So many emotions in this review. . .
For starters, I am a Christian. So, the overall message of Christianity in this book is pretty good. . . the death of Hugh, in which he begs his parents to convert to Christianity, in order to be with him again, is actually very touching. . . although, he seems to be able to talk pretty clearly, and act energetically for someone who's supposed to be dying of a wasting disease, but then, I've never died, so I don't know much about it.
On the other hand, Christianity seems like a pretty loose thing in here. No one speaks of baptism (the most common form of conversion in those days) or even of praying a prayer. It appears that the author was of the opinion that all you had to do was say, "I'm a Christian now", and you were good to go.
But the "romance" in this book is what truly turns my stomach, and I'm shocked that no one mentioned this in any of the other reviews. When Guy and Fleda meet, he is already a grown man, and she is a little girl, of, I think, about six years old. He's introverted, and dislikes the company of most of his friends and other adults, but becomes obsessed with this little girl, and delights in taking her off by himself. He likes touching her, mostly stroking her hair, but they also seem to develop a sort of code language, and enjoy discussing things that "No one else would understand."
The little girl is also an introvert, and suffers from terrible migraines, usually brought on by her need to take care of everyone else. Her aunt, uncle, and cousins, while insisting that they think the world of her, expect her to cook, clean, mend, sew, garden, and, eventually, run the entire farm by herself. One of her cousins (Hugh) also works himself into an early grave, while his sister marries some creep, his brother is a dandy in the army, and his parents are lazy nouveaux poor. His mother sits around and cries all of the time, and his father is a total idiot, spending money he doesn't have, and even other people's money, as well.
I can strongly identify with Fleda, as I tend to overdo and give myself a sick headache, but she is clearly being exploited by narcissists.
Guy Carleton returns to America, and lets his mother know upfront that he intends to find the little girl, and marry her. She is now a teenager. They meet up, and slip into their old code language and habits, and, thrilled to see that his grooming has been successful, he begins intense pursuit. In the meantime, a more obviously creepy man, who Fleda has distrusted since childhood over his abuse of a dog, decides to use the fact that her uncle used his father's name on a check as means of blackmailing her into marrying him, becomes the "villain". Fleda, not knowing what else to do, turns to her "friend" Guy, and tells him all about it. The villain had told her that the debt would be resolved if she married him, and Guy instead pays him off, and the debt is hushed up and forgotten. This then convinces Fleda to marry Guy. Sure, the idea is that he would have paid her uncle's debt even if she hadn't said yes, but let's be real. It was manipulation.
After marrying her, he rushes off to England to settle "unrest among the poor", and leaves his bride in the hands of his mother. He refers to her as his wife, but it seems that the author's idea of marriage is much like her idea of salvation. . . there is no mention of a wedding of any kind, not even an elopement, just "She said yes", and "Mother, take care of my wife for me."
She is so young and naive that I really, really can feel nothing but pity for her, and even in the end, Guy is manipulative, and makes her vow to always let him heal her hurts, or something like that, after she says she can't promise to never cry unless she is in his arms, because tears have a will of their own. (Why does he get a thrill out of her crying??)
There are also many mentions that make it known that he's not ignorant of the fact that she's still a child; in fact, he tells her that "She will no longer be her uncle's child, but his now."
Maybe I've just seen too much (I'm not unspoiled by the world, as Fleda is), but this book made me cringe, and even though I stuck it out to the end, it took some serious willpower after Guy came back into the picture. In short, he made a perfect Guy of himself.