As a young comic reader, I loved rifling through my collection, pulling out two or three years worth of issues and then sitting down to read them all on a lazy Saturday afternoon. As an adult with responsibilities, it took me much longer to read ESSENTIAL DOCTOR STRANGE, VOLUME 3 but shades of that childlike experience nonetheless remained. A lot can change in just a few years, and following a character over that time frame still proves a fascinating and even somewhat intoxicating journey.
ESSENTIAL DOCTOR STRANGE Volume 3 took me on such a journey. Collecting the first twenty-nine issues of the second DOCTOR STRANGE series, along with DOCTOR STRANGE ANNUAL #1, the material spans four years (1974-1978) and three Presidential administrations (the end of Nixon's, all of Ford's and part of Carter's.). Throughout that time, "Doc" (as we fans affectionately call the title character) never ceases his battles against the mystic forces of evil, but the people who draw his adventures and put words in his mouth continue to come and go, with each bringing his or her own spin to the series.
Steve Englehart, a "hot" comic writer in his day, pens the first eighteen issues, and most would likely agree that these are the highlight of the collection. Englehart brings us a Doctor Strange who is both more self-assured and more powerful, and he also tackles such "weighty" themes as the natures of death, reality and religion. The first five issues, which are perhaps the "deepest" philosophically, are jointly plotted by Englehart and artist Frank Brunner. Afterwards, Brunner departs, and Englehart plots and writes solo, with Gene Colan handling the art chores. While the stories with Colan may be somewhat less "heady," they still have their philosophical moments, and they also feature some wonderful consolidation and expanding of the Dr. Strange mythos, as Doc faces Dormammu, Umar, Nightmare, Eternity and even Satan himself (Well, you have to admit that the Devil would seem a natural foe for Dr. Strange.)! Brunner's art is somewhat more realistic and lush, whereas Colan's is moodier, wonkier (in a GOOD way, I'd argue) and more atmospheric. Naturally, each has his fans and detractors (I'm a Colan man myself.), but they're both fan favorites for a reason and both did some wonderful work here (Different inkers vary the results somewhat, but then, variety is the spice of life.).
While most of Englehart's run is here, the first few issues (originally published as MARVEL PREMIERE #s 9-14) are actually reprinted in the previous volume. I believe that the whole run has been reprinted elsewhere, and selective fans wishing to avoid inferior runs might want to seek out alternate collections. The ESSENTIAL volumes, again, have the advantage of showing complete change to a title over time, and when you read them, you really do have to take the good with bad.
This, of course, is my way of saying that the book's post-Englehart tales vary greatly in quality. Sadly, Colan left with Englehart (He would return to the series at a later time.), and then, we find a revolving door of writers and artists, some better than others. Marv Wolfman immediately succeeds Englehart as writer, and for whatever reason, he seems determined to undo many of Englehart's changes. Sadly, he often seems more concerned with THAT than writing a good story, and his issues are arguably the weakest in the volume. Fortunately, he doesn't write that many, and to my surprise, Jim Starlin manages to rescue (in my mind, anyway) Wolfman's story by expanding it into a much trippier and more epic tale. Finally, Roger Stern comes aboard to give us a more human Dr. Strange, with the able Tom Sutton providing the art. I should probably also note that DOCTOR STRANGE ANNUAL #1, with some elegant art and a fairy tale plot by P. Craig Russell, also represents a highlight of this collection.
As with other ESSENTIAL collections ( no longer in print, sadly), this volume presents the stories in black and white, on cheap paper, at a bargain cover price. I'm okay with this, and this format is obviously for people who want to READ the stories and don't care if they look pretty on a shelf. Interestingly, the absence of color provides different results. For an artist like Gene Colan, who specializes in mood and shadow, it's sometimes arguably an advantage. On the other hand, there are artists like P. Craig Russell, whose work, I think, really begs for lavish color. Again, you take the good with the bad. For me, personally, I just loved feeling like a little kid again, sitting down to a big stack of comics.