** 2 - 3 stars **
I approached this book with high expectations but ultimately found it disappointing. While the author’s ambition to provide a comprehensive overview of the development of railways worldwide is commendable, the execution falls short.
The first 214 pages of the book are primarily an overwhelming succession of paragraphs recounting how various railways were built – when they were initiated, who was responsible, which towns they passed through, and what delays, costs, or problems were incurred. Although the sheer volume of information is commendable, the book lacks the essential elements needed to appeal to any particular audience. It does not include the detailed and qualified data or thorough indexing required to make it a valuable reference work; at the same time, it lacks the engaging personal stories or compelling narrative style that might make it enjoyable as a leisure read. Moreover, it does not provide sufficient technical detail to appeal to true train enthusiasts. For example, there isn’t any meaningful exploration of the mechanics of railway construction or true insight into the engineering challenges involved. This omission contributes to a sense that all the railways described blur together into an indistinct whole.
Whilst the non-written components for this part were conceptually a good idea, I felt they were misplaced and poorly implemented. Captioning the images with explicit references to certain points in the text would have helped contextualize them. Likewise, the maps were not integrated with the relevant text, making it difficult to connect them to the descriptions of specific lines or locations. Placing these maps alongside the corresponding text and ensuring the labels matched the locations mentioned would have greatly improved their utility. Overall, I believe this preliminary content would have been far more effective as an encyclopaedic guide, with each railway or train line receiving a dedicated spread. Such a format could include a clear map, a timeline, and a well-structured history of each line, making it both more informative and engaging.
These criticisms primarily apply to the first 214 pages of the book. However, the final 115 pages or so show a notable improvement. This part fulfils the promise given in the blurb, focusing more on the impact of the railway revolution and the benefits it brought to nations worldwide. Thanks to its relative brevity and the inclusion of more personal details, the text is less of a never-ending ‘information dump’, making it a more entertaining read. Its content is also accessible to a much wider, more general audience than the preceding part! That said, this section still could have benefited from more frequent referencing and another run of copy-editing.
In my opinion, the book would have been much better if the first 214 pages were condensed, allowing more time to explore the second section. Perhaps a few particular railways could have been examined in depth, looking first at their construction and then their impact. This approach would help tie the two parts of the book together and provide a focus for the reader.
Overall, while the book demonstrates the author’s ambition and dedication, it is let down by its structure, focus and writing style. When taken as a whole, it falls short of being either a useful reference for research purposes or an enjoyable read for a more general audience.