’t displace the blame, 6. See challenges as stepping stones not as obstacles, 7. Be meek before God, but bold before men, 8. Live debt free and below your means, 9. Always keep to your budget, 10. Loaning money destroys relationships, 11. Set aside the first 10 percent to honor God, 12. Understand the power of partnership.
I have read a number of books that dealt with leadership and business principles so it was refreshing to read a book that took a different approach in addressing this popular topic. Instead of writing a book on “Twelve Principles for Successful Living” Felber employs the powerful use of story to communicate and enforce the principles he shares. While some of the twelve principles found in this book may not be new to those that are familiar with this genre, it is worth the time to be reminded of them especially considering the way they are presented in this relatively short read.
My biggest complaint is with the details of the narrative. There are a couple of places where there are out right contradictions. There are also places where details are given that seemingly have a purpose in advancing the plot but that are never revisited. While these issues do not impact the overall plot, they are a distraction. The narrative is also written very simply and though I enjoyed the story I could not help but think that I was reading a story more suited for younger readers. I also do not agree with the way Felber applies certain Bible verses to support his life principles. This is not to say that the principles themselves are wrong, but that the verses used to support them are taken out of context.
I would recommend this book based on the enjoyable narrative and the wisdom it practically communicates.
An easy book to get into. Characters are separated enough that there is no issues distinguishing between them, even with reading in short bursts. The religious aspects did not bother me as much as similar books have, and I think this was in part to how the author went about explaining the character's belief that business owners have a responsibility to the church. It did not seem as forceful as others. Given that, plus some sound ideologies and I think this is a book I will revisit shortly. However, there was nothing profound about the principles. But I will be taking note of them to try to actively apply them.
Principles:
Work Hard and God Will Prosper You
Financial Prosperity is Connected to Soul Prosperity
A Man Must Do Whatever He Can to Provide for His Family
Trials Develop Your Character, Preparing You for Increased Blessings
Take Responsibility for Problems That Are The Result of Your Own Bad Decisions. Do Not Displace the Blame
See Challenges as Stepping Stones, Not As Obstacles
Be Meek Before God, But Bold Before Men
Loaning Money Destroys Relationships
Live Debt-Free and Below Your Means
Always Keep to Your Budget
Set Aside the First 10% to Honor God
Understand the Power of Partnership
I had this at one star for the reasons stated below but after some thought, bumped it to two stars as there is some useful information in here. Working hard and not giving up being two important points. My problem with the book is how it implies that the strength of your faith is somehow a measure of how successful you will be at gaining MATERIAL wealth.
For me, this book smacked of prosperity gospel. The principle that if you work hard God will prosper you is great unless you work hard your whole life and still live in poverty -- where does that leave you? Does that mean you didn't love God enough? Or work hard enough? What if you work three jobs and 80+ hours a week and still can't get ahead? Are you a bad Christian? I can never get behind something that preaches God's favor is measured by how financially successful you are.
It's right up there with the "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" nonsense. Again, another great saying on the surface but a real problem when you consider not everyone has bootstraps with which to pull themselves up with.
Does God want you to be rich? Maybe. Does God care if you're happy and do good and share His love with the world? Definitely. If you are successful in business, that's awesome. But it does not mean your faith is stronger because you're better at making money than someone else.
This book is a fictional story through which entrepreneur Terry Felber shares twelve biblical principles for financial success. Set in the Renaissance age, young Julio visits Rome with his grandfather, Antonio. During their trip, Antonio shares with Julio some very important life lessons he was taught by a close mentor.
Antonio tells his grandson his own life story; victories, shortcomings and all. Woven through are twelve keys to success. They are all biblical and simple, and each time he introduces a new one, Antonio explains how he applied it and what difference it made. Although my life bears little resemblance to that of a 1500s Italian merchant, I felt I could easily follow Antonio’s example.
Antonio’s story is interesting, full of twists, new challenges and triumphant achievements. As he navigates the sometimes unpredictable events of his life, Antonio’s mentor, Alessio, encourages and counsels him. By failing and trying again, Antonio learns how to apply the twelve practical principles that you and I can also use.
Antonio talks to Julio about a variety of financial topics, such as debt, tithing, diligence, budgeting and partnerships. All these are as relevant today as they were in the 16th century, and a fictional story is an interesting and enjoyable way to teach. I really liked this lovely little story and would definitely recommend it.
Several years ago a friend shared her copy of this book with me. This fall I was trying to remember what it was called so that I could read it aloud to my kids. Then I signed up for Financial Coach Master Training and this was one of the special bonus gifts I received! It felt like Christmas came at the beginning of December. So we read through it on a weekly basis as part of school.
Terry Felber presents 12 keys to successful living wrapped in a fun narrative set in Italy just after the great renovations of St. Peter’s Basilica. A grandfather takes his grandson to this important site and tells him the story of his life. He shares the wisdom of both his adopted father, a monk, and Alessio, his mentor. This story shows how to be minister in the marketplace and power of partnership between merchants and pastors. It is such a beautiful picture of the necessity, dignity and worth of every calling of life work that God puts on us. Plus packed into this story are important financial principles like budgeting, tithing, taking responsibility, and being debt free.
Choose this book for a memorable story and a quick read that you can enjoy with your whole family.
I wasn't too taken with this one. The principles that are taught, for the most part, are solid and useful in life. The issues I have with this title is that the author didn't make me feel I was in Rome or Venice which is where the stories of Alessio and Antonio are told.
Alessio was a wise character and he was my favorite, but I couldn't feel that connection to any of the characters very much. There were times where the writing would change and I can see the author trying to push their theological perspective on the reader. For example, tithing 10% because the farmer has to sow to read which is a common word of faith teaching. Sure, tithing is fine, but don't start with the whole "sow and you will reap a harvest" nonsense because that's not biblical. God asks us to give and we will receive, but He isn't saying "give Me money and I will give you more money".
I would have liked the book to be more biblical and less fictional. The situations that are given often aren't realistic and wouldn't work in real life. I wanted a more biblically sound, practical book that would tackle real problems not made-up ones. Sorry, but this one is going to Goodwill. Skip this one.
I ordered it in a pack from Dave Ramsey. It was an easy quick read but brought up several new points about religion and business that I had never thought of.
1) Work Hard and God will Prosper You - DO something with your good idea 2) Financial prosperity is often connected to Soul Prosperity 3) A man must do whatsoever he can to provide for his family 4) Trials Develop your character preparig you for increased blessing 5) Take responsibility for problems that are that the results of you own bad decisions. 6) See challenges as stepping stones , not as obstacles 7) Be meek before God but Bold before Men 8) live Debt Free and Below your Means 9) Always keep to your budget 10) loaning Money Destroys Relationships 11)Set Aside the 1st 10% to Honor God 12) Understand the Power of Partnership - Priest us the $ and resources of Kings in order to further the kingdom of God - IN the book he builds a cathedral. In life, we see tithing $ to build temples and such. Rev 1:6- Kings vs Priests
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The story surrounding the points is really fluff, doesn’t connect very well (or at all usually) to the points, and is just meant to impress you by describing wealth, exotic locations, and sensational sounding stories just because they have a pirate or whatever in them, but in reality they are very poor stories, just cheap tricks here, move along.
As for the twelve points delivered, I didn’t disagree with any of them, but on only a couple of them does the author have anything interesting to say! He just says “the Bible says such and so, so you know, that’s the way it is.” And moves on.
There’s also no sense of even a good system of organizing his talking points into a system or order that makes sense or anything. I mean really, this isn’t a BOOK. This is just some individual guy’s principles that he has probably personally found helpful for being successful in his life, and he’s conflated that with what a good book is.
Really quick fable that includes scriptures and examples of how merchants and monks are both needed to build the kingdom of God. Each has a role to play, and historical misconceptions and some scriptural interpretations have muddied the waters. This helps clear up the view that money in and of itself is not evil, it is what a person desires and does with his/her money that is the determining factor. Does the money become an idol or a tool? Does the heart become generous or greedy? The Lord gives us each a stewardship and expects us to be good stewards over what he has given us, multiplying our talents and helping our neighbors, whether that be through running a business and employing others, sharing knowledge through teaching, or ministering.
Interesting! I have recently realized that I have de-valued the marketplace and have seen the life of the “monk” as holier and more pleasing to God than the life of the “merchant.” I’m still processing that and trying to figure out how to best understand and how to view wealth, and this book was helpful in that journey. I may also need to re-read Keller’s “Every Good Endeavor.”
I’m not sure I agree with everything in here. There were some Scripture interpretations that make me a little nervous, but I’m trying to be open-handed and curious. Going to continue to pray through my relationship to money and wealth. Lord, help me!
This is a short book of rules to live by for financial success while still honoring God. This is very much in the pattern of the Og Mandino books; Riches Man in Babylon; and Charles Sheldon's Books. This is told as the story of a grandfather sharing with his grandson the experiences he had in building his merchant success while still honoring the teachings and values of his adopted father's (who is a monk).
If you were new to these concepts, it would be very valuable, but I have read over a dozen very similar books with similar concepts to share.
A very easy read, got it done in about two hours. The narration is wonderful and gives insight on principles that help you grow yourself before anything else. You grow, and your ministry and business follow. It also helps reconcile the age-old question of keeping ministry separate from the marketplace, as they are in fact partners aimed at a same goal. My mentors recommended this book to me and I’m very grateful. I already feel a paradigm shift with my thinking and focus.
Not particularly engaging, this book would work better as straight advice. Weaving it into the plot line, Julio often values the advice lines because of how rich his grandpa Antonio has become, but Antonio is fake and his wealth is fake. The plot line of an advice book should build the logic theory. Beyond that, some of the principles felt off... some good takeaways: Work hard, take responsibility, support ministries, and never give up.
Fantastic little book. Great that it is under 200 pages for a business book. No need to belabor the point. Clear, simple, straightforward writing but it makes you think quite a bit. For one thing I did not know about Venetian trade beads, pretty cool concept. Book helps answer the question of how do you do God's work while engaged in a flawed world that requires business and profit to thrive. Very good. Read it to find out.
A fine book for what it is. Some good principles for a Christian businessperson, although I disagree with some of the opinions regarding scripture (felt like there were no genuine rebuttals to commonly held beliefs surrounding hoarding wealth besides ‘that’s just not a good reading of the Bible’). The framing device of the book within the book was interesting. A little on the nose in the manner that the lessons arise. A quick read.