Among German crimes of the Second World War, the Nazi massacre of 642 men, women, and children at Oradour-sur-Glane on June 10, 1944, is one of the most notorious. On that Saturday afternoon, four days after the Allied landings in Normandy, SS troops encircled the town in the rolling farm country of the Limousin. Soldiers marched the men to nearby barns, lined them up, and shot them. They then locked the women and children in the church, shot them, and set the building and the rest of the town on fire. Residents who had been away for the day returned to a blackened scene of horror, carnage, and devastation.
In 1946 the French State expropriated and preserved the entire ruins of Oradour. The forty acres of crumbling houses, farms and shops became France's village martyr, set up as a monument to French suffering under the German occupation. Today, the village is a tourist destination, complete with maps and guidebooks.
In this first full-scale study of the destruction of Oradour and its remembrance over the half century since the war, Sarah Farmer investigates the prominence of the massacre in French understanding of the national experience under German domination. Through interviews with survivors and village officials, as well as extensive archival research, she pieces together a fascinating history of both a shattering event and its memorial afterlife.
Complemented by haunting photographs of the site, Farmer's eloquent dissection of France's national memory addresses the personal and private ways in which, through remembrance, people try to come to terms with enormous loss. Martyred Village will have implications for the study of the history and sociology of memory, testimonies about remembrances of war and the Holocaust, and postmodern concerns with the presentation of the past.
On June 10, 1944, German SS troops entered the small French village of Oradour-sur-Glane and rounded up the men and shot them. Women and children were locked in a church, where they could hear their men being shot – then they were shot and the church set afire. The entire village was then vandalized and set in flames. 642 women, men and children were murdered that day. There were only a few survivors – a few managed to escape, one woman did through the church window. Others, more fortunate in a sense, were away during that time – only to arrive in the devastated village to find their entire families and relatives slaughtered. The villages long history, going back hundreds of years, had ended.
The author tells us the story in full. Up to the 1990s survivors provided historical tours of the remnants of the village. The entire village was left as is – to be a memorial to the murdered martyrs. Their remains – ashes – are in the church burial ground.
Page 93 (my book)
[This] contributed to a peculiar tension of France as a victim of the Nazis versus France as a proud country of resistors.
One of the main problems was the site of Oradour-sur-Glane could not be preserved intact. The ruins of the town over the years were constantly deteriorating with the winter weather and the constant overgrowth of vegetation covering up many of the ruins. The site was in flux and looking less and less like it did on June 10th, 1944.
The author also examines the tragedy in terms of France and the Resistance movements.
Page 88
The use of the term “martyr” reflected the overwhelming belief that France had been powerless in the face of Nazism.
There was much political jockeying between France’s diverse parties and the families of the murdered victims.
Page 93
The proponents of Oradour as a national monument drew on a tradition of mixing religion and nationalism.
In 1953 there was a trial of some of the soldiers who were there that day which also escalated tensions and divisiveness in France. Some of the soldiers were recruits from Alsace – French territory annexed by Germany after 1940 (it had also been annexed by Germany between the years 1871 and 1918).
One of the most poignant passages in the book is when the author is taken on a tour of the ruins with a survivor. She also discusses the P.T.S.D. which afflicted surviving family members for their entire lives – their homes, families and relatives gone forever on that fateful day.
This is an excellent rending of Oradour-sur-Glane within the wider context of France and also how changes in France’s role – more so the aspect of Vichy France, have been re-evaluated and examined over the years. For example, Francois Mitterrand could hardly acknowledge France’s role in actively aiding the Germans with the deportation of French Jews to Auschwitz; whereas Jacques Chirac openly admitted France’s guilt. The Pandora’s box of the years of occupation continues to be probed and scrutinized – and myths demolished.
I first learned of Oradour-sur-Glane from the memorable series “The World at War -episode I” made in the early 1970s. The first two minutes of the intro concern Oradour. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0b4g4...
In 2011, my wife and I "discovered" the burned out village of Oradour-sur-Glane in west central France. The memorial village is about 30 minutes northwest of Limoges. If you are planning a trip to France, the town should be considered a "don't miss" on your itinerary. You'll enjoy Limoges as well (porcelain is its claim to fame). After going through the small but extraordinary museum attached to the village and walking through the ruins, the questions of why and how this could happen bothered me for the next few years.
Recently, I found two books on the subject. The first was ORADOUR by Robin Mackness (previously reviewed by me) a British author and entrepreneur. It reads like a spy thriller but is non-fiction. The second was MARTYRED VILLAGE (ISBN 978-0520224834, price varies, trade paperback from the University of California Press) by Sarah Farmer. This is scholarly history. The two books vary in their theories as to the "why" of the massacre of nearly 650 innocent French citizens 4 days after D-Day invasion of Normandy during WWII. (June 10, 1944).
Professor Farmer covers the event very briefly at the beginning of the book. Most of "Martyred Village" deals with how the rest of France dealt with the tragedy over the next 50 years and how the memorial came into existence. she talks a great deal about national, regional and local memory (Never Forget!) when dealing with tragedy. Even though Oradour is located in the Limousin region of France (yes, there is a new village adjacent). Professor Farmer puts the story in perspective to other regions of France and in a national/international context as well.
I urge you in strongest terms to delve into this tragic story and REMEMBER.
When I first read this book, I only had a week to digest the information. It was one of the required texts for an upper level college seminar called Politics of Memory in Modern Europe. I picked it up again 15 years later, knowing that it is academic and meaty, and I enjoyed it even more. There are few texts from school that I could sit down and enjoy in a leisure- type way, but this still proves to be a page turner.
The tragic occurrence at the French village of Oradour-sur-Glane during WWII is heart-rendering and infuriating. I was interested in learning more details and gaining a better understanding of what happened, so I searched for books on the subject. Martyred Village by Sarah Farmer was one of the two books I ultimately purchased.
Upon reading the introduction, I grew fearful that this wasn't what I was seeking. The introduction clearly indicated that the subject of the book would be the subject of memories and how it impacts individuals and society-at-large. The introduction read much like a college thesis, so I was fearful the book would be more philosophical and scientific as opposed to historical.
Fortunately, while the subject of memory is covered in some detail, the book proved fascinating, filled with history and personal stories. While the actual incident itself wasn't covered in great detail, the subsequent investigations, trials and village status and future were discussed in depth. The author did a thorough job in these areas, especially considering the main emphasis of the book is on memories.
For those interested in more than just the details of the actual incident, Martyred Village would be a very good source.
A fascinating and superbly researched account of this dark chapter in French history. I will be visiting Oradour in July and wanted to research the history before I go. It was highly interesting reading about the disputes and repercussions post-war. A highly recommended ,serious book.
I would've appreciated a more in-depth analysis at the end of the work tying together the major themes, but definitely not the worst French history book I've read this year.
Very readable. She treats the experience of Oradour both as historical event and in memory. A worthwhile read especially for anyone who has been to or plans to go to Oradour-sur-Glane. I went a few years ago and it was well worth the car rental.