There are times while reading this book that I would rate it 2 stars, then 3 stars, and other times 5 stars. I decided to give it 3 stars overall.
I remember watching Andy Rooney on 60 Minutes as a kid and thinking about how pessimistic and irritable he always seemed, but at the same time, he would ponder some philosophical questions and give a no nonsense answer. This book is a clear representation of his personality – pessimism at its best. At times, he would say things that I wholeheartedly concurred with about the war and how historians have interpreted various historical WWII events. At other times, I would completely disagree with his viewpoint.
In his book, Rooney comes across as cocky, insubordinate, vengeful, philosophical, and bratty. At times, I feel as though he thinks he is superior to others; while at other times, he downplayed his abilities. He seemed to evaluate himself as he wrote this book. Perhaps he was thinking back on how little he knew in his 20s versus his older age. He said he was not racist or judged others based on education and/or wealth, but then, he would do just that to those he spoke up in his book. He was very well off growing up, but yet, he downplayed his upbringing saying he didn’t know he was better off than others. (He went to a private school, and his father made a fairly decent income, particularly during the depression.) Even though he got married in North Carolina, he said he absolutely hated NC when he was in basic training, and it stayed with him because of “tobacco & Jesse Helms.”
He is an atheist, and during the 50th anniversary of D-Day, he wondered why graves were only marked by crosses and stars of David. He seemed offended that there were only two categories for soldiers’ grave markers.
His sour, matter of fact, extremely pessimistic attitude emanated throughout the book.
I found one particular incident disturbing. At the Falaise Gap, he felt more sorry for the horses dying in battle than of men dying. He described the horses’ deaths in more detail than the deaths of soldiers. Perhaps this is due to the fact that German soldiers were being killed, and he had seen a lot of atrocities during the war.
I do understand his argument that many times historians evaluate events in the present rather than looking back at the moment they occurred. He defends the battle at Falaise Gap by saying historians are wrong on the amount of German troops that escaped. He was there as well as coming ashore soon after D-Day. He saw the bodies still lying on the shore. He contends this battle was bloodier for the Germans than D-Day was for us Americans. Historians have the advantage that they know how the story ends, but those who live it are living day by day with the unknown and uncertain future.
Rooney writes “For the first time, I knew for certain that any peace is not better than any war.” Rooney thought this after seeing the atrocities of a concentration camp along with a workers’ camp where the Germans burned everyone alive rather than allow them to be freed by American troops. Rooney’s statement is quite profound. It brought to mind how British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain wanted to make peace with Germany and Hitler, but Churchill understood Rooney’s statement better than any other British citizen of the time. Also, Rooney said he would rather call the Holocaust a genocide and provided his rationale for it.
Lastly, Rooney did not like being in the army. He was drafted and found an opportunity as soon as he could to become a reporter at the Stars & Stripes newspaper. He seemed to enjoy the freedom that provided as he reported on various battles and events of the war. He provided an honest account of his experiences covering the war. If you ever knew individuals who were born in the early 1900s and lived through the war, you get a glimpse of their no nonsense, matter of fact, don’t care who I offend - I’m going to tell it like it is attitude when you read Rooney’s book. While I didn’t always agree with many of his sentiments, I would recommend reading this book.