With Beyond Summer, Lisa Wingate's Blue Sky Hill series is three for three. This third installment might just be my favorite, because of its multifaceted cast of characters, its earthy yet almost fantastical plot, and how Lisa took one of the most basic tropes in literature and turned it all around like a prism chock full of color.
In fact, let's start with that trope. I admit some skepticism going in, because I thought Tam would be a somewhat spoiled character fixated on how life had gone downhill because her dad lost all their family's money. Actually though, Tam is much more mature than I gave her credit for. And while I haven't experienced what she has, I could relate to her frustration with the chaos of her new home, the antics of Barbie's kids, and the clueless, truly adult-but-bratty, behavior of Barbie herself. Yet, that relatability wasn't pity. Throughout Beyond Summer, I rooted for Tam to find a physical and emotional place in Blue Sky Hill, whatever form that took.
She did, and better, that form wasn't the cheesy, Hallmark form it could've been, where everything in Blue Sky Hill became perfect. Instead, Tam has down-to-earth, everyday interactions with Shasta, her boys, and even her own family, that expertly mix the good, the bad, and the difficult or confusing. For instance, it would've been easy for Shasta to become Tam's "educator on privilege." But Shasta is a dynamic, three-dimensional woman, wife, and mom with concerns, questions, and presumptions of her own. Seeing the two women work through these at different levels of amiability was a big reason I had trouble putting the book down.
I also loved the layers Tam, Shasta, and others were able to pull back regarding Tam's family and the agenda behind the Blue Sky Hill development. First off, these two feed each other, so Beyond Summer is deeper than the typical "solve the mystery of the greedy developers' endgame" novel. More importantly, Lisa milks the theme of appearance vs. reality and all its angles for all it's worth. Tia, Barbie, even Tam's dad and Barbie's boys, burst with hidden depths. For instance, I loved Tia almost on sight, but was delighted that Lisa went way beyond making her a quirky, elderly auntie. And I was shocked in the best way at how I actually came to like and sympathize with Barbie.
I did have a few preferences or loose ends I'd have liked Lisa to tie up or tweak. For instance, I remember wondering why Shasta never just asked her boys about the mysterious lady leaving the books and figured out she was the "green pants lady." I mean, Shasta seems a lot smarter than that. I also still don't know if I'm fully on board with the resolution for Blue Sky Hill as a neighborhood, meaning the comeuppance wasn't as clear as I'd have liked. But those issues weren't big enough for me to go lower than a five-star rating. Overall, Beyond Summer goes above and beyond and again, might be my favorite of the series. Don't skip ahead, but do read it when you get there, and take time to savor it.