Maroon Societies was thrilling journey across the breadth of Maroon experiences in the Americas. Though an older work that uses some terminology that is offensive or deprecated today, and one that certainly does not benefit from the latest work in the field, the primary sources and depth of the scholarship hold up to this day. It was fascinating to read about details like alliances and mergers between Indigenous and Maroon communities in different places and times, marronage as one of the varied strategies enslaved Black people turned to, and interplays of war and peace between Maroon and white planter societies.
The geographically organized chapters foreground the unique circumstances and contexts of each region, such as Jamaican plantation owners' incoherence and ineffectiveness in the face of the culturally cohesive and highly competent Maroon bands, while also commenting on larger patterns such as factors that made some enslaved people likelier to choose the difficult and risky path of permanent escape, or grand marronage.
An astounding array of narratives emerges from the tragic to the humorous, such as all the able-bodied enslaved workers on a French Caribbean plantation called Deshaies hiding away to successfully thwart the sale of the plantation, or a British posse leader in Jamaica entertaining the wife of Maroon leader Bulley trying and failing to get her to betray her husband.
The various Maroon societies' peerless ingenuity and the rich, diverse complexity of their organization are on display across time and space. The abundance and quality of many of these communities' agricultural cultivation in the wilds were recorded in admiring detail by the colonial soldiers that found (and then destroyed and pillaged) their fields. Many Maroon communities survived and thrived on trade with freed Black communities and white planters, and enjoyed deep relationships of support and exchange with enslaved Black communities. In numerous cases, Maroons achieved military triumphs over planter armed forces through brilliant strategems, careful preparation, and courageous maneuvers. The fortifications and traps that embattled quilombos in Brazil built against approach and invasion by enslavers were marvels of engineering and resourceful uses of terrain.
Through this vast array of accounts Maroon communities, together with the freed and enslaved African diaspora communities they were so often intertwined with, foreground themselves as active agents and creators of history, frequently fighting planter societies into suing for peace and establishing themselves in Jamaica, Suriname and elsewhere as key political players in the process of nation-shaping.
The accounts also do not shy away from the troubling compromises many Maroon groups had to make, foremost among them agreements not to accept any more escapees from enslavement or even agreements to cooperate in the capture of such fugitives. It is a sobering reminder that the triumphs of Maroon bands generally took place against the backdrop of the military and industrial might of enslaving colonial societies.
It is fitting that the final chapters focus on modern Maroon-descended communities, specifically communities of the Djuka people in Suriname, living at peace in societies of their own making. The lively descriptions of their customs and organization as of the late 20th century were windows into African diaspora societies' creativity and complexity in drawing from diverse influences including ones from Africa, such as Akan-originated matrilinearity among the Djuka, while taking received traditions in different directions such as more equal divisions of inheritance among the Djuka compared to the Akan people and general tendencies toward economic parity within communities.
The book closes with an account of Surinamese Maroon Granmans (Paramount Chiefs) traveling to Africa for a tour across the West African regions their ancestors were abducted away from centuries before. The colorful and entertaining narrative was also a poignant testament to the Maroon communities' survival in the face of heartbreaking injustices and incredible adversity to build vibrant societies and cultures, and to their complex yet real ties to distant ancestral homelands.
I won't say Maroon Societies is a quick or easy read. There are unflinching descriptions throughout of antiblack cruelty, murder, and enslavement (but I repeat myself) that readers may find traumatic, and it is no single-sitting page-turner for the vast majority of people given the scope and sheer length across 21 chapters by almost as many contributors. Nor does it offer a pat, unifying grand narrative as bestselling popularizations of history tend to. Rather, the different contributions do the hard historical work of puzzling through minutiae and complicated conclusions while being accessible and readable throughout.
The good news is, the sprawling and decentralized nature of Maroon Societies means it is perfectly valid to read chapters about regions or subjects of particular interest. The book does not have to be read in particular order, either. It does not even have to be read in full, and seeing how reasonably priced it is for such a long work I would say a few chapters of reading still makes it a bargain.
Reading the book in full, however, makes for an incomparable experience, both a high-level view and intimate scrutiny of Maroon and associated African diaspora experiences in the Americas and the Caribbean. I didn't hurry through it, reading chapter-by-chapter over the course of about a year with plenty of breaks, and was rewarded with a rich telling of these remarkable communities' stories in all their dazzle and darkness. It was an inviting entry point to the large and dynamic field of Maroon scholarship, and the single most epic reading experience of my life.