I didn’t just come to Reformed Theology through the Young, Restless, and Reformed movement- I came to faith within it. The only church I've ever known has celebrated catholicity and the historic, orthodox Reformed doctrines. Voices like D.A. Carson, Tim Keller, and John Piper helped shape this new way of doing church in the post-Christian West, and this collection of essays by D.A. Carson is a celebration of that entire movement.
Being a fan of both essays and Carson's broader corpus, I found this book incredibly enjoyable. But more than that, I believe it will find wide use in pastoral circles. It is deeply pastoral at its core, theologically rich, and packed with practical advice on engaging modern Western culture. One of the most rewarding aspects of the work is how ecumenical it is. Carson, through his ministry, touches almost every part of the church as an institution- local churches, academic institutions, para-church ministries, and think tanks like The Gospel Coalition.
The book is divided into six sections of grouped essays. The first section focuses on Carson himself, exploring his unique approach to theology and ministry. It’s the only section that includes essays from other scholars, offering a brief biography of Carson and an analysis of what sets his theological method apart.
The second section focuses on the Gospel, addressing themes such as true gospel conversion and the tendency to conflate the Gospel with its positive effects.
The third section is perhaps the most academic, dealing with issues related to Biblical Theology. Two essays that stood out to me personally were "Kingdom Ethics," which examines how our ethics should be both institutional and individual, and "A Biblical Theology of Education," which looks at education through the lens of Biblical Theology.
The fourth section is about how the church should engage with contemporary culture. Several essays here address the intolerance of modern “tolerance” movements, particularly in the LGBTQ+ space. In "Words and Deeds," Carson provides practical advice on how ministers can promote acts of mercy within local congregations, while in "Polemical Theology," he offers guidance on how to practice winsome polemics.
The fifth section focuses on leadership issues within the church. This part leans more towards Carson’s Baptist roots but remains in line with the ecumenical spirit of the book. One essay on the shortcomings of the YRR movement and warnings for genuine revival was especially engaging.
Finally, the sixth section covers discipleship, tackling topics such as excommunication and how to handle disputable matters within the church.
Overall, the book is long but incredibly helpful. The essays are well anthologized and categorized into easily referenced chapters. While it deserves to be read as one cohesive volume, it will also serve as a valuable reference tool for pastors and ministry students for years to come.
The work is accessible- one of the hallmarks of Carson’s writing style. However, it might not appeal as much to a lay audience, given its pastoral focus.
Crossway and TGC have produced an attractive book with an easy to read typeface, ample margins, and thick paper well suited for note taking. The inclusion of a few blank pages at the back for additional notes is a nice touch. The two non-Carson essays add meaningful content to the volume, and I appreciated their inclusion.
All in all, a great read. I plan to reference it often.