"Through a window a broken fingernail of moon was visible. It barely illumined the intruder's face, but what Sam could see he didn't like. Two dark eyes, shiny like the green-black carapace of a beetle, flashed at him. The eyes were set deep, each in a squint counterpoised to the other, lurking under a matted shock of black hair. Tangled elf-locks framed high cheek bones and a swarthy complexion... A row of teeth glimmered in the faint moonbeams, a mouthful of blue light. The teeth were perfect, but, unless he was mistaken, they were sharpened to fine dagger points."
Such a hideous, chilling and unconventional description of a favorite childhood fantasy figure seemed like a great start to this very bizarre novel. In the mood for a wicked scare during one of my favorite months of the year, I thought this book was just the ticket. Unfortunately, rather than peeking around corners and jumping at the slightest creak of the house or howl of the wind, I instead felt slightly revolted. Seven-year-old Sam looses a tooth and is surprised by a visit from this androgynous being. Sam will learn that this will be a recurring event throughout his childhood and adolescent years. This noxious and vulgar creature exhibits erratic moods, uses coarse language, changes from male to female and back again, and exploits the angst of a developing young man. All this seems to revolve around Sam's personal experiences, sexual awakenings and frustrations. As the tooth fairy points out to Sam, "This is not a one-way thing, you know. You may think I'm your nightmare, but you in turn are my nightmare. It's your moods that pull me here." The question becomes – is this being real or a manifestation of Sam's imagination during these critical coming-of-age years? An interesting concept, but when put into words and descriptions, it went way over the top for me. It became repetitive and unnerving rather than satisfyingly frightful.
Despite my criticisms, I did find some really good points to this novel. For one, the characters are fairly well developed and memorable. Clive, Terry, Alice and Linda all suffer, along with Sam, from typical teenage concerns, get mixed up in various scrapes – some less innocent than others, and band together for support and camaraderie. Skelton, Sam's psychiatrist throughout this ordeal, is an interesting character with his own "demon", an addiction to alcohol. He may actually be the one to grasp some understanding of Sam's turmoil and the real reason for the presence of the tooth fairy in Sam's life. Also, when not foul, the writing was actually quite exceptional. I think Graham Joyce has a gift of vivid prose that has the potential to be quite gratifying: "The earth under the snow was moist and brown, rich and curranty like a cake beneath a layer of marzipan. Breaking through the outlying trees, he found the woods made anew. Nothing stirred, and all noise from beyond the woods was baffled by the density of snow on the trees. The woods were stunned. It was a moment in closed time, a dream of ecstatic paralysis, a phase of Creation in which the trees waited impatiently to take on color, sound, texture." This passage and others like it are the reason why I will most definitely give this author another try. 2.5 stars go to The Tooth Fairy, simply because overall I found it unsettling and somewhat unresolved in my mind by the end of the book.