Renowned Russian historian Reginald E. Zelnik’s final manuscript is a biography of Anna Pankratova, a woman from Odessa who became a leading labor historian and academic administrator in the Soviet Union from the 1920s to her death in 1957. Drawing upon archival materials once inaccessible to Western scholars, as well as memoirs published since the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Zelnik conceptualized his study as one of "constrained dissent," in the sense that Pankratova, a Communist scholar loyal to the Party, nevertheless courageously sought to protect her colleagues, students, and friends from disaster. Portraying Pankratova as both "victim" and "victimizer," Zelnik treats in evocative detail several revealing episodes in her career as "the most powerful woman in the Soviet Union’s history profession." These episodes include her husband’s arrest, her own exile, and the ruin of many scholarly colleagues during the Stalinist purges. One particularly interesting part of Pankratova’s life was her experience during World War II in Kazakhstan, in Soviet Central Asia, which led her to champion the “national rights” of the Kazakhs. Zelnik’s last monograph marks his first examination of issues of ethnicity and nationalism in the Soviet period, and in the Central Asian context in particular.
Five essays that address Zelnik’s scholarship as a labor historian who approached the central question of class formation through his investigation of participants’ personal experience, as well as his teaching and citizenship, accompany the monograph. Contributors include Laura Engelstein, David A. Hollinger, Benjamin Nathans, Yuri Slezkine, and Glennys Young. The volume also encompasses excerpts from two Soviet texts, including Pankratova’s historic 1956 speech on the menace of Stalinist legacies in history and historiography.
This book is an excellent counterpart to Yekelchyk and Barber; it shows the human side of the Soviet historiography, the actual historians who in other works are reduced to their statements in meeting protocols. Zelnik brings to light the historical and human contexts of the moral choices faced by Soviet historians by tracing the life and career of labour historian Anna Pankratova, who one one hand denounced her "trotskyite" husband and her academic adviser Pokrovsky, but on the other hand supported purged colleagues and went against the current of Party prescriptions in her refusal to switch away from a Marxist approach to history and to idealize the Russian people at the expense of other Soviet peoples. Zelnik only uses published sources, which seem to be sufficient for his purpose. Pankratova's personal papers that available as a result of the "archival revolution," allow to see her not only as a careerist, but as a scholar with some ideological room for maneuvering, in which she acted in accordance with her principles, even if it could potentially backfire. Still, Pankratova acted within the existing ideological framework, she did not see history as objective, but rather as class-based; I found it hilarious that in a speech denouncing the cult of personality in order to support her claim she cited Stalin. Zelnik makes a passing reference to Kotkin, stating that Pankratova spoke Bolshevik not in the sense of adopting it for her own needs, but because she grew into it - I wonder if he has written anything that would expand upon this point. In her review, Engelstein noted that "Perhaps [Zelnik] strains too hard to absolve Pankratova of subservience," which is probably a valid point.