Dead Waters is the fourth Simon Canderous novel from Anton Strout and when I first started reading it, I was beginning to think that it wouldn’t be as good at the third novel, Dead Matter. And it isn’t, at first. The book takes a little time before it kicks into gear, so if you’re reading Anton Strout for the first time, I’d say give it some time. Because when the book DOES kick into gear, it gets good.
The main premise is that Simon and friends must investigate the murder of one of the department’s head honcho friends, who apparently drowned while in the middle of his apartment. Getting that investigation started is the part of the novel that’s slow. But once Simon gets a lead, the plot picks WAY up and things kick into action. And the plot has many, many twists and turns, more so than in any other Canderous novel in my opinion. I also feel that the plot is more tightly woven here. Most of the "looseness" that I had issues with in previous books is gone. And while this book doesn’t have as much of the character development as the previous one (it was more focused on plot), there are some good character issues here, mostly dealing with Simon and his girlfriend Jane. Again, those issues are rocky at the beginning, but I felt that they were handled well once the book took off.
One of the aspects of Simon Canderous novels that I’ve liked is the use of some of the New York City setting and history. We got glimpses of this in the previous books, with one of them even using Bryant Park and its history to great effect. Here, though, I think Anton has upped the ante, bringing in the Hell Gate Bridge and its history and actually using it for a significant portion of the book and the plot. And then there’s the slew of characters and creatures that feature in this book. I’d mention some of them, but each is discovered as the plot progresses, and I don’t want to spoil anything.
THEN there’s the major twist at the end . . . which I also can’t mention. *grin*
So, a good book, definitely one of the best in the Simon Canderous series so far, with a few minor drawbacks: it takes a while to really get the plot moving, and I didn’t really need to be reminded over and over and over again that some of Simon’s actions were being influenced by the experience with the ghost in the first chapter. But those things aside, much tighter plotting here, and some interesting bad guys all around.