Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Case Against Fluoride: How Hazardous Waste Ended Up in Our Drinking Water and the Bad Science and Powerful Politics That Keep It There

Rate this book
When the U.S. Public Health Service endorsed water fluoridation in 1950, there was little evidence of its safety. Now, six decades later and after most countries have rejected the practice, many cities and towns across the United States continue to fluoridate their water supply and the Center for Disease Control and the American Dental Association continue to endorse it, despite increasing evidence that it is not only unnecessary, but potentially hazardous to human health.

In this timely and important book, Dr. Paul Connett, Dr. James Beck, and Dr. H. Spedding Micklem take a new look at the science behind water fluoridation and argue that just because the medical establishment endorses a public health measure, that doesn't mean it's safe. In the case of water fluoridation, the chemicals used to fluoridate the water that more than 180 million people drink each day are not pharmaceutical grade, but rather hazardous waste products of the phosphate fertilizer industry; it is illegal to dump them into rivers and lakes or release them into the atmosphere. And water fluoridation is a prime example of one of the worst medical practices possible-forced medication with no control over the dose or who gets it. Perhaps most shocking of all, it is not subject to any federal regulation.

At once painstakingly-documented and also highly-readable, The Case Against Fluoride brings new research to light, including links between fluoride and harm to the brain, bones, and kidneys, and argues that while there is possible value in topical applications like brushing your teeth with fluoride toothpaste, the evidence that swallowing fluoride reduces tooth decay is surprisingly weak. The Case Against Fluoride doesn't question the good intentions of dentists who support fluoridation, but rather explores the poor science, bizarre tactics, biased reviews, and puzzling motivations of a relatively small number of influential people who continue to push this practice on a largely ill-informed public.

392 pages, Paperback

First published August 16, 2010

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Paul Connett

5 books9 followers
Professor of Chemistry
St. Lawrence University
New York

Dr. Paul Connett is the Director of the Fluoride Action Network (FAN), and the Executive Director of its parent body, the American Environmental Health Studies Project (AEHSP). He has spoken and given more than 2,000 presentations in forty-nine states and fifty-two countries on the issue of waste management. He holds a bachelors degree from the University of Cambridge and a Ph.D. in chemistry from Dartmouth College and is a retired professor of environmental chemistry and toxicology at St. Lawrence University. He lives in Canton, New York.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
43 (44%)
4 stars
30 (31%)
3 stars
16 (16%)
2 stars
2 (2%)
1 star
5 (5%)
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews
15 reviews3 followers
March 9, 2011
I used to think the anti-fluoride crowd was a bunch of on-the-fringe nut cases. But now I am one! Thanks to the facts provided by sources like this book and the Fluoride Action Network (http://fluoridealert.org/), Americans are becoming more aware of the dangers associated with the common but unnecessary practice of dumping fluoride into our municipal water supplies. I hope people are willing to read this book and become educated.
Profile Image for Rogier.
Author 7 books27 followers
August 4, 2013
This is undoubtedly THE go-to book on the whole fluoride hoax.

It remains incredible on the face of it that a hoax could be continued this long, but I guess it has.

In Europe fluoridation started in the 60's and ended in the 70's, after the lack of a solid scientific base became clear, right now the tide is turning in Canada, and in New Zealand, and even Australia. Ireland is seeking to make it criminal, and Great-Britain and the USA are the lone holdouts any more. Yet there is now so much good science that refutes all the pro-fluoride arguments, that it cannot take too long any more before we are ready to get rid of this industrial poison in our drinking water in the USA as well.
12 reviews1 follower
December 8, 2010
mostly a skim read for me. seems like a solidly argued case on why communities should not add fluoride to drinking water. history, bad-science and political background that got things where they are today is interesting as well.
98 reviews
May 1, 2012
Dr. Connett is a chemistry professor who previously accepted the common belief that fluoride was a positive for dental health but after thorough scientific investigation he has become an activist against the forced medicating of our population with fluoride. Read this book and you will immediately run out and buy a reverse osmosis water filter. Not only is ingesting fluoride not good for you, it's a hazard that is causing serious public health issues including but not limited to dental fluorosis, bone fractures, thyroid dysfunction, and lower IQ scores just to name a few.
Profile Image for Jenny Robinson.
78 reviews3 followers
December 13, 2010
This book has TONS of information from every point of view on the issue of Fluoride! This is very important and even if you just skim through this book EVERYONE should know this stuff. Fluoride is NOT Good for us or our children. Start small and filter your water and DO NOT give your children Fluoride tablets or anything they would digest. I do agree that there are some benefits to putting it Directly on your teeth, but it still gets into your system.
Everything in moderation.
11.7k reviews44 followers
March 27, 2024
A SHARP AND DETAILED CRITIQUE OF FLUORIDATION OF PUBLIC WATER SUPPLIES

The Introduction to this 2010 book states, “If you picked up a book that described a government plan to put a hazardous industrial waste product into the public water supply to deliver a topical medical treatment, without fully investigating its long-term health effects and without receiving the informed consent of all the citizens involved, you might well think that you had picked up a science-fiction novel. But… it is a matter of historical fact. We are talking about water fluoridation… In this book we do not argue against the use of FLUORIDE in toothpaste of dental dressings and sealants; but we explain how FLUORIDATION---the addition of fluoride to the public water supply---is … propped up by very poor ethics and very poor science…” (Pg. vii)

They continue, “From its inception, fluoridation has been more about politics than about science… Two consequences of this are (1) that the amount and type of science that is done can be largely determined by political influences; and (2) that the relatively rational discourse that usually accompanies scientific disagreements, at least in public, may be replaced by outright hostility even to the point of personal abuse and discrimination… political influence has ensured that remarkably little scientific work has been done on the issue; and it has generated a high degree of animosity between promoters and opponents… in the book, we shall also see many examples of how science has been manipulated and misrepresented to serve an essentially political end.” (Pg. vii-viii)

They add, “We do not believe that we are overstating the seriousness of the possible downside of fluoridation. People with impaired kidney function accumulate more fluoride in their bones and are more vulnerable to its toxic effects on those issues and possibly others… some young men may be losing their lives to a fatal bone cancer because of this practice… and their thyroid function lowered… millions of infants may be having their mental development subtly impaired… and many adults may be suffering from a series of common complaints---from arthritic symptoms to tiredness not relieved by sleep, to gastrointestinal problems---that could be reversed if the fluoride was removed. Note the word ‘may.’ We do not claim that all these harms have been conclusively proven. What we can say, however, is that much existing information points clearly to a variety of serious risks inherent in the fluoridation program. We argue that these risks are far too high when we are considering the mass medication of millions of people, the more so since the benefits are now seen to be so small and achievable by other means in dozens of non-fluoridating countries.” (Pg. xi)

In the first chapter, they summarize, “Fluoridation… is a poor medical practice because it violates the principle of informed consent to medication. It is indiscriminate and offers no control over the dose received. It makes inadequate allowance for different sensitivity to toxic effects, or for the size and body mass of recipients… young children … may receive proportionately much higher dosages than adults at time when their bodies are far more vulnerable to toxic agents… As a drug, it has not been rigorously tested and has not been approved by the U.S. FDA. Fluoridation increases the chances that the child will develop fluorosis of the permanent teeth… The notion that fluoridation is equitable is misplaced for two reasons: Children from low-income families are more likely to have poor nutrition, making them more vulnerable to fluoride’s toxic effects; and low-income families are least able to afford avoidance measures.” (Pg. 12)

They ask, “Who is in charge of the American fluoridation program at the federal level?---the answer is NO ONE. We can only assume therefore that whatever liabilities are involved in this practice are taken on by local communities or by state authorities where the practice becomes mandatory via state legislation.” (Pg. 28)

They state, “surveys of dental fluorosis indicate that today, even without fluoridation, a large number of children are overexposed to fluoride from an increasing number of sources… The simplest and most direct way of improving this unacceptable situation, opponents say, is to end water fluoridation. Not only would that resolve a major and direct source of fluoride, but it would also eliminate an indirect source---the cumulative amounts of fluoride ending up in beverages and foods processed in fluoridated communities.” (Pg. 112)

They recount, “In 2002, the Office of Drinking Water of the … EPA commissioned the National Research Council (NRC) to review the same drinking water standards for fluoride… The panel’s exposure analysis in … its report indicated that certain subsets of the population consuming water fluoridated at 1 ppm were already exceeding the EPA’s reference dose… the authors singled out three clinical conditions that they believed triggered the need for a new health risk assessment: 1. Clinical stage II skeletal fluorosis… 2. Bone fractures… 3. Severe dental fluorosis.” (Pg. 137-139)

They acknowledge, “Although the NRC report did not examine the safety, efficacy, or benefits of water fluoridation, or specifically evaluate the toxic effects of ‘optima;’ levels of water fluoride on humans, the committee did examine a number of issues that are relevant to such evaluations. In particular, the committee did an extremely thorough review of fluoride intake in the U.S. …” (Pg. 143)

They assert, “Nowhere do the dangers … become more apparent than in the possibility that they may damage brain function… Such changes may not be recognized until the damage becomes irreversible of irreparable. This appears to have happened in the case of … children’s IQ in the United States, when lead was present in gasoline. It doesn’t take a very large downwind shift in IQ in the whole population to have a dramatic effect in decreasing the number of intellectually gifted children and increasing the number of mentally handicapped.” (Pg. 148)

They note, “It is extraordinary that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) was not brought in early to review the safety and effectiveness of ingesting fluoride as a drug to reduce tooth decay… If the FDA had been involved, it would have required a much stricter methodology for assessing both the effectiveness and safety of fluoride… Perhaps one reason the FDA has never become involved with testing fluoride in the public water system is the sheer difficulty of setting up and maintaining meaningful [randomized clinical trials] for ingesting fluoride… Even that would not necessarily resolve the safety issue, since … a cumulative poison … may manifest harm only after many years or decades.” (Pg. 217-218)

They explain, “Fluoridation … simply uses the public water supply to deliver medicine… Once medicine is added to tap water, key controls are lost. You cannot control the dose, and you cannot control who gets the medicine. Moreover, you are forcing medicine on people without their informed consent and, especially in the case of low-income families, without their ability to avoid the medicine if they wish.” (Pg. 247)

They summarize, “fluoridation makes a lot of money and provides a lot of prestige and power for a relatively small number of people… We like to think that for the vast majority of fluoridation promoters, it is more a matter of firm belief than a cause tainted with economic interest. However, it might take only a few people to influence the whole fluoridation-promoting apparatus.” (Pg. 268)

They conclude, “We hope that this book will encourage many more scientists, doctors, dentists, health workers, environmentalists, and others to consider the issues raised and reach an informed opinion… Readers can also play an important part in informing the media, which have tended to over-impressed by the apparent authority of the official line. We need every one with an open mind to examine this issue more carefully… Everyone who is persuaded by the facts we have presented can contribute to informed political pressure at all levels…” (Pg. 274-275)

This book will of great interest to those seeking critiques of public water fluoridation.
Profile Image for Douglas Larson.
479 reviews22 followers
February 22, 2012
I don't usually read so-called "expose" books where the author is telling the reader how bad such and such or so and so is. So I am not sure why I picked up this book, but I am definitely glad that I did.
Even before I read this book, I had been aware that some people believe that fluoride in the water supply is bad for you. I have read the occasional magazine article that spoke to this belief. After reading these articles, I wouldn't say that I believed or disbelieved their message but rather found some aspects of what they said to be plausible and yet didn't have any way to verify or refute their statements.
In this book, the authors present a case against the practice of fluoridating our water supply. They present a history of water fluoridation, describe the key points that fluoride supporters say about fluoridation and then present and discuss, point by point, why each and every one of these arguments are either false or lack sufficient evidence to justify them.
The authors don't present their information with scare tactics the way many expose books do but rather lay it out simply and in a straight forward manner. One of the most astonishing facts they discuss is that even the American Dental Association, one of the key supporters of water fluoridation, has publically admitted that there is little evidence of benefit from fluoride in the water supply. But they do say there is great benefit from fluoride applied topically, e.g. in toothpaste and fluoride rinses. And yet the ADA still supports water supply fluoridation despite this.

The authors point out that even though the majority of countries around the world do not fluoridate their water, the tooth decay rates of children in those countries are no worse than the tooth decay rates of children in countries that do. Very high rates of tooth decay in the United States occur in cities that have been fluoridated for years.

And finally they state that the chemicals used to fluoridate drinking water in the United States are not pharmaceutical grade, meaning that they are not of the same purity used in dental products. Instead, the bulk of the chemicals used come from the wet-scrubbing systems of the phosphate fertilizer industry.
Profile Image for Marc.
21 reviews7 followers
July 17, 2013
Great book that everyone should read regarding the forced mass medication we have to endure through water fluoridation in violation of the Nuremberg protocol. Interesting how studies have shown that fluoridation has been linked to sleeplessness, reduction of an average of 20 points in IQ, Bone cancer, dental fluorosis, joint pain, fibromyalgia, weight gain and arthritis. Not surprising when fluoride happens to be the waste from the aluminum, fertilizer and nuclear industries and is conveniently dumped into our drinking water under the guise of dental health so these industries can not only earn extra profits by selling it to municipalities but then don't have to store or destroy it. Beware tea drinkers especially green tea as the tea leaves have a very high concentration of fluoride from the soils. I now don't drink tea anymore unless it is organic and all my water is distilled.
Profile Image for Athena.
24 reviews9 followers
June 25, 2024
“Once these chains of command were captured at the top (which occurred in the United States in 1950; see chapters 9 and 10), fluoridation-promotion policy could move down from their headquarters to every town in every fluoridating country. Moreover, each chain of command is self-perpetuating. Since 1950, the belief system that supports water fluoridation (it has never been based on science; see chapters 9,10, and 22) has been passed on to each new generation of dentists and public health bureaucrats. Most courses at dental schools and public health programs do not challenge the dogma of the “safety and effectiveness” of fluoridation.” (225)

“What makes this disturbing is that the vast majority of rank-and-file professionals have little time to examine the issue for themselves, at least not in detail.” (226)

“...today the ADA boasts a list of nearly one hundred organizations that endorse fluoridation. While it is clear that these organizations have mobilized very little science of any substance to support their endorsements, for many people, who do not have the time to study the details of this issue for themselves, the strategy of using endorsements is very effective.” (227)

“...few journalists go deeper than a superficial treatment, frequently giving deference to the proponents’ presumed authority.” (229)

Quote by Michael Crichton: “I regard consensus science as an extremely pernicious development that ought to be stopped cold in its tracks. Historically, the claim of consensus has been the first refuge of scoundrels; it is a way to avoid debate by claiming that the matter is already settled… The greatest scientists in history are great precisely because they broke with the consensus… There is no such thing as consensus science. If it’s consensus, it isn’t science. If it’s science, it isn’t consensus. Period.” (257)

A professor said to a Public Health Master’s student “Your job is not to question the science. Your job is to promote the policy.” (260)

“In 1949, one year before the U.S. Public Health Services endorsed fluoridation, the director of the Sugar Research Foundation, a lobby representing about 130 sugar interests, said that its research mission was to “find out how tooth decay may be controlled effectively without restriction of sugar intake.” (264)
Profile Image for Aidan Reid.
Author 23 books116 followers
July 9, 2019
Vital book, especially for those living in fluoridated areas (Ireland being 1 of 8 countries where fluoridation is mandated for the entire populace). Only 2% of the population of Europe consume fluoridated water, which begs the question why, in countries such as Ireland, has it been allowed to remain in the water supply (not to mention promoted through other products), despite the incidence of tooth erosion/decay being virtually the same as in non-fluoridated countries. The book avoids conspiracy theory and is backed by an abundance of credible sources to highlight the wonky science and corrupt corporate agenda that continues to promulgate the erroneous assumption that fluoride is good for us. Powerful.
Profile Image for Camille McCarthy.
Author 1 book43 followers
February 2, 2015
This book had a clear message and after reading just a few pages I was convinced that fluoride should not be in our drinking water, does us no good, and could be causing harm to a lot of people. It presented its views with strong evidence and compelling arguments, however, as with a lot of technical concepts, the authors rely too much on convincing the reader with logic which I feel might actually cause it to fall on deaf ears; not everyone has the background needed to understand these arguments so they might feel like it's much easier to just follow the more emotional arguments that these people are just paranoid and there's nothing wrong with the water, fluoride is helping poor people have better teeth, etc. Perhaps they should have been less technical in their writing and maybe tried to be both logical and appeal to peoples' emotions.
Even though the subject interested me, the book was too long. It was like a PhD thesis on the subject, while the common person just needs to know the information included in the first 60 or so pages. This also turned me off and was probably another setback for the authors. A shorter, more personable book would probably have gotten the point across much better, especially since it is a message that needs to be heard -- after reading this I feel that fluoride in the drinking water is a terrible idea and we should get rid of it as soon as possible.
Profile Image for Rachel C.
213 reviews4 followers
January 25, 2011
There may have been painstaking research done on this topic, but this book was painful to read. I was not impressed with the so-called evidence supporting their case throughout the first half of the book. Most of it was based upon studies done in the 1950s. Come on, medicine has changed dramatically in the last 60 years. There may have been other reasons for the conditions those people suffered in the 50s.

Even though I mostly skimmed this book, I did connect more with the latter half of it. Not that I agreed with it in totality. I do feel that over-fluoridation can have negative effects, and that there has definitely been well supported scientific evidence to that end in regard to bone density. Also, I agree that the CDC, FDA, and ADA need to financially support more thorough, current studies into long term effects of fluoride. In the meantime, I think the best approach is - as is most often the case - all things in moderation.
Profile Image for Dr. K Reads.
18 reviews1 follower
September 21, 2011
A well-researched but poorly-written essay on the saga that ensues regarding fluoride. They could have done a lit review on pubmed and called it a day. I couldn't even finish it and I read this stuff all the time. However, if you are on the front lines it will be great to have it in your arsenal. Good luck getting it out of your drinking water if it is there and good luck stopping it from going in...
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews