I’ve had this on my TBR for well over a decade, always passing it over due to sheer size, but with the year I was having with books in 2025, I knew this either would close out or start a new cycle of novels for me. Unfortunately, it wasn’t a real triumph to sit through.
Positively, it is well written once we get to the trial portion. Thompson clearly knows his way around a court room, and knows how to engage an audience in the proceedings. The dialogue there is snappy, thrilling and engaging from a scientific and theological standpoint.
Now, my biggest grievance is how bloated the book feels. A lot of time spent building up characters we lose track of as the book moves on, especially the plaintiff. When dealing with any conversational dialogue, the book falls stiff and flat, feeling more presentational than anything else. You get the vaguest sense of internal lives from the primary lawyers, but at the end of the day I finished feeling like these were stand ins for an issue debate more than people fighting for a cause.
Also to say it feels like the female attorneys on both sides felt ancillary, used more so men wouldn’t have to interrogate female witnesses on abortion.
Ultimately I’m glad to have conquered one of my white whale books, but it’s not the resounding success or failure I was hoping for. It’s just…. Fine.