If anyone would have asked me a few days ago if I knew who Matthew Gregory Lewis or Monk Lewis was I would have replied, yes he wrote "The Monk". Everybody knows that. (OK maybe not everybody). But a few weeks ago I came across Mistrust; Or, Blanche and Osbright, and have since learned that M. G. Lewis was not a one book author.
Mistrust is a short story, the one I read was just over 100 pages long. It was published originally in 1808 as part of his collection of "Romantic Tales". In the introduction to my book it says that Mistrust was an adaptation of a German romance from which Lewis acknowledged he had "borrowed a great part of the plot, and one of the most striking scenes". That has me wondering what the original German romance was, but we aren't told.
The story begins with the "hero" of our story returning home from war. He was described as a brave warrior and "few had displayed more valor than the youthful Osbright of Frankheim. He was impatient to depart and as soon as it was given he "gave his horse the spur and sped toward his native towers." However in the next paragraph you find out that it is not his own castle walls that he is hurrying to, not to his parents, or to his younger brother; but it is toward "the avowed enemy of himself and of his whole house".
So he rides as fast as he can through forests and mountains trying to get to his "enemy" as soon as possible. He follows a path through the forest that comes to the entrance of a cave that is covered with ivy and weeds. He enters the cave, finds it empty , but there is a wreath of flowers left there, he takes the wreath, leaves his scarf, and heads for his own home.
As he arrives at the castle, he hears a bell tolling from the chapel, so slow, so solemn, that it could only be for the death of someone. Now he hurries to the chapel, rushes inside, finds it crowded, but no one takes any notice of him. He enters the gallery "unquestioned and unobserved" where only his noble family members are allowed and finds it empty. Looking out over the chapel he sees an open grave in the center, and both his parents standing against the tomb.
OK, now I am almost certain that I know where this story is going. His parents by the tomb, his just being at war, his love for one of the enemy, no one seeming to notice him in a crowded chapel; I am sure that this guy is dead and he is the only one that doesn't know it. I think, that's why the flowers were left in the cave, the poor girl who fell in love with her enemy left them there because she couldn't come to the funeral and so she put them at the place where she used to meet him. That's why no one noticed him, he's dead. Now somewhere in the story, perhaps soon, perhaps not until the end of the story, our hero will realize he is dead. That's what I'm sure of, and I'm wrong.
It's not him in the grave but it is another of his family members; and his father, Count Rudiger, Count of Frankheim is absolutely convinced that the murderer is his enemy and neighbor Gustavus, Count of Orrenburg. Although Gustavus seems to be the most level headed of anyone in the story, everyone else at Orrenburg is also absolutely convinced that Rudiger poisoned Gustavus' son months earlier. These people never did seem to get along. Rudiger married the girl Gustavus was in love with, Gustavus got the land and money that Rudiger thought would go to him, etc. etc. Therefore the hatred keeps growing between the two neighbors especially after people start dying around them. As the story goes more people get killed on both sides until the final conflict which pretty much destroys just about everybody in the book. Just about but not quite everyone. All because they couldn't "trust" each other.
The story was very interesting and I'm glad that I found out that M. G. Lewis wrote more that just "The Monk". I'll definitely re-read it someday, who knows when. Happy reading.