Seven Sacred Rivers deserves 5 stars. Bill Aitken loves India's geography and its rivers. He has lovingly described them as celestial nymphs and livings goddesses, having a personality of their own. He has lamented the lack interest of ordinary Indians in their geography (which till date is true) and building of roads, bridges and dams (To this he refers as 'Nehruvian Development') resulting in destruction of forests, loss of habitat of flora, fauna and tribal people. However in my opinion, the construction of infrastructure is absolutely necessary and inevitable.
The low point in the book is that he views the difference between worship of rivers in the North and South India and their iconography (as goddesses) through the Aryan-Dravidian theory (he has explicitly mentioned it) which long has been debunked by anthropologists. Maybe the theory was in vogue when the book was being written. This also creates a confusion- its not clear as to which period was the book being written, as it also doubles up as a travelogue. For example, he has written about his travel in Laddakh region and has described the poor condition of roads, arrival of tourists hoards in convoy of busses. Tourists nowadays take flights to the region and the roads have been improved (and bikers riding upto Laddakh in their Bullet motorcycles is common). Hotels, restaurants and markets have been built. Then, there's a genuine complaint of seeking of alms by temple priests.
It also happens that Bill Aitken strongly despises Brahminical Hinduism and laments the disappearance of Buddhism from India, along with the destruction of forest habitat of tribals, flora and fauna.
This book is not an organized, systematic, chapter-wise study of India's major rivers from their source to the delta, but is an account of author's travels along their course, studying their meanders, cascades and their ebbs and flows along with the life on their banks. As a result, objectivity is missing- the reader gets confused which river is he writing about, and is he writing about the mainstream or their tributaries ? In the beginning of a chapter that appears to be about a peninsular river, he deviates to the uphill, rocky path in the high Himalayan gorges that surround the Mandakini. He would describe the shift of the sacredness of the river from the Indus to the Ganges and in the next Paragraph he would describe the Rann of Kachh and Dwarika . The following paragraph would be about students' agitation for Gorkhaland in Darjeeling and then he describes his travels in Nepal Terai.
Bill Aitken has travelled the length and breadth of India, often risking his life, to study the rivers and their tributaries to tell us their stories. His description of India, its rivers, mountains, gorges and watersheds is vivid, easy to understand. Recommended for every nature lover and geography enthusiast.