Indeed, Goliath the Percheron’s non fiction picture book story is definitely engaging and very much inspiring, and author Claudia Friddell also clearly textually demonstrates with Goliath: Hero of the Great Baltimore Fire that before the advent of fire engines fuelled and powered by gas, the many fire horses that had to pull these massive vehicles were generally quite as steadfast and also in every way as heroic as the firemen themselves, standing steadily and generally without panicking or bolting awaiting their handlers’ orders and commands even with flames and debris flying around. And considering that horses are in fact genetically pre-programmed to be massively afraid of fire, and thus instinctively tend to get spooked and try to flee, that in Goliath: Hero of the Great Baltimore Fire Goliath the Percheron fire horse obviously remained standing totally calmly even as the structure the firemen were futilely trying to save (the Hurst Building) exploded and the resulting inferno was very seriously and painfully injuring him, I do find this both positive and praiseworthy, but that of course and naturally, part of me also kind of wishes that Goliath had actually up and bolted, that he had run away from the inferno and the flames that almost killed him, that scarred him for life.
But yes, I do definitely very much understand why for many Baltimorians Goliath’s tale is considered one of true equine heroism. And furthermore, I am also most definitely glad that the veterinarians assigned to care for Goliath after the explosion were both able and also willing to save Goliath’s life, as sadly, horses used as working animals were/are far too often seen as expendable resources, and it is thus sure a huge positive that this was delightfully not at all the case with Goliath, that Claudia Friddell ends Goliath: Hero of the Great Baltimore Fire with a sufficiently recovered but scarred by the flames Goliath returning to the fire station and receiving a well earned hero’s welcome.
Four stars for how in Goliath: Hero of the Great Baltimore Fire Claudia Friddell tells of Goliath’s heroism without making the story sound too fantastical, too unbelievable and Goliath more than he actually is, a well trained and obedient Percheron horse that stood its ground, did not panic and although gravely injured saved both himself and his handler, but lowered to a high three stars for two main reasons, namely that I both want and desire a more expansive historical afterword and a bibliography with suggestions for further reading and that aesthetically, I do find Troy Howell’s accompanying illustrations a bit one dimensional and flat, not deep and nuanced enough for my visual tastes.