I got this book in a set of westerns for my mom and am reading them after her.
I thoroughly enjoyed it. By the time I got around to reading this one, I had forgotten that it was a collection of short stories. I was so enjoying the first story, the mystery, and the way that the main character, Utah Blaine, was figuring things out that I was looking forward to reading the rest of the book about him, when, to my dismay, that short story ended and the rest of the book didn't have him at all. But it didn't really matter, because I enjoyed those as well, although I think the first was my favorite. In it, Utah had become the new town marshal and had to solve the old murder cases. I liked the analytical ways that he figured them out. In most westerns, the emphasis is on emotion, excitement, or ability, not intellect, and so that was interesting to me.
In the second story, Kirby Brock was just a spoiled brat, although she did have better reason for acting as she did than I first realized.
The last story, for which the collection was named, "Monument Rock," seemed to move more slowly than the rest, but I liked it in that the good guy did not defend the defenseless woman because of romance. He already had a sweetheart elsewhere that he was faithful to. He just did it because she needed the help, and because he didn't trust the man calling himself her father on the ranch.
On the other hand, another reviewer said that there's enough romance in this book of westerns to even satisfy women who only like to read romances. I can see that, too.
Also in that story, the topic of posses getting the wrong people for lynching came up. I know that did happen in the west. Justice was quick and not always just. But it was interesting to me to see Louis L'Amour play around with that topic in story form.
In "Reviewing the Movies," Peter Fraser said, “The pleasure [of westerns and other adventure stories] stems from the implausibility of the story… We have lost hope for real solutions to problems like international terror and organized crime." Some of these stories did have their implausible moments. Some of the villains in a couple of the stories had Stormtrooper-like abilities in missing everything they shot at, but that wasn't in most of the stories, and I didn't think it detracted much from the stories. Besides which, shooting a moving target is hard.
Favorite quotes:
"I'd sure not want to leave a lady out here in the desert with nobody to fuss at but rattlers. It wouldn't be civilized!"
"Until you learn how to act like a gentleman, I haven't got a thing to say!" Although I'm all for people talking through their difficulties with each other, that doesn't mean that they have to listen to insults, because that's not really working towards reconciliation.