For some time now I’ve had the vague idea that I’ve “read” Robert E. Howard. Oh, I’ve read most of the Conan stuff, as well as several stories. But after a weekend of reading Cthulhu: The Mythos and Kindred Horrors, it’s clear I’ve got a ways to go. I ran across this 1987 gem in a used bookstore, and I was intrigued right away. Other than the oft anthologized “Pigeons from Hell” (which is not a Cthulhu story), I didn’t really note any stories that I had read before (as it turns out there was one). Prefacing the collection was a too-brief, but perceptive, introduction by David Drake. In fact, it’s fairly hard hitting, stating that for all of the blood and thunder in his fiction, Howard was a fragile man, one who tried suicide at the death of his dog, and who would in fact do the deed with his mother’s fatal illness.
Drake doesn’t spend much time discussing Lovecraft, but does mention that Howard’s pulpy world was a mask for a dark worldview. But that’s probably all that is needed. What follows are many Cthulhu related stories that are as good as anything Howard wrote. What’s interesting is how Howard takes another man’s creation (Lovecraft’s Mythos), and makes it his own. There’s some wonderful atmosphere and dread – Lovecraft strengths, married up with Hot Damn Howard action. Also interesting is how Howard set out to create his own subset of the Mythos, complete with his mad poet, and a particular focus on Tsathoggua (the nasty frog thing).
There are a few other stories related to ghosts and black magic, but this book is overwhelmingly Mythos related. It's also one of the best books I’ve read this year, and one that quickly goes on my “Treasured Finds” shelf. These stories are probably available in more recent reprints (The Horror Stories of Robert E. Howard being one), but this particular edition has a focus that really makes it special. Also, it has a few poems by REH. My favorite on that front (despite a glaring typo) was “Silence Falls on Mecca’s Walls.” Clearly, he was a big fan of Kipling, and it shows. Not a bad thing, especially when it takes a Weird Tales direction. A few notes on the stories below:
“The Black Stone.” Set in eastern Europe, this one was clearly influenced by Stoker. Turkish raids on an evil town, the search for ancient stone, the writings of a mad man, and a night time dance before a demon. Also reminded me of the John Silence stories by Blackwood. Whoa!
“The Fire of Asshurbhal.” Sort of an Indiana Jones meets Cthluhu story. American adventurer and his faithful Afghan guide battle nasty Arabs in a demon haunted city. Excellent.
“The Thing on the Roof.” A jewel or carving that should not have been brought back from the jungles of Yucatan. Terrific.
“Dig Me No Grave.” This story reminded me a bit of M.R. James, with a character that’s obviously using Aleister Crowley as a model. Black magic, deals with demons, and other horrible things. Excellent.
“The Valley of the Worm.” The first of several “worm” stories in this book. Also the first of the sword and sorcery efforts in the collection. Here we have the (reincarnated) account of Niord and the Worm. As Niord tells it, Beowulf learned it all from him. A hideous valley with a secret, and an ass kicking hero.
“The Shadow of the Beast.” This one involves an abandoned house in the “piney” woods, and a bad man who should not have hid there. Weakest story in the collection, and probably an early attempt at what would become “Pigeons From Hell.” It’s not a bad story, but given the company in the collection, definitely not on the same level. Non-Mythos story.
“Old Garfield’s Heart.” A story with a western setting, which involves a bully, an Indian magician, and a very old man who doesn’t look that way. I liked this. It’s not great Howard, but it’s pretty good. Non-Mythos story.
“People of the Dark.” Bizarre and crowded story that involves reincarnation, revenge, Conan, and a running battle in a cave with Descent like creatures. I had read this before. Pretty good.
“Worms of the Earth.” A Bran Mak Morn story. A long, and seemingly convoluted story, that involves the Pictish King on a mission of vengeance against a Roman governor. This one has it all. Black magic, revenge (and its limits), and sword play. One of my favorite stories in the collection. Excellent. I need to read more Bran Mak Morn. A lot like Conan, but a bit subtler.
“Pigeons From Hell.” A nasty horrible haunted house story set in the South. One of Howard’s best stories, and one that also illustrates Howard’s pulpish range. I’ll say no more.
Cover Art: 3 1/2 stars.