Summary and Analysis:
Little Red Cowboy Hat is a book that would be appropriate for older readers to read independently or younger readers to read with support, as there is a large amount of text in this book and some of the vocabulary could be challenging for a younger reader. Little Red Cowboy Hat is set in the American Southwest and focuses on a young girl who becomes known as "Little Red Cowboy Hat" due to both her bright red hair and her affinity for a large red cowboy hat. Little Red is given the task of bringing homemade bread and a jar of cactus jelly to her ill grandmother. Along the way, appropriately enough, Little Red meets a wolf who hassles her and makes her feel uncomfortable. Although Little Red is able to escape the wolf on her trusty steed, she later encounters the wolf in her grandmother's house. This scene includes the lines of dialogue that this tale has become famous for. Finally, it is grandma that returns and saves the day.
As with many of the "Little Red Riding Hood" tale I selected this week, the authors of this particular tale chose to make major changes to the setting of the story. The author chose this setting because it is one that she was familiar with growing up on a cattle ranch in the Southwest - as she shares in the forward to the book. The details in the text and the illustrations are definitely in keeping with the setting - rattlesnakes, cacti, cactus jelly, horses, cowboy hats, cowboy boots, canyons, mesas where gold poppies and blue lupines bloom, buzzards, etc. The pictures are cartoon-ish but illustrated in warm shades of red, orange, and yellow. My only question is this - is having the wolf as a character in keeping with the American Southwest? Do wolves really live there? Wouldn't it have been more appropriate to change the antagonist of this book to a coyote, for example?
Additionally, the protagonist, Little Red Cowboy Hat ("or Little Red for short") is a great deal more bold and independent than in the traditional versions of the tale. However, Little Red still falls into some of the common errors made by traditional Little Red Riding Hood protagonists, even though their parents/mother/father warn warn against them - gets distracted and doesn't go straight to grandma's house, talks to strangers (the wolf!) along the way. The truly strong character in this tale is the grandmother, which is slightly unusual. Right after the wolf reveals himself and lunges for Little Red, Grandma appears with an ax (as she was chopping wood in the yard). Instead of threatening the wolf with the ax ala the woodcutter - Grandma reaches for her shot gun and runs the wolf off the ranch on horseback, firing all the while.
Another small difference between this tale and other versions of Little Red Riding Hood is in when exactly, does the protagonist notice that it is the wolf and not grandma that they are speaking with in the climax of the story. I have noticed that the stronger and more independent the protagonist, the sooner she notices. In this version, Little Red still believes it to be the grandma once she hears her voice and comments on the big eyes. Little Red becomes aware that it is really the wolf in grandma's bed when she sees the muzzle and comments on the nose. The conversation continues until the sharp teeth comment and response. This surprised me, as I thought Little Red in this tale was a little more "with it", so to speak.