So, I finally read Hasil—and honestly? Mixed feelings. I went into it without reading Peer-e-Kaamil, so I didn’t have any spoilers or expectations. That worked in my favor because the plot felt new and different, which I enjoyed in the beginning.
The start had me hooked. I felt genuinely sad for Hadeed—watching him lose people one after the other pulled at my heart. Those Cathedral scenes? That was probably my favorite part of the book. The way they’d meet and have those deep, soul-searching conversations felt raw and meaningful. It made me think this would be a five-star read.
But then... Sania’s story began. And I won’t lie—everything shifted for me after that. The pacing suddenly felt rushed, like the author wasn’t as invested in telling that part of the story. I could feel it in the writing. The emotional connection between the characters fizzled out. Their chemistry? Practically non-existent. It was like they were going through the motions, and I couldn’t buy into their relationship at all.
And don’t even get me started on that confession scene to David—second-hand embarrassment. I had to put the book down for a moment—it felt that awkward. Plus, David as a character didn’t sit right with me. His interest in Sania felt so half-hearted. Like he wouldn’t have cared much either way if he married her or not. It made his death feel less tragic and more… just part of the plot moving along.
Another thing that bothered me: the book never clearly addressed that a Muslim woman marrying a non-Muslim man isn’t allowed in Islam. It’s such a significant point, and it felt wrong that it was just brushed over, especially when the story could have made that clear.
I think what disappointed me most is how much potential Hasil had. It really could’ve been great if the characters had been developed more, if their relationships had been given space to grow, and if the story didn’t feel like it was sprinting to the finish line. It needed those slow, quiet moments between the characters—the kind that make you fall in love with their journey.
Would I recommend it? Only if you’re curious. Personally, I’d say pick up Peer-e-Kaamil instead. I’m told it’s on a whole different level.
Final rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️ — decent, but I expected better.