We made both the French and Italian macarons. We had more success with the French shells and the Italian shells were a bit too sweet for our tastes. Both the dark chocolate ganache and coffee buttercream were great. Also made the pistachio buttercream, it was good but not as good as the chocolate and.coffee.
We had issues with the baking directions. Often the steps were unclear on how to tell when the mixture was ready. The steps weren't broken down well, once we had to ask for a third opinion about what the direction ment. Several times the process came to a halt as we read further down the recipient and we would both be, "why didn't they mention that earlier, we needed to know that steps earlier," then we would have to sort out how to fix what we already did.