This long-anticipated work completes John Oswalt's two-volume commentary on the book of Isaiah. After opening with a valuable discussion on the state of Isaiah studies today, Oswalt provides an insightful verse-by-verse explanation of Isaiah 40-66, giving special attention to the message of the prophet not only for his own time but also for modern readers.
This is a super technical and dense commentary. I found it incredible helpful at times and annoyingly technical at others. Oswalt sees Isaiah as having only 1 author and continually defends prophecy and miracles throughout it.
If you want a highly technical commentary on Isaiah, this is probably the place to go. If you are not used to academic, or technical commentaries then I would go elsewhere.
Contains technical material but moves easily and often into devotional reflections. This was my 'go to' commentary for preparing to teach. By no means did I read every word, but what I did manage to read was worth the effort.
Great commentary to listen to as you read through the book of Isaiah. There was only a handful of times I listened ahead of where I was in Isaiah because I lost track of what chapter Oswalt was on.
I do wish there was more emphasis on chapter 53. Thats the famous chapter that describes the crucifixion of Jesus in such detail more then 700 years before Jesus even walked the earth. It seems like Oswalt assumes the listener is already familiar with the chapter. I'd have liked it if he would've directly compared that chapter with the life of Jesus verse by verse.
With that said I definitely recommend the entire commentary. I'll definitely be checking out John Oswalts other work.
I liked these two books, however the author's tendency to start every discussion of every passage with (what seemed to me to be) a review of all of the views of all of the writers who ever looked at the passage and then saying "this is one is probably closest to being accurate" got a little tiresome after awhile.
Easy to read, not overly technical. Fair handed, and exceptional.
One was working out the new covenant as arriving in Christ, and not referring to his 2nd coming. There were lots of times where I had to pause and think through all the ways this would change the interpretation.
How rare it is to read a commentary that is simply joyful to read. Oswalt is an excellent writer and this commentary was a great read on Isaiah. If only more commentaries were this joyful to read...
Oswalt's commentary carried me through teaching a Sunday school class on Isaiah (fools do rush in). Evangelical in its emphasis on the book's unity and its connections to the New Testament, I appreciated its disinterest in prophecy and its non-Calvinist interpretation. For Oswalt a central theme of the book is the necessity of God's people trusting in the God they claim to serve. He does not overwhelm with scholarly apparatus or linguistic detail and does a good job bringing out history and context. Motyer and Westermann were useful as well, but I found Oswalt easier to read (less jumping about) and more pastoral in his interests.
In preaching through Isaiah Oswalt has been one of the primary commentaries I have leaned upon. He is clear, does a good job of unfolding what he is trying to get at. Both volumes have been very useful.
The one thing he is fuzzy on (or maybe I just disagree with him) is the current and eschatological role of historical/ethnic Israel. An example would be his using the existence of the current secular state of Israel as evidence of Yahweh's promises. He has feet on both sides of the continuity/discontinuity fence.
Excellent, conservative commentary on the text of Isaiah. He argues for a unity of the text. includes a translation of the book that is his own. His translation and the associated notes where particularly outstanding and worth "the price of admission" alone!