I’m honestly not sure what my feelings are on this book. It’s been on my shelf for quite some time, along with the other 3 that I could get my hands on in the series (which are now quite frankly going for silly money on eBay and Amazon). I bought this and the rest, because I enjoy the films and I also enjoyed the novelisations of the films. (As far as I can find, only the first 3 have been novelised.)
There are a couple of things that instantly date this book, which were glaringly obvious - Governor Schwarzenegger being mentioned on the first page and repeated references to Palm Pilots.
I did feel that, much like the films, there were too many characters and underdeveloped characters at that, included in this. I found them quite difficult to track of, and it took me considerably longer to read than I was expecting. For me, the characters in the films stand out more, because they’re easily recognisable - a few of the characters in this, I completely muddled up who was who at certain points, losing my grasp on the storyline.
The storylines were good - there are multiple storylines going on at once, but I do think the whole storyline set in Victorian London, could have been a completely separate book/novella. It had no reason to be included, apart from being referenced, like Dead Reckoning was. I found the inclusion of this past storyline to be quite distracting from the present day storyline, and it didn’t seem to flow with the rest of the story - almost like it had been written by two different people, or added in as an after thought.
The deaths are well described, with some very similar to the deaths in the films. Some were quite horrible to picture in your head, but there were a couple that I couldn’t picture at all. Ultimately, the deaths work better in the films, for obvious reasons.
For me, while I will read the rest of the series, this just didn’t stand out enough for me, compared to the films.