I can understand the general opinion that this book is not as good as the first one. It drags in some parts, but in others it has boundless energy. I think the biggest dislike for this book stems from the fact that most people find that they want to escape, and if given the opportunity, they believe they would take it. No looking back, just jump. For some that's true, it is possibly even why they read so much. I think many do not realize just how difficult it would be to up and leave everything behind, knowing you could never see any of it again.
That is exactly what this heroine, Marian, was dealing with. Her brother was her whole world. Her parents were either long gone, or emotionally so. With only her brother by her side, she made it to adulthood and was codependent upon him. I think most people reading just wanted her to stop wallowing in fear of losing her brother and just act. I can agree to some extent, but I would feel very similarly to her should I be in her situation. I actually found I empathized with her more than Alexa, though I wished I were more like Alexa myself.
Overall this book was actually really good. I enjoyed the depictions of magical training and the descriptions of battles, the glimpses of characters we knew and loved from the first book.
I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who loves fantasy and magic and strong women.
Trigger Warnings: Verbally Abusive Parent, Death of a parent (past), Sick sibling, character death, lost (but found) pet, eye damage